ââTerrible Crimeâ - Judge,â Toronto Star. April 19, 1917. Page 5.
----
âThis is one of the most terrible crimes I have ever heard of,â commented Judge Coastworth in the County Criminal Court yesterday after Clarence Ludgate, aged 21, ex-cashier of the C.N.R. and Henry Richmond, aged 19, pleaded guilty to a charge of stealing four rings from Mrs. Catherine I. Skinner, and âdid use personal violence and did strike her at the same time, being armed with an offensive weapon. I will remand Ludgate and Richmond one week to the case over,â stated Judge Coastworth at the conclusion of the case. It was remembered that Ludgate and Richmond entered Mrs. Skinnerâs apartments at the Queenâs Court Apartments, Jarvis Street, on the morning of March 21, on the pretext that they they were telephone inspectors. On gaining admittance to Mrs. Skinnerâs apartments Ludgate grabbed Mrs. Skinner and held her arms, while Richmond put his fingers down her throat to prevent her from crying out. One of them grabbed four rings from her hand and after they threatened that she would be shot if she attempted to communicate with the police.
On the stand Mrs. Skinner was still showing serious nervousness from the way she was treated. Mrs. Skinner told her story with much effort.
William A. Menton, who defended Ludgate, and Harcourt Ferguson, acting for Richmond, pleaded that the boys were young and had made a mistake, and to send them to Kingston Penitentiary would ruin their after life.
âIt is one of the worst cases I ever heard of,â commented Judge Coatsworth.
âThey told her they were sorry,â stated Mr. Menton, âand are willing to make full restitution.
âA man that holds a woman and lets another man handle her like Mrs. Skinner was subjected need not come here and say he is sorry,â stated the Judge. âMrs. Skinner will not get over this for many years.â
âLudgate is only a boy: give him a chance. He is willing to make amends,â pleaded Mr. Menton.
âI am not going to try and smooth over the seriousness of this case,â said Mr. Ferguson, speaking for Richmond. âOne would almost think that he had been steeping himself in Nick Carterâs dime novels. His father told me the cause of his downfall is frequenting poolrooms. If you send them to the penitentiary, it will ruin their lives and make criminals out of them.â
âThey have got to be dealt with severely,â stated the court.
âTheir weakness is probably due to drugs or insanity,â stated Mr. Ferguson.
âI cannot help that, it is too serious to pass over,â said the judge.
âI feel they should be punished,â stated Mr. Menton, âbut to send them to the penitentiary would ruin them for life.â
âI will think it over carefully,â stated his Honor, âand I will remand them to jail for a week.â
Both boysâ parents were present in court.
[AL: Both men did go to the penitentiary after all.]