S.H.I.E.L.D.âs nonsense.
Director Nicholas Joseph Fury is a spy, heâs the spy, his secrets have secrets, and the man isnât just holding his cards close to the chest, heâs got an entire second deck.
Which makes the choices he take in Iron Man 2 really aggravating.Â
Though it isnât outright stated, it is heavily implied that S.H.I.E.L.D., or at least Fury, was aware for a good amount of time that Tony was suffering from Palladium Poisoning. This implication comes from their little âstop gapâ formula of lithium dioxide (and Iâll get to that injection in a moment).
Fury tells Tony that âYou have become a problem, one that I have to deal withâ which implies that at least for a while Tony was under someone elseâs jurisdiction as S.H.I.E.L.D. monitors all potential threats, and now for whatever reason, it is Furyâs turn to put up with him.
He then has Natasha inject the lithium dioxide into Tony without consent, without knowledge, and without proof that it will actually help him.
Then tell Tony that theyâve done what they can, Tony has to get off his ass and cure himself.
As though Tony hasnât been trying to do that for months now.
All of this after it has been revealed to him that Pepperâs secretary -a person who is consistently in very close quarters and communication with Pepper- is a S.H.I.E.L.D. spy.
Tony is already dealing with the stress of a closely impending death, the stress of what happened the night before at his birthday party, the stress of keeping all of this hidden from his nearest and dearest, and now this bullshit had been thrown onto his lap.
If I understand the psychology of the moment correctly, Fury waited until one of the last possible moments to give Tony the stop gap, so as to engender feelings of gratitude and obligation in Tony as they âsavedâ him in his time of most need. In this moment, Tony is extremely emotionally and mentally vulnerable, and Fury has no problem taking advantage of that.
Tony Stark is a very dangerous man, but he has proven to be loyal to those he feels deserves it, so why wouldnât Fury try to force through a little of that loyalty to himself, through âsavingâ Tonyâs life?
I doubt Fury thought twice.
Without gaining Tonyâs consent, without fully informing him of what it was, what it did, without providing evidence that it could even help him, Fury has Natasha stab a needle into Tonyâs neck.
While I am no expert, I do believe that can qualify as an unwanted medical intrusion, maybe even an unwanted body modification.
Frankly, I think Tonyâs had far more than enough of those from Afghanistan.
And by forcing it on him, Fury is showing he has little to no respect for Tonyâs body or personhood.
As the Director of one of the shadiest super spy organisations on the planet, Fury has become used to seeing people as tools and pieces, to be used and moved as he sees fit.
And Tony, as brilliant and intelligent and innovative as he is, is simply a slightly more useful tool to use and piece to move.
After all, he didnât listen when Tony said no.
Fury then forces Tony into some measure of house arrest, once more doing something to J.A.R.V.I.S., and then tells Tony that everything heâs done so far to try and save himself is pointless, and he needs to hurry up and get to work and prove himself to be as clever as Howard always said Tony was.
Okay, not only brushing aside all the effort Tony has been making, but bringing in the dead man.
As will become quickly apparent on my tumblr, I am in no way fond of Howard Stark. The man was, at best, horribly neglectful towards his child. At worst, Howard was outright abusive, and not necessarily physically abusive (though he very much is so in comics) but certainly verbally abusive. Itâs cannon that Howard often traveled to search for Steve, so he wouldnât be with his wife and child for at least a couple months, so he was likely dismissive of Tony, and Tony confirms that Howard never even told Tony he liked him.
Do not try and defend this man to me.
But Fury brings him up to Tony.
This has several reasons why.
1) It is a subtle comparison between the two men, implying that Fury thinks one may be better than the other, so Tony feels the need to prove himself to be himself, and not his fatherâs shadow.
2) It brings up memories of Tony going to great lengths to prove himself to Howard, and perhaps be praised or rewarded, and Fury is telling him about how Howard was constantly raving about his son.
3) It brings up the ache Tony felt growing up and not being enough for Howard, a man who was always going on about Steve Rogers, and wouldnât it be grand to finally show Howard how great he is?
Fury does not bring up Howard to be kind to Tony, to build a rapport with Tony, to remind Tony of a past kindly missed.
No, Fury brings up Howard to push Tony into getting to work.
Because Tony Stark is a useful tool.
And Coulsonâs disregard for Tony physical and mental state?
âIf you try to escape, or play any sort of games with me, I will taze you and watch âSupernannyâ while you drool into the carpet.â
Coulson âWe need you.â
Tony âMore than you know.â
Coulson âNot that much.â
Yeah, I can see how much you care for Tony, Coulson.
Now, letâs move to Furyâs little power play, shall we?
Tony is either taken or directed to a bunker-like location; just from the glances we see, I get major military vibes from the place. He is left in a room with a couple of agents who have no interest in talking to him, and a folder about the Avengers Initiative left on the table in front of him.
It is obviously bait, obviously left to garner Tonyâs interest, especially as Tony twice now, has said no.
Yet when Tony tries to read the file, Fury âsuddenlyâ appears out of nowhere and tells him he doesnât deserve to.
When Tony is finally considering that, maybe yes he could work with a team, he is told no, we donât trust you.
Natashaâs personality profile is read, and we get to that line. That cursed line that taints so many future reactions to Tony.
Iron Man yes, Tony Stark not recommended.
I have heard the theory that Natasha wrote up two profiles for Tony, and that one is just for the purpose of forcing Tony to work harder, be better, to prove himself worthy of being an Avenger in a way that gives S.H.I.E.L.D. a measure of control over him, and I feel it has merit, but we havenât received any proof of this to my knowledge, which leads me to think that Natasha actually believes that of Tony.
And itâs obvious that Tony believes that of himself too.
His defences of his actions are half-hearted, almost joking. He doesnât just get up and leave, because he doesnât feel that they are wrong.
And Fury and Natasha take advantage of this in the future, so Iâm not just seeing things.
In the end, Fury âcompromisesâ and offers Tony a position as a consultant.
Tony is one of the most intelligent men on the planet. The sheer potential that can come from his thoughts and ideas is so beyond staggering. Tony really isnât wrong when he tells Fury that S.H.I.E.L.D. couldnât afford him; Tonyâs time really is worth more than most can pay.
Yet Tony feels the tugs of gratitude and obligation, planted by Furyâs âlife-savingâ actions, and agrees to waive the fee in exchange for a favour.
For a man like Fury, pushing Stern into the position of having to award Tony a medal is beyond easy.
And he gets potential years of free consultation from a mind of near-no-peer.
To paraphrase Thanos, these scales do not balance.