"Take it like a good girl and stop whining." Lip demanded as you were seated on Carmy's cock. You stifled a whimper, pouting up at Lip for a moment.

Carmy gently rested his arms around you as Lip walked away - he was trying to get some work done, and you had been a dirty little tease all damn day. Distracting him, distracting Carmy. Cockwarming and no moving was your punishment. Tears formed in your eyes, ruining the pretty makeup look you'd done just for your boyfriends.

"Oh, bunny, don't cry, 's okay sweetheart." Carmy muttered softly, gently kissing at your neck while he held you still. "Y're doin' s'good, baby. Takin' me so, so well."

As Carmy continued to praise you, and give you ever so gentle movements to give you a small amount of pleasure, Lip eventually overheard. You didn't notice him at first, until he cleared his throat, staring at the pair of you. Carmy gave him an innocent smile.

"Stop until she does what I’m telling her to." He grunted. "For fucks sake, Bear, this is supposed to be a punishment."

"I-I know but-" Carmy protested, then smushed your face in his hand, making you look up at Lip. "Look how cute she is! How could you wanna punish 'er, huh?"

Lip grabbed the bridge of his nose, letting out a sigh. "If you keep this shit up, she'll never learn to take punishment, dude."

"I can't help it!" Carmy whined.

"Y're fuckin' whipped, Bear." Lip commented, then looked at you. "No cumming til I'm done, can you at least do that, bunny?"

You giggled a little, and nodded. At least Carmy always helped you somewhat win Lip over.

"c-carmy?" you whimper, and suddenly your aching cunt is empty, and a sharp sting blossoms heat inside you as lip slaps your inner thigh. "no! come on, i-i was doing so good," you whine out, hands reaching blindly for one of the two men that were somewhere near the foot of your bed.

"she's been good man, come on," carmen says. he soothes your reddining skin with gentle kisses before lapping at you. his soft grunts send vibrations through your clit as his nose bumps it, messily making out with your pussy.

you huff petulantly as carmen is pulled back from you, a whimper and a whispered 'what the fuck!' tipping you off that lip had grabbed him by the curls to yank him away. "she's a smart girl," lip says, then the two fall silent.

you peek from under your blindfold, just trying to get your bearing a little. you need the upper hand here. but lip catches you, he crowds into your space, caging you in below his body.

"aw, that's cute you think you can cheat y'way outta this," he scoffs. "carm, light a cig."

you look up at lip with wide eyes as he grabs your hips, flipping you over until your ass is in the air and your cheek is pressed to the pillow. he fits the blindfold snugly over your eyes, ignoring your soft whines and tears of frustration. you just need the release they're prolonging, your body red hot from desire.

you feel heat next to your face, feel a soft kiss to your swollen lips, and carmen whispers, "he's gonna let you cum again baby, don' cry, yeah?" his gentle hand rubs your back for a moment before disappearing.

someone's dick presses inside you shortly after, thrusting in to the hilt in one go. you sigh then, the ache in your core placated by the rough pace he sets.

To your surprise, Lip is the one that needs more convincing. Not that you are entirely surprised, but Carmy was more agreeable to the idea than you thought he would be.

You and Lip met Carmy through Richie.

Richie had made a scene when he first met Lip about him being Carmy. It was one of those bizarre moments you only saw online with celebrities that you could swear were the same person. Like Natalie Portman and Kiera Knightley, where they look so similar, you convince yourself they could be related.

Thankfully, the Gallagher and Berzatto family lines don't overlap at all. The three of you had been incredibly thorough in your search to ensure there were no relations. It took two outside opinions to convince Lip and four to convince Carmy. The original three look overs were enough for you, but the boys weren't as trusting as you were.

You knew Richie through Tiff, who you knew from high school. Tiffany had never mentioned Carmy when she met Lip the few times she had, and maybe she didn't think it was noteworthy. Maybe she didn't see it or didn't want to talk about her ex's family.

Nevertheless, Carmy was possibly the best introduction to your and Lip's lives.

The sharing took some getting used to for the both of them, surprising given neither one of them was an only child. But everyone has a learning curve.

At first, it was just petty bickering and possessive movements. Eventually, it all culminated into a snap of tension that was incredibly aggressive. What had originally started as a first fight somehow ended with you between both of them, hot mouths biting and kissing at your skin.

That was one of the few times you got to share a bed with them in that context. Which... Was fine. But you wanted more.

Not to say you didn't like when one of them would watch, either waiting for his turn or getting off by himself. But you wanted them to enjoy each other too. It didn't seem fair that only you got to enjoy both of them in a one-way transaction of all the affection.

You had noticed the more obvious lingering looks Carmy gave Lip after giving you a kiss goodbye or when Lip kissed your forehead when he said hello. Lip was a bit better at hiding his yearning, keeping lingering looks and touches to sporadic moments, always hiding it when no one's watching.

Maybe you shouldn't have been surprised Carmy agreed so easily....

Carmy was not only eager to please you, but to please Lip as well. You saw how he flourished under Lip's praise, preening for it whenever he could. Almost asking for it whenever he did something he thought Lip would like.

So, being used as a personal fleshlight seemed like the obvious thing for him to agree to. That and the fact you would be riding him, so he had some form of gratification.

Lip was a little more hesitant to the idea. He blew you off before coming back later and asking questions. Once you clearly explained and helped him figure out what he would be comfortable with, Lip agreed happily.

Which is how you ended up sitting on Carmy's lap, grinding like two teenagers in the middle of the bed. Lip waited by the doorway, watching you rub your bare cunt over the bulge of Carmy's boxer briefs. The stain of both your arousal is dark in the middle of the fabric. The moans and whines being made by both of you are being traded in your mouths like smoke.

When you reach down to the waistband of Carmy's underwear, Lip removes his own boxers. Carmy helps you shuffle his boxers down his thighs so his cock can fall back against his stomach. Settling yourself against his hips, letting him rest against you as you coax him to lie back.

Carmy is quick to listen, laying down until his head falls back against the edge of the bed. You can't help but watch as Lip walks to Carmy's side, bringing his hand to cradle his face. Carmy needs no prompting when Lip brushes his thumb over his lips and takes Lip's thumb into his mouth.

With Carmy distracted, you slip your hand around his length and lift your hips up before slowly sinking down. Carmy groans around Lip's thumb once you're fully seated on his cock, bucking up a little into you.

"Alright, bear.." Lip whispers, slipping his thumb out of his mouth. Carmy is eager to listen, opening his mouth wide as Lip positions himself in front of his mouth.

The sight of Lip slowly thrusting into Carmy's mouth makes you clench around Carmy. This results in a chain of Carmy groaning around Lip's length, his throat contracting around him and making Lip swear under his breath. One of Carmy's legs comes up, jostling you on his lap, so you have to rest your hands flat against his chest for support. The new angle is deep and has your clit drag delightfully against his happy trail.

The star of your show is watching Lip pull back out before thrusting in, watching the imprint in his throat each time. You almost forget your role in this agreement until Carmy is grabbing for your waist. At first, you think it's his way of telling you it's too much, but the three taps never come. Instead, he weakly lifts you up before sitting you back down.

When you don't get the hint the first time, you hear Carmy huff before lifting his other leg, planting his feet on the mattress so he can thrust up into you. Whatever noises you could have made are swallowed by Lip as he kisses you roughly, snapping his hips into Carmy's mouth.

The room is filled with the sound of whining and skin against skin. Carmy sneaks his hand between both of you, rubbing gently at your clit. You can tell Carmy is near his own end, the way his thrusting has become more sporadic, his length twitching inside of you.

You're panting heavily against Lip's mouth when you feel Carmy come inside you. With a few more tight circles of his thumb, you feel the tension in your stomach snap, walls clenching tightly around Carmy. With both of you satisfied, Lip wastes no time chasing his own release, bringing his hands to hold Carmy's head still as he thrusts into his mouth. Carmy's whining and groaning are audible even around Lip, making him grunt softly until he stills. You watch, catching your breath, as Lip grinds softly into Carmy's mouth before pulling out.

Carmy inhales sharply, chest rising and falling as he tries to catch his breath. Lip is just as disheveled, breathing heavily as he sits down on the edge of the bed, turning to kiss you quickly before settling back down.

What Carmy does next shocks you.

With Lip sitting on the edge of the bed, he's easier for Carmy to reach. His movements are jarring as he sits up and reaches for Lip's cheek. Carmy is quick to bring his mouth to Lip's, licking into his mouth. Lip grunts out of surprise before he groans at the taste on Carmy's tongue, quickly taking over the kiss. You watch, mouth agape, as Lip licks at Carmy's mouth as if he can't get enough.

It feels like they go on for hours before Carmy pulls away to catch his breath. Carmy looks dazed as he pants softly, turning back to look at you instead of Lip.

Lip pants heavily before he turns to face you with a cocky grin.

FOR THE SAPPY PART

@gallaghersgal - maggie my beloved, my first mutual and the person who pushed me into writing. I love you sm and I wanna js thank u for getting me into this amazing community and encouraging me to put myself out there on here

@mouseymilkovich - my lovely mouse, I can’t express how grateful I am to have you as a friend whose always there for me both abt life and fics. Not to mention lowkey parenting me when needed.

@carmenberzattosgf - olive my dear thanks for always filling me in on the lore and supplying the immense amount of JAW pics my heart desire. Not forgetting your amazing chem tutoring skills.

@dearpyramus - Cass my favorite dad!carmy connoisseur who will listen to anything I have to say abt him and always coming opening stupid little TikTok’s I send that relate to fics and always comes to my inbox to drop the cutest moments.

@saltnsugarbear - Cas my other tumblr parent and my favorite person to talk abt a bunch of shows with. Also my fav team Logan fan and fellow tvdu enthusiast who created heretic!lip with me. I love u sm for feeding my Rafe Cameron addiction whenever u send me fics.

@ariiiloves - I know we just started talking not too long ago but ever since we became mutuals I’ve enjoyed every conversation we’ve and your reblogs never fail to make me smile

@carmybrainworms - wormy it’s been a minute but i always find myself going back to your fics and I truly love your open vibes and tysm for being my ny twin

Being roommates with two attractive guys was difficult enough as it was— you guys had to lay out ground rules. Basically it boiled down to no sex with said roommates, it was that simple.

As you sat on the couch, staring off into space, while Carmy was over in the kitchen cooking dinner for the three of you, you heard him speak up.

"If you keep looking at me like that, I'll forget we have rules," He said.

Before you could respond, you heard Lip chuckling as he came out of his room. "Yknow, I said the same thing to 'er earlier when I was fixing the faucet."

You blushed, Carmy smirked.

That was the end of the conversation until after dinner, when all three of you were on the couch together, trying to watch a movie. But their words from earlier rang in your head.

"Yknow, we could... forget the rules for one night," You mumbled, causing both guys to look at you— Carmy from the other end of the couch, and Lip from his chair.

"Is that really a good idea?" Carmy asked softly.

"Maybe if we just get out the sexual tension, it won't be there anymore," Lip added with a grin before he got up. He held his hand out to you, and as you got up, he looked at Carmy. "You in or you out, Bear?"

Well, he was in, because you all went to Lip's room, and clothes were discarded just about everywhere. You were across the bed on all fours, Carmy behind you and Lip in front of you.

"Fuck, knew she'd be fuckin' good at this," Lip grunted as you took him down your throat.

Carmy was barely able to speak, holding your hips and rutting into you with reckless abandon. He was making illegible noises, Lip figured it'd been a little bit since he'd been with anybody.

"Look at'cha, Bear, this pretty little thing's made you a mess," Lip teased between moans.