Ok, I’ve done enough playthroughs of Detroit become human so my final thoughts on this. Some spoilers for a 3 year old game lmao.
Some things I didn’t like
- Markus story moves too fast and him going from carer to Robo MLK was too fast and it made little sense why the older androids just went along with him.
- the whole thing taking in place in like a week is strange
-Everyone moved too slow and stiff, got annoying sometimes. Particularly when Markus needs to find Jericho
-Why wasn’t calling the police an option if Kara truly though Alice was human?
-Why can an unemployed slob living in a shithole afford a family of robots to batter? I get he’s taking out loans but it makes no sense to me.
-Hank goes from Android hater to supporter too fast
-I know it’s to have that ‘imitation krabs’ moment, but hank could have just asked the real connor to convert deviants, instead of asking questions that could be uploaded from memory.
-The Connor was a planned deviant all along story makes no sense. Also didn’t like that his deviant scene could only be brought on by Markus or North instead of Hank. And it’s rushed as all hell.
-why would connor be upset at not being unique? Surely he’d be aware.
-Androids have a few repeated models with the same faces sold by the millions but can disguise themselves to get into Canada? Just have a list of the faces.
-Sumo looks so bad graphics wise, like it’s odd cos everything else looks so good
-The main female character being put into the abusive situations was uncomfortable.
-I felt deviancy wasn’t really explained very well and left too ambiguous. Which as the major plot point really irked me.
-Not really game related but the Gavin/RK900 shipping really baffles me. One get’s barely any screen time and zero dialogue in one end credit scene and the other is a bland shitty person who gets about 2 minutes of conversation. Like where did this come from?
- Alice android reveal ruined Kara’s whole story for me, like so much of what you do is pointless and especially fucking annoying in a game that is to be replayed. Her being in ‘denial’ about it felt weak and luther repeatedly tired to tell her. This kid robot has also sold so well that it’s lowered birth rates and she still never noticed? You could see the twist coming early on as well.
-Humans, aside from Carl and Hank, are just painted as straight bad guys. Yeah they treat their Androids like servants and replace them but they are supposed to be appliances. It’s like that Sid toy story meme how the fuck are they supposed to know those fuckers were alive? They shouldn’t be. Deviants are killing people so it’s not like the fear is totally unwarranted. Could have seen more from the human’s side, like Cyberlife is obviously dodgy, maybe humans wouldn’t so quick to embrace these ‘alive’ machines if they distrusted cyberlife
-The android rights demands were odd too, like owning property, reproduction and compensation for work. Androids will never die and the unemployment rate is at 40%, how’s that meant to even work?
-The fucking robo auschwitz section. It’s so tone deaf it’s actually comical. Someone really sat down and thought this was a good idea.
-The ham fisted revolution in general. Other people have explained this better than me, but again, it’s cringeworthy I found it more funny than anything. Really thought an ‘I have a dream’ option was coming up.
-North and Markus lovestory felt forced as all hell. I pissed her off constantly but it took little to raise her to near lover status. I actually don’t mind her ‘kill all humans’ mindset, she has her reasons, but the lover thing was bleh.
-Same with Josh, he was hostile on one of my playthroughs but nothing happened? He supported me anyway? Wasted character.
-The way most people in Jericho, new and old members, just follow Markus without question made it feel more like a cult at times. Also wtf was with Lucy.
-David cage in general tbh.
-WHY CAN’T WE SKIP SCENES AND REPLAY CHAPTERS FROM CERTAIN POINTS FUCKING HELL. I ended up just killing Kara to speed up replays, she adds nothing to the main plot anyway.
-Choices actually mattered, first for me in any game I’ve played. Permadeath is neat. And although it is handled poorly a lot of the time, controlling a whole revolution is kind of cool. Getting to fail by just dicking about.
-Connor and Hanks’ storyline is by far the best, best gameplay with the investigations and they play off each other well. And you can be an absolute savage arsehole if you want. Connor was my favourite, I liked his awkward deviant/cold machine personality and his less linear story. Think the most effort went in his storyline and it’s the only one with humour.
-The actors all did very well, despite the shitty writing at points.
-Cool scene in the dump with markus.
-Some really nice moments, like the carousel scene.
-We finally hear Sailor mouth Mr Krabs, probably my favourite thing about the game.
-Looks amazing, best facial features in any game i’ve played, probably even better than resi2
-I liked the futuristic yet familiar setting. There are autonomous cars and androids but everything else is mostly like present day. Weird ebooks everywhere is a bit dumb though.
-Some pretty tense scenes, mostly in Kara’s story. That motorway scene was a highlight. Bit less so when you know Alice is an android but whatever.
-Really good soundtrack as well, underrated. I don’t remember much of Markus's tbh,aside from his singing, but Kara and Connor had some great themes that I’ve had on repeat the past week.
-I don’t like American accents usually but connors is very soothing.
-I like these Ai stories in general, so I’ll have a soft spot for it even if it could have been so much better. Basically ‘makes no damn sense, compels me though’.
Overall, it was fun and entertaining, but felt like it could have been so much better. Would have liked some DLC of connor and hank investigating crimes as that was the highlight but with an open ended game I guess you can’t really do that.