actual good-faith question: on what do you base your view that lgbt fans who vehemently take issue with elements of content featuring lgbt themes are engaging in deliberate slandering campaigns instead of just being angry
No one is deliberately starting slander campaigns but peopleās behavior and intentions spread.
Steven Universe, one of cartoonnetworksĀ most ambitious, representative, and powerful shows has been the WORST contender for it.
And I hate to keep usingĀ SU to talk about itĀ because things like Voltron, Dream Daddy, etc. also got hit with it but I always come back to SU because itās a show for kids that has been ruined and is now just SCRAPPING to survive because of peopleās extreme need to tear LGBT content apart.
Steven Universe has been GREAT for kids, Iāve seen kids talk about the characters, the relationships, the story, their emotions, EVERYTHING on a level that -- as a kid -- I NEVER got.Ā
So itās INFURIATING to me, when people feel the NEED to talk about the little problems, CONSTANTLY. Criticizing the art is one thing, 10k, to 20k+ note long posts about how Steven Universe is absolute shit because their QUEER TEAM + GROUP OF ARTISTS isntĀ consistent with their storyboard style is EXTREME, and itās not just the LGBT community, of course it isnāt, you have meatheads on youtube taking 800 hours just to rant about Steven Universe and how bad it is, how hard its trying, how shitty and annoying the characters are, when in 2013-2014, everyone was ALL OVER IT!Ā
Then, now Iām seeing people justify this behavior with how the LGBT representation wasnātĀ āgood enoughā, how one of the artists deserved to get run off by the fandom for her āqueer baitingā or āart directionā, how Lapidot was bad because it was normal or silly, I saw some people talking about how Ruby and Sapphires relationship was unhealthy, the MAIN consistent lesbian pair.
Why does LGBT/POC content have to be PERFECT to be GOOD.Ā Other cartoons sit on cartoonnetwork or disney or nick just fine and donāt get this much BACKLASH, and they all have pretty much the same formulas, protagonists and love interests, background characters and background romances.
Not once have I asked people to stop criticizing, Iāve asked people stop normalizing this widespread behavior of taking content and doing everything in their power to find EVERY SMALL THING wrong with it before they just ENJOY it.
I wouldnāt say any of these show are perfect or free from peopleās anger, nothing is.Ā
But when ADULTS (everyone Iāve talked to has been between 18-20+ tonight??) decide they will do everything in their power to TEAR the opportunity of representation away from kids just because of some mistakes, some art discrepancies, or how the plot isnāt going how they want or some shit, itās DAMAGING. It ruins the chance for SUCCESSORS to follow, it ruins the chance for our public networks to sprout.
And it has nothing to do with being a coward, it has more to do with how the people up top will refuse to greenlight anything even similar or better than Steven Universe again, how writers will conform their writing and tip toe to avoid hitting anyone, how the SIGHT of a POC creator/character will immediately turn off stations/editors because people. canāt handle it.Ā
Its dangerous, itās risky, and if its not just right it will fail.Ā
That shouldnāt be the case, I want more kids to be happy and sing songs and be accepting of themselves because thatās the surface of what a cartoon is showing to them rather than the concepts grown folk have decided itās okay to politicize and dictate for them.
Itās a slandering campaign when thereās visible damage and itās widespread, people should be more privy to talk about the good things than the bad things if the bad things arenāt overwhelming or glaring, thatās all I ask. Please be as close to as easy on LGBT/POC content as you would be on an Avengers movie or fuckin Supernatural.