#goatalicious

The Organization came from the mainland with Asarakam to conduct human experiments on the island with the intent to learn how to create living weapons to fight in its war. Now going around snatching up unsuspecting commoners wouldn't go over all that easy. Recruiting them outright isn't easy either. The best way to be able to do whatever you want is to build power and influence that is big enough for you to control an entire population.

Throughout the series we don't get a very concrete sense of politics or geography on the island in the main timeline. We see towns and cities that are rather separated and somewhat self governed but we don't hear anything about any sort of government or ruling body other than the Organization, which oversees the warriors primarily and, as we find out later, Yoma control. The exception to this being Rabona of course, which has never needed the Organization's assistance prior to the infiltration that Clare handles early in the series.

But we do see the ruins that suggest that there was some sort of ruling class on the island at some point. The hideouts that Riful uses are both large castles that are in disrepair.

So if there was a ruling class of some sort, who were they? What happened to them and the people that they ruled?

The Organization took them down, from the inside and outside. Kind of like this:

Suddenly the island and its people have a huge problem that doesn't affect just one group of people: The Yoma. Yoma are not the sort of problem you can just push aside because of politics or affiliations. The average human can't easily kill a Yoma, but one Yoma can easily kill a multitude of humans.

Then an organization comes forward with a solution to combat the Yoma. This group is composed of people with ties to the various governing bodies to band together so that they can handle the Yoma as a united front. They could have a rather nondescript name like “The Organization” that shows that they are not solely aligned with any one country/area.

Now the role of a warrior could be painted in a rather attractive light. A warrior becomes superhumanly strong, lives longer than the average human, and has a necessary role in society that would fight a unique problem. Kind of heroic depending on how you view it. You could offer this solution to future leaders, their families, their knights, etc. with a few successful test subjects to show off you can now recruit. 

There would surely be a high cost from the Organization that would begin to deplete the wealth that these governments/royal families have acquired. As political power is poured into the Organization, these governing bodies begin to mean less and less to both the common people and across the political landscape as a whole.

The Organization wouldn't be above coordinating attacks from Yoma to destabilize any resistant groups. Aaand I wouldn't put it above any warriors with prior political standing to use their new position/power to take out an old enemy or competitor. Or aiding in a plan to infect noble families to justify getting rid of them.

Now having just men as warriors at first makes sense. The time period would probably align best with the armies and generals/knights being men. Though, as we see from the chapters showing the early warriors when Riful meets Isley, Dauf, and Rigardo, women would eventually be phased in for a brief mixed force, then to the main timeline the manga where the warriors are just women.

Since plenty of men would die either as warriors or fighting against the yoma initially, the switch to female warriors would have to be made eventually. This switch gives them power to control the Yoma, warrior, and human population. Effectively minimizing resistance on either front. 

Now while canon does essentially say “it feels sexually good so men can't control themselves/are naturally too strong,” I don't really buy it. Especially given as Helen herself explained that when she surpassed her limits she felt the same arousal. The Organization is more than willing to push untrue narratives if it supports their actions.

Potentially the Organization could have gone a bit overboard on recruitment, many male warriors could've died fighting Yoma. They also could have tried to revive their old political structures or tried to form their own groups, which inevitably the Organization wouldn't want and so they'd have to discreetly be disposed of. And they could influence the public perception of male warriors being too power hungry to help justify getting rid of them as much as possible. 

When it comes to the main timeline, the female warriors of the series are met with uncertainty, fear, and even hostility by the common people of the island, I believe this also is orchestrated. There is a benefit to creating division between warriors and commoners. And while the warriors are physically powerful, they don't have any sort of sway among commoners. Commoners are too wary of warriors and The Organization itself to risk any ties. So there's minimal communication and less risk of any sort of uprising.

To bring back an old Volume 1 line, Clare mentions that she had been trained to play certain roles, namely aristocrats or prostitutes. Now in the case of Rabona, this makes a lot of sense as she has to blend in for this particular mission and kill Yoma. But the skills she was trained in (and supposedly other warriors would be trained in) would make her and any other warrior an excellent tool of surveillance. If warriors weren't just used as a way to kill Yoma, but also to spy on commoners then this would create additional distrust. 

As for acting like an aristocrat, there could potentially still be some new leaders or those who claim to have royal blood. But the current ones would likely have to have close connections with the Organization, so they would serve as a puppet. And having a warrior ready to play a role to spy on them prevents them from plotting in a way that the organization doesn't approve of.

The Awakened Beings from this time the Organization would likely allow some to stay alive not just because they were too powerful, but to have some that could be used to keep the fear among commoners and warriors alike. When Miria, Clare, Helen, and Deneve are sent to hunt down an Awakened Being, they were canonically being sent to what was supposed to be their deaths. Same with the warriors in Pieta.

Speaking of Pieta, this actually brings me into an adjacent theory that a few notable Awakened Beings in the series are not only the most powerful awakened beings and early warriors, but that Isley, Rigaldo, and Riful in particular were royalty. 

”Silver King” Isley,”Empress” Riful “of the West, and “Silver Eyed Lion King” Rigardo are the only Awakened Beings with any sort of titles associated with royalty. 

These titles could still be a reference to their influence as being powerful yoki wise or how they had leadership type roles amongst other Awakened Beings/Yoma… but no other awakened beings share this naming trait, even those who are similar in power, from the same era, or other Abyssals.