You seem very rational. Have you ever seen or experienced something unexplainable, something which defied your logical framework?
a paranormal experience, a strange encounter, or some other anomalous memory 🕳️
It's not something I talk about a lot on this page, but... I have experienced psychosis, and I have a dissociative disorder. Anomalous memories and experiences are something I inevitably live with.
I think the reason I am generally a sceptic of the supernatural is because I'm very aware from experience just how easy it is for perception to become warped or altered, beliefs to form without real basis in logical reasoning, and our memory of experiences (and our ability to recall them) to be shaped and coloured by the state of our brain and all sorts of factors beyond our conscious control.
I'm not saying every person who has ever experienced something unusual "was imagining it". But I hesitate to draw a direct equivalence between experience/memory and objective consensus reality. I think sometimes we experience things because our brain, our body, our subconscious, is trying to tell us something -the experience is real and meaningful but also personal and subjective, internal-become-seemingly-external.
I genuinely think that we often "know" or "perceive" more than we think we do. And our "holistic" self (our entire brain, our entire body) tries to impart info to our conscious verbal mind by whichever tools are available.
So... maybe we feel watched and see shit moving from the corner of our eyes in the creepy house that's not structurally sound (body going "get out of here, I can feel the sub-audible creaking, this place is not safe!") or... we dream of (or even hear!) a deceased family member or benevolent Other telling us to go to the doctor (body going "we're sick! You don't know it yet but this is serious!"), or we just get a bad *vibe* from a person (brain picking up minute discrepancies in body language that seem to indicate there's something off about this person), or...
None of this subconscious "knowing" is necessarily more true or real than conscious thought -it is subject to instincts and biases and mistakes just the same. Our "gut" isn't always right. But it's also not nonsense. There's a reason why "a strong feeling of impending doom" is genuinely one of the warning signs for a heart attack or anaphylaxis, or why many healthcare practitioners over time get a "feeling" for when a seemingly stable patient is about to crash, for example. Our body is a complicated machine that can indirectly provide us meaningful information, about both ourselves and the world around us.
And sometimes it gets fucked up. Sometimes all our holistic self is trying to tell us is that we're tired and scared and overwhelmed. Sometimes we see shit and think shit because things are just kinda bad for us and our physical functioning is in disarray. So there's that too.
And for myself, my dissociative disorder means there's not just the dichotomy of my verbal mind and my non-verbal holistic body-mind, but also a split in my own self-perception, memory and abilities. I contain often-contradictory multitudes. I don't always know or remember or believe the same things, I can't always do the same things or access the same skills. Sometimes the split is incomplete and I can do things I don't recall learning, or have knowledge disconnected from its logical context. It's weird like that.
So...
If the question was, Have I experienced things that, if taken at face value as real objective events, would indicate the existence of the supernatural? Then yes, I have.
If the question was, Do I take these anomalous experiences at such face value? Then no, I don't. I tend to assume even the unexplainable has an explanation, it's just unknown to me or inaccessible to my current state of being.
If the question was, Do I believe in the supernatural? Well. I think belief intrinsically involves uncertainty. And I'm not certain there is *nothing*, which implies that on some level I do believe in the possibility of the supernatural. You could consider me an agnostic on this topic, I guess.











