The truth was, Blair never really fit in with Theo’s family.
She tried.
For years, she tried.
But no matter what she did, there was always an opinion, a suggestion, or a criticism waiting around the corner. If they bought something, someone had a comment. If they made a parenting decision, someone had advice. If they set a boundary, someone questioned it.
At first, Theo brushed it off. That’s just how his parents were.
But when Blair became pregnant with Teddy and Archie, everything intensified.
What should have been one of the happiest times in their lives became exhausting. Every decision felt like it belonged to someone else. Theo’s parents constantly inserted themselves into conversations about the babies, their home, and their future. They weren’t trying to be malicious—they genuinely believed they knew best—but Blair was tired of being treated like a child in her own life.
The breaking point came when a simple conversation about the twins turned into another lecture about what they should and shouldn’t be doing.
For the first time, Theo didn’t defend his parents.
He defended Blair.
That conversation led to an argument, and the argument led to weeks of tension.
Around the same time, Theo was offered a Junior Teacher position at a prestigious private school in West Arbor. The offer came with a significant teacher bonus, higher pay, and opportunities he never would have had if he stayed.
For the first time, leaving felt possible.
So they did.
Not out of spite.
Not to punish anyone.
But because they needed space.
A month before the twins were born, they packed up their lives, loaded Hayley and the dog into the car, arranged transportation for Orion, and left.
The fallout with Theo’s parents wasn’t explosive. It was worse, especially with his sister.
It was quiet.
Phone calls became less frequent. Visits stopped. Holidays became awkward. Eventually, the distance became permanent.
And honestly?
Blair didn’t miss it.
For the first time in years, she could make decisions without feeling judged.
In West Arbor, life wasn’t perfect. Some neighbors were wonderful. Others were nosy. Some people became close friends. Others never bothered to learn their names.
But that was normal.
That was balance.
Theo thrived at his new school. Hayley made friends. Orion settled into his new pasture. And when Teddy Oliver and Archie Elliot were born, they entered a life that felt peaceful rather than crowded.
Looking back years later, Blair never regretted leaving.
Not because she hated Theo’s family.
But because she finally understood that loving someone doesn’t mean giving them unlimited access to your life.
Sometimes the healthiest thing you can do is create distance, build your own home, and let your family become exactly what you want it to be
