How would carmy react to finding out his gf used to sleep with mikey (pretend mikey is still alive in this version🤞)
okay no bc having had a thing with mikey while carmy was gone...you're a couple years younger than carmy but nothing happened between you and mikey until you were old enough ofc. i think maybe you drift apart due to wanting different things from each other and ultimately you both just kind of push all those feelings back and move on.
when carmy comes back it's like you see some of his brother in him but you still see him as his own person at the same time. they have a lot of similarities in good and bad ways but you just fall for those traits all over again.
i feel like carmy pieces it together himself for the most part but doesn't want to believe it. maybe you and mikey have lingering feelings for each other, maybe he just sees the way you look at each other and hears the inside jokes. i think mikey probably says something really off-color to you in his presence and it makes the wheels really turn in carmy's head. it inevitably causes a fight and mikey finally confirms his buried suspicions.
and carmy doesn't know how to feel, because he knows he shouldn't be pissed, because it has nothing to do with him, but he is. he's so fucking mad. because how could you fuck his brother (even though that's something he has no right to be mad about because you hadn't even dreamed of seeing each other at that time)? how could you keep it from him for so long? and how could you still joke about it and give each other these little knowing looks like you had never gotten over each other?
it fucks him up for a while but i feel like he gets over it. he's just extra cautious around mikey in case big bro decides to turn into mr. takeyabitch.











