evanslily replied to your post: Rewatching Gilmore Girls and pretty sure Jess was...
Doesn’t Jess mention later that it was Shane though? When Luke confronts him about it and Jess says it was Shane and that he didn’t shove her in the closet, she jumped in on her own. I’m pretty sure it was just a continuity issue.
Oh I am 200% positive it is a continuity error but this rewatch I am filling as many plot holes with head canon that I can. Also thought that maybe he lied and said it was Shane because Luke would not be okay with him cheating. Jess and Shane don’t seem like they would care if Luke caught them upstairs.










