Do you think true crime dehumanises the victims while glorifying the perpetrators?
Fuck yeah it generally does. I have read a few stories from families of victims that describe the constant harassment they’ve faced regarding their deceased family member’s case, people trying to get information and by way of that, forcing them to relive their worst memories. I think many true crime enjoyers forget that these are real people with real lives and real identities. It’s never appropriate to harass a victim’s surviving family for details.
I do think there is a responsible way to report on true crime but ultimately it should be up to the victim’s families on whether or not the story is open for discussion. Also I have a hard time with people profiting off true crime, I think profits should be donated directly to surviving families or to charitable orgs dedicated to violent crime prevention.
Ultimately, I do consume a lot of true crime content but I don’t like to call myself a true crime fan. My interest stems from having studied psychology with specific interests in trauma, criminality, and antisocial behavior. If I ever pursue graduate education in society, I want to study the psychology of violent crime and it’s relationship to trauma. So typically, I’m pursing journalistic sources or content produced by the actual families of victims. Academic research journals are also good, but less accessible. Some examples of productions I feel good about recommending:
Voices for Justice podcast by Sarah Turney, covering her sister’s disappearance and her pursuit for justice. Sarah Turney is also making good content on tiktok and she is actively working to help other surviving family members pursue their own justice.
Missing and Murdered: Finding Cleo - podcast by an investigative journalist helping a family find a lost member. This series especially made me aware of the rampant violence toward indigenous women and the lack of investigation into these crimes. Also goes into the consequences of the separation of indigenous families and Canada’s residential school system.
Cold, Season 1 - another investigative journalist podcast covering the disappearance of Susan Powell and the eventual murder/suicide committed by her husband. MASSIVE trigger warning for violence against children. Susan’s story will probably always haunt me, because there’s no end to it. One of my greatest hopes is that one day, her family will have closure.
I wish I could think of more recs offhand, but I firmly believe these three do a fantastic job of maintaining the humanity of their victims and never glorify the perpetrator. Apologies for the long-winded info dump, this is something I could talk about for hours.