SURPRISE matt sturniolo x reader
summary. . . shower sex with matt turns into your first introduction with his brothers turns into matt proving himself, however that looks like.
warnings. . . mdni, smut, shower sex, pnv, some clit & nipple play, heavily implied f receiving oral towards the end, not proofread, over 2.7k words
des speaks. . . sigh. guys i actually hate this i think it's one of my worst creations yet u can tell i had no idea how to end it off oh my god HOWEVER i just needed to put SOMETHING out so my creative juices could start flowing again. buuuutttt i do have some bbf and bfb cookin in my docs and i am pretty excited about that tbh đ€ alr alr alr read on sluts
you'd known at some point you'd have to meet matt's brothers, but you didn't think it'd be like this.
if you had known they were planning on popping up like a bunch of weeds, surprise hugs and gifts under their arms, than maybe you wouldn't have teased matt enough to have him join you in the showerâwouldn't have started touching him in the way that had him preening under your fingertips, wouldn't have started kissing him as the stream of water hit the both of you, wouldn't have lifted your leg so he'd have better access to your cunt that throbbed with desire.
âfuckinâ. . .â you panted out, your words sounding like a hybrid between a plea and a protest. âfeels so good, matt. keep goinâ please. . .â
his next thrust was deeper, but not roughânever rough with youâmaking your toes curl from where they were locked around his waist. âyeah, baby? right there?â
you nodded wordlessly, words failing you as he hit that spongy spot inside you that made you open up to him even more, gripping him tight enough to pull him in further. your body couldn't get enough of the way he made you feel, constantly making you feel like you were about to explode like a pack of fireworks. matt could feel what he was doing to you, could feel the way your pussy was tightening around him like it never wanted his dick to be apart from it ever again.
âcum, baby,â matt whispered in your ear, his tone firm yet full of love despite his dirty words, caring more for your pleasure than his. âcâmon, you could do it, baby. cum all over my dick. suck me in juusst like thatâshitâfuckinâ love it when you cream allll on me, baby, câmonâlemme see it.â
he secured your leg around his waist, holding your leg with his left hand and making sure your hands were properly wrapped around his neck before his right hand trailed down, finding your clit easily. it felt like a little pebble, throbbing from lack of attention, the feeling almost making him chuckle if touching it didn't immediately make you gasp and mewl. his touch was light, his thumb rubbing tight circles around the small bundle of nervesâhe knew it was only a matter of seconds before you came, your walls already starting to pulsate around him.
just a few more deep thrusts, some timely rubbed circles andâ
âmatty! yo, where you at?â
matt's entire body froze, his hand and hips stopping just a second off from your orgasm.
that intense euphoric feeling you were about to achieve was ripped from you in an instant, going from fuzzy to frustrated within a second. âmatt, what the fuckââ
âshh, shh,â he cuts you off with an index finger to your mouth, your brows raising incredulously from his audacity. you would've bit his finger off and started complaining at him for edging you like this, but then you saw his wide eyes and the way he seemed to be trying very hard to listen to something.
after another five antagonizing seconds of silence, you both hear it clearly this time. well, not clearly, the words were faint behind the bathroom tile walls, but they were still there. âmatt, câmon, we came all this way to surprise you, and this is the thanks we get?! get your ass down here, kid!â
matt groans lowly as his forehead leans against yours, your own eyes widening with recognition. not exactly recognition because you've never met them in person yet, but shit, were you about to. muttering a quick sorry and kissing the side of your mouth, matt pulls out of youâslow enough to not overstimulate you, fast enough that he didn't keep his brothers waitingâand turns the water off from the shower.
you watch him for a brief moment stumble around the bathroom, throwing on his shorts he left on the ground before tossing you a towel, grabbing one for himself for his hair, running it through like he was trying to create a fire.
âmatt, why are your brothers here right now?â you hissed in a whisper at him, holding the towel to your chest. you weren't mad, not at all, but you felt like you were allowed to be shocked.
this was definitely not how you planned on meeting them. fucking their brother in the shower and then a minute later showing your face to say hello? absolutely not.
ââm sorry, baby, i donât know,â he mumbled hastily, checking himself in the mirror before looking back at you, already backing to the door. he tucked his still hard length into his waistbandâclassicâbefore shrugging on the shirt he left on the sink. âthey like to visit from time to time, think it's a âgood' surprise. justâfuck, get dressed and meet us downstairs, okay? i'll make it up to you, angel, i promise.â
he was already out of the bathroom before you could throw a complaintâwhich would be reasonable, considering you were now left aching for that release and had to play meet and greet with the few people you actually wanted to impress.
after briefly and honestly, thinking about masterbating before exiting the shower, you decide you'd rather not add to your list of embarrassments tonight and just started getting ready. even that was an understatement when all you did was dry off, sneak to your guysâ bedroom while hearing three sounds of laughter come from the living room, and get dressed in something decentâan oversized shirt with loose shorts, with unfortunately, a bra underneath.
you didn't hate bras, but you preferred to keep them off when in the comfort of your home when it was just you and mattâbut there was no way you'd show your face to his brothers with your nipples acting like mountain peaks right now, so, sacrifices had to be made.
when it came time to actually meet chris and nick, they surprisingly didn't make too many âcaught you at a bad time?â jokes, giving both their brother and you some grace and respect even though it was totally obvious from the way both you and matt had wet hair. they were funny and polite, not that you were expecting anything less from the way matt described them, but it made the interaction more bearable to get through.
turned out, as well as randomly dropping by to see their brother who they haven't seen since âhe bagged a baddieâ their words, although, it did crack you up, they were also going to be staying the night. you weren't all that angry about that fact, you didn't care if they stayed one night or ten, but you were a little disappointed because you knew matt wasn't going to resume shit while his family was in the same house. he was respectful like that and, plus, you had a mouth on you.
you were back in your room now, brushing through your now damp hair with a wince while he was setting his brothers up with pillows and blankets for the couch. your bra was hanging off the side of the bed and your libido was suddenly gone, replaced with this closed lid irritation for the fact that you were no longer horny. after applying your hair oil that was definitely too late to even use but you didn't care anymore, the door opened and closed swiftly, matt releasing a breath he didn't even know he was holding as he leaned against the closed door.
âi love my brothers, i do,â he started saying in a whisper, your eyes glancing at him from the mirror. âbut they have the worst timing.â
you shrugged one shoulder, attempting to act more casual than you felt, closing the cap on your bottle. âcould've been worse. they could've walked in on us in doggy or something.â
his gaze held onto your figure, eyes tracking the way you moved around your vanity like a tight rope ready to snap loose. he had noticed you were wearing your bra while talking with chris and nick, but it was gone, twin peaks poking through your shirt due to the small chill in the room. he felt that familiar ache start to returnâhis dick, that was so neatly tucked between his pelvis and his waistband, twitching just slightly.
âyou mad at me?â he asked quietly after a beat, the question catching you off guard that you turned to look at him. he looked small against the door, like he was bracing himself, but there was a different look in his eye other than guilty.
âno. what? why would i be mad at you?â
he looked at the ground, not trusting what he did if he kept looking at your tits with his brothers in the next room. âi mean, kinda accidentally edged you. i'd be pissed, too, if you did that to me.â
you stared at matt, conflicted choosing between being a drama queen and making it a bigger deal than it was or letting it go and instead focusing on how well your first introduction to the boys went. well, not like how you intended, but for what it was worth given the situation. your shoulders dropped and you softened your voice, shaking your head. âi'm not mad. a little frustrated, obviously, i was edged to death in that shower, but your brothers are funny. i'm glad i got to meet them, under the circumstances.â
his eyes flicked back up to yours, as if testing whether you were lying or not to make him feel better. âyeah? you liked them?â
you were nodding now, a small smile forming on your face as you recalled one of nicks bizarre stories while chris offered commentary the whole time, you and matt laughing at every joke and comparison. âyeah, actually, a lot. like, would i have preferred meeting them in a restaurant or a coffee spot or somewhere in neutral ground? yeah, but i didn't, and it was better that they weren't making it a big deal or anything. that helped.â
it took matt a second to register your words before he was smiling, tooâthe one that made you feel lighter and relieved and a little giddy that you got along with his brothers. he pushed off the door and crossed over to you in two strides, hands itching at his sides like he wanted to touch you, but was holding himself back. âyeah, they're cool like that. i can tell they liked you, tooâthey don't perform their over the top stories for just anybody.â
you giggled, your own relief and a small sense of pride washing through you, turning back to your mirror in the vanity. finally, like he couldn't help himself, matt leaned down and placed his hands on your shoulders, fingers kneading gently before kissing your cheek. you blushed at the softness of it, locking eyes with him in the reflection. âthank you. seriously.â
you wanted to feign some sense of humbleness, to act like you didn't know why he was thanking youâknowing damn well that at any point you could've gotten pissy, threw a fit. but before you could come up with a remark, he was kissing behind your ear, hands making their way down your chest. you stilled as he grabbed both your breasts, squeezing gently to feel your hard nubs against his palm.
âand i promised that i'd make it up to you,â he added before punctuating it with another soft kiss at the side of your neck, hands now fondling your tits in the way that was making you feel a little dizzy.
not only because he knew massaging them would turn you on, but because he was usually against the idea of being intimate when around other people. you remembered when you'd taken him to meet your parents and you both stayed in your childhood bedâthe man practically built a pillow wall just to stop you from getting any ideas. this new boldness was surprising and, at the very least, welcomed.
âwith your bothers two doors down? won't you get worried they'dââ, your cut off when he started sucking on your skin, pinching one of your nipples through your shirt, a small moan leaving your lips before you gathered yourself, ââhear us?â
matt didn't answer, at least not right away. instead he took away his hands and turned you around, making you sit facing him. he was looking at you with a fierce mix of lust and love and it made you only needier, feeling that heat return to your core like it never left. then he was leaning in again, hands finding your knees, pulling your legs apart slowly.
âi know, baby, but. . .â he got down on his knees between your legs and paused, as if he were ashamed to even be thinking it with family in close proximity, before rushing the words out in a low tone, leaning up so your faces were only inches away. âfuck, i just really need this.â
âyou. . . really need?. . .â
he brushed his lips against yours, eyes locked onto yours. the intensity would've once made you squirm and shy away from his gaze, but now, you relished in it. âreally, sweetheart? you gonna make me say it?â
even in the heat of the moment, you couldn't bite back your smirk. âthat depends. is it something you're gonna cringe at immediately after?â
matt's brows shot up, his face creating the smallest bit of distance as he looked at you incredulously. âyou sayinâ i cringe after saying extremely sexy and dirty things?â
your shoulders lifted in a tiny shrug. âi mean, iâm not not saying you do that. . . but you do have the tendency to overthink your words in the moment unless you're already in me.â
matt held your gaze for a beat as if he was looking for something he was missing, like he'd find it written all over your face. you didn't break eye contact because you weren't going to lieâif anything, you liked when matt embarrassed himself and when he lost himself in your shared intimacy. however, it seemed like your words broke a dam in him, his face twisting from soft and teasing to a determined thing.
before you knew it, you were being hauled off your chair and carried over to the bed, yelping when you realized your feet were off the ground. he tossed you on the bed softly, tsking with a little head shake. ââoverthink my words unless i'm in youâ. now, i love you, but shut up or else my brothers will hear.â
your eyes almost bulged out of your skull as you watched him tug his shirt off, sputtering real quick before he dropped to his knees again and tugged you forward. the motion made you gasp before you realized what he planned on doing, the anticipation swirling in your gut.
he left your sleep shorts on, but now your knees were separated apart, almost being pushed up to your chest. he started by kissing the inside of your thigh and then, just to further confuse you on where this sudden act of boldness came from, nipped you. âgood luck talkinâ all that shit while iâm licking this sweet pussy.â
you shivered when he moved his mouth directly to your clothed center, lips kissing against the fabric. âi-i don't know, i can already see you b-blush from herââ
âthe only person that's gonna be blushing is gonna be you when iâm done making you cum on my tongue,â he murmured before giving one last kiss through the material before bringing your legs back together, just to pull them off you in a swift motion, the cold air immediately hitting your warmth and making you gasp again. ânow i love you, but you need to keep that pretty mouth closed, alright? can't have my brothers hearinâ.â
you truly didn't know what the hell had gotten into himâhe was never this unabashed when there were other people around, when his brain wasn't already turned off from all the sex. and fuck, his new attitude was making you soaking, watching as he attacked your pussy with his mouth and his saliva mixed with your essence.
you made sure to take into account that interrupted sex + some light teasing = a very determined matt.