@alyxeris Well... I’ve overhauled the card game. I’ll put the changed rules up next.
One thing that needs to be done is to have some way for hoaxes to last only a few turns, as having them last all game is way unfair. Something similar to vanishing from MTG would work very well.
Instead of one person always rolling first, there should be a marker for the first roller that always shifts to the next player at the beginning of a round. This would help out the above case, as hoaxes could now say “when the turn marker moves, remove a counter from ~”
I want to really pin down types, bother creature and item.
Alien – What it says on the tin.
Water – Monsters that live in or are only seen near water
Flying – Monsters with wings. Not levitating ones, or UFOs.
Spirit – What it says on the tin.
Beast – Monsters that don’t fit in any of the above categories.
Stationary – Only ever seen in one area (Fresno Nightwalkers, Mothman, etc.)
Hoax – Item to be played on an opponent, to their dismay.
Fading – Sticks around for a limited number of turns.
Single-use – Goes away afterwards.
Event – In the cryptid deck. Does something, then goes away.
Currently, each monster left over in a player’s stash nets them 5 points. However, I want to assign a star rating to monsters. Each ★ (alt + 9733) on a monster indicates the number of points gained at the end of the game. Famous monsters (Nessie, Bigfoot, etc.) are worth ★★★★★ (5 points). Monsters believed to be extinct or are simply much larger than their regular sizes (Thylacine, Oke Octopus, etc.) are worth ★★★★. Lesser known monsters and those found only in folklore are ★★★.
All planned monsters, by star rating:
★★★★★: Bigfoot, Nessie, Mothman, Chupacabra, Roswell Visitor, Yeti, Dover Demon, Globster, Flatwoods Monster, Jersey Devil, Kraken, Mongolian Death Worm, Montauk Monster, Yowie, Black Bird of Chernobyl, Missouri Monster
★★★★: Oke Octopus, Thylacine, Megaconda, Megalodon, Dodo, Mastodon, Ivory-Billed Woodpecker, Sewer Alligator
★★★: Georgia Stalk, Owlman, Gashadokuro, Bahn Sidhe, Black Shuck, Bakekujira, Hopkinsville Goblin, Ahool, Altamaha-ha, Bunyip, Cadborosaurus, Dingonek, Dobar-chu, Fresno Nightwalker, Kappa, Kelpie, Loveland Frog, Saybrook Blockheads, Futa-kuchi Onna [Two-mouthed Woman], Rokurokubi, Kuchi-sake Onna [Split-mouth Woman]
Hoaxes: Fur-bearing trout, Wolpertinger, Jackalope, Barnum’s Mermaid
Alien: Roswell Visitor, Dover Demon, Flatwoods Monster, Georgia Stalk, Hopkinsville Goblin, Fresno Nightwalker, Saybrook Blockheads
Water: Nessie, Altamaha-ha, Bunyip, Cadborosaurus, Oke Octopus, Sewer Alligator, Kraken, Bakekujira, Kappa, Kelpie, Megalodon, Globster
Flying: Black Bird of Chernobyl, Mothman, Owlman, Ahool, Ivory-Billed Woodpecker, Jersey Devil
Spirit: Gashadokuro, Bakekujira, Futa-kuchi Onna, Kuchi-sake Onna, Rokurokubi, Black shuck, Bahn Sidhe
Beast: Bigfoot, Chupacabra, Yeti, Mongolian Death Worm, Montauk Monster, Yowie, Missouri Monster, Thylacine, Megaconda, Dodo, Mastodon, Dingonek, Dobar-chu, Loveland Frog