Hunter Doohanâs acting in Wednesday deserves all the love
I donât think people talk enough about just how insanely good Hunter Doohan is in this show. From the very first season he proved it â the way he could make us fall for the soft, sweet boy-next-door Tyler, only to rip the ground out from under us with the Hyde reveal. It didnât feel like a âplot twist,â it felt like we had been watching two completely different characters, and yet it was all him. That ability to seamlessly switch between roles is rare, and Hunter makes it look effortless.
And what makes it even more mind-blowing is how he does that slide between Tyler and the Hyde. Itâs not a hard cut â itâs a gradual shift, sometimes happening in a single scene, even in a single expression. You watch the light in his eyes flicker into something darker, the warmth drain into menace, the softness harden into cruelty. And then, sometimes, just as quickly, he slides back, leaving you shaken because you donât even know which side you were just looking at. That kind of control over his performance is pure artistry.
Season 2 though? Heâs on a whole new level. What gets me is how much he communicates without even speaking. You can literally watch the shift happen in his face â the smallest flicker of fear, anger, longing, or resignation. Itâs like he has this internal war constantly burning inside him, and somehow Hunter lets us see both sides at once.
Thereâs one scene I cannot stop rewatching (and trust me, Iâve seen it more times than I should admitâŚ. Actually probably all the scenes with Tyler in season two.): when he stages the threat against Enid just to keep Wednesday there (and donât even try to tell me that he didnât just do it to keep her there for even just a second longer). Because those few seconds before he even says a word â itâs all right there. The desperation, the calculation, the quiet plea. You see a boy whoâs breaking and reaching out, even if he canât do it openly. Who wants to keep Wednesday there, even if just for another moment. That kind of layered acting? Itâs the stuff that leaves you breathless.
And then, of course, thereâs the chemistry. You canât deny it. Hunter leans into that unspoken tension with Wednesday in a way that makes every look, every silence feel heavy. Itâs not just attraction â itâs recognition. Two people who are mirrors in the worst and best ways. And even when nothing physical happens, it feels like something just did. Thatâs how much weight he carries in the quiet moments.
What I find the most incredible is how he balances contradictions. Tyler is dangerous but vulnerable. Controlled but yearning. Shattered but still reaching for connection. On paper he couldâve been just another tragic villain, but Hunter gives him depth. He makes us care. He makes us feel the conflict, the push and pull, the ache of someone who never really had a chance.
At the end of the day, Wednesday wouldnât hit the same without him. The writers gave us the outline of Tyler, but Hunter Doohan breathed life into him. He turned him into a character whoâs messy, complicated, heartbreaking, and unforgettable. Thatâs not just good acting. Thatâs the kind of acting that stays with you â the kind you canât stop thinking about long after the episode ends.
At the end of the day, Tyler isnât unforgettable just because of the writing or the twist. Heâs unforgettable because Hunter Doohan gave him life, depth, and tragedy. He makes us hurt for him, fear him, and still be drawn to him â sometimes all in the same scene. Thatâs rare. Thatâs talent.
Hunter Doohan truly gave us one of the most haunting, heartbreaking, and electric performances in the series. And honestly? I canât wait to see where he takes Tyler next.










