Baby I'm not alright, but I'm okay (Part 9)
Cash Wheeler x f reader
A/n: reader is referred as Y/n Mercer
Previous chapter
Daniel looked at her, confused, then nodded. "Alright. But you’re definitely telling me where you’ve been and why you’re hiding from your ex," he said firmly.
As they moved through the fairly large venue, Y/N kept glancing around nervously, but thankfully, there was no sign of her ex. Slightly calmer now, she asked, "How did you even end up here?" "You don’t know what’s going on here at all?" Daniel replied with a smirk, answering her question with another. "To be honest? Not really. I was assigned a shift, given a location, and told what to do. I didn’t ask any more questions."
As they continued walking, Y/N noticed familiar logos—and soon after, familiar voices. "Wait… is this like, some kind of fan booths, and you're here for work?" The realization hit her as unexpectedly as their chance meeting among hundreds of people. "Gosh, I'm sorry for distracting you. You probably have a lot to do, despite saving some damsel in distress."
Wheeler stopped, gently took her hand, and turned her toward him. He leaned in slightly, locking eyes with her. "First of all, you are not just any damsel in distress. And secondly, if you ever need someone to help you, save you, or just be by your side and listen—whatever it is—you've got me. Or Dax."
Their gazes met. In Wheeler’s eyes was unwavering certainty in every word he’d said. Despite her long disappearance, he was still ready to be there. His strong yet gentle hand held hers, offering warmth and comfort. "Thank you. I appreciate that. A lot." And she really meant it.
She was about to step forward and hug Daniel when a male voice with a clear accent called out to her. "Y/N? Long time no see! How are you?" Without realizing it, Y/N let go of their joined hands and slipped back into her mask of confidence. "Oh my god, Steve! I’m doing great. Thank you." They hugged like old friends who hadn’t seen each other in ages.
Daniel was surprised to see Y/N addressing none other than Nigel McGuinness so casually by his real name. "You two know each other? I didn’t think you were ever into wrestling," Daniel said, clearly taken aback. "Oh, I never was," the girl chuckled. "We have our ways." "You never stop surprising me. Seriously, every single time." "I hope only in a good way."
Nigel and Y/N exchanged playful smiles before finally breaking apart. "C’mon, the guys want to say hi to an old friend too."
Cash stood alone, stunned. "What the…" was all he managed to mutter. "What the… what?" Harwood asked, approaching his friend. There was a rare look of confusion on Daniel’s face. "What happened?"
Daniel briefly explained how he ended up there with Y/N and how she had addressed Nigel. "So you don’t know? I thought she already told you," David said quietly. "Told me what? What am I supposed to know?" The situation was getting even more confusing. Dax raised his hands and shrugged apologetically. "If she hasn't told you yet, it's not my place to speak. It's not my story. She'll tell you when she's ready."
Y/N spent some time catching up with her friends before returning to her duties. Daniel watched her from afar, making sure everything was okay.
Later that evening, once her shift was finally over, Daniel gave Y/N a ride home from the venue. The car was silent until he turned on the radio. Slow jazz filled the space — unusual for both of them, but oddly soothing. Y/N closed her eyes, leaning back in the seat and letting the tension of the day melt away.
All this time, Wheeler avoided pressing her about what had happened and what exactly he had saved her from today. But a part of him kept circling back to the topic unconsciously.
Parking outside her house, he turned off the engine and turned to look at her, studying her relaxed expression. It seemed like she felt his gaze, because she opened her eyes, smiled faintly, and sat up. "Something wrong?" she asked, slightly anxious.
But Wheeler shook his head. "No. Everything’s fine."
Silence settled between them again.
"Don’t you want to know—" "Do you want to come in?" she interrupted unexpectedly.
They started speaking at the same time, neither hearing the other. Wheeler went first this time. "Sorry," he said softly. "You go ahead…" Y/N hesitated slightly, then repeated her offer in a quieter tone: "Maybe… you could come in? For tea or something. I’d like to treat you, as a thank-you for rescuing me today." She looked away awkwardly, losing confidence with every word. "He wouldn’t turn down a little gratitude, right?" she wondered silently.
It was unusual to see her like this. In the short time they'd known each other, Y/N had always seemed cold and distant. Only rarely did those protective walls lower enough to reveal a sweet, sometimes vulnerable girl. And now, it seemed like one of those walls had developed a crack. And that was unlikely to end well.
From personal experience, Wheeler knew that when such walls finally collapse under pressure, they destroy everything alive inside. They bury it all beneath the rubble, leaving nothing but lifeless ruins. "I would love to," Daniel replied quickly, not giving himself time to think twice.
They both got out of the car and entered the quiet, peaceful house. "Come in, make yourself comfortable," Y/N said, stepping aside to let him in. "You must be hungry. You spent the whole day dealing with me and my problems, even though you didn’t have to."
Y/N headed to the kitchen, and Cash followed. He leaned forward on the table with his elbows. "Listen, I already said—it’s not a problem. But remember? You owe me one. You promised to explain what happened."
She sighed heavily, rubbing her temples. She didn’t want to revisit this, but she had no choice. "Fine. Then I’ll make us some tea and tell you. This isn’t quick."
Mercer brewed the tea and placed a steaming cup in front of Daniel. Sitting across from him, she began: "Today, I ran into my ex. His name is Josh. We were together since high school. At first, everything was innocent. He was caring, loving, supported me through panic attacks. But for some reason, my brother never liked him. I asked Scott many times why, but he never told me. It was almost like a feeling he had."
Y/N paused and took a sip from her cup. The tea burned her mouth, but continuing without interruption was harder. Wheeler reached out and covered her hand with his. "If you don’t want to keep going… it’s okay. You don’t have to." "No, no, no. I have to go on… So… Years passed, and I didn’t notice how things changed. Support disappeared. Care became a memory. I became convenient for him. It was easy for him to come home to a girlfriend who cooked for him, hugged him, gave affection, and never asked for anything in return. Maybe I wasn’t giving him what he needed, so he cheated on me. When I found out, it literally broke me. I felt worthless. I kept asking myself, 'What could I have done differently to fix things?'"
Wheeler wanted to say that cheating is always the fault of the person who does it—but he didn’t dare interrupt her, only tightening his grip on her hand. "When I confronted him directly, Josh said it was my fault—and he hit me. I still have the scar." Y/N lifted her shirt slightly, revealing the mark on her ribs. "I stayed alone with the thought that it was my fault, that things could be fixed. That went on until Scott came. Seeing me bruised, he nearly killed my ex. He took me and brought me here. Josh tried to reach out, but Scott insisted I change my number and block him everywhere. Things were calm for a while. But when the news about us started coming out, I got scared Josh might find me again—that’s why I left without telling anyone. I'm so sorry…"
Daniel could feel how much pain it caused her to remember. He saw the fire in her eyes, the trembling lips. It tore at his heart. He couldn’t understand how someone could hurt her like this. Y/N turned away to hide her tears. Daniel walked around the table, stepped closer, wrapped his arms around her, and began gently stroking her back. "I know. I’m sorry you had to go through this."
She allowed herself to relax in his arms and finally cried, releasing years of built-up pain. "Don’t hold back. You need this."
Strong, masculine arms holding her trembling body gave her a sense of safety and protection. For the first time in a long time, she felt that someone truly cared—not just about her presence, but about her feelings. And somehow, that was enough.












