Day 3 - Virginity/Innocence - Penelope Garcia x Reader
Summary: In which your virgin status is revealed to your best friend and she decides to do something about it.Ā
WC: ~1k
It was kind of embarrassing being a 24-year-old virgin, but you were more focused on a career than sex. That worked out for you and you ended up at the FBI at the ripe age of 23. In the year that passed, you were too busy doing fieldwork and the paperwork that followed to have any dates, much less one night stands. On this rare night off, you and the team were over at your best friend, Penelopeās apartment. Everyoneās wine-drunk and someone, probably Penny, decides to suggest a game of truth or truth. Really, you have nothing to lose, well except your virginity, but nothing in the sense of this game, so youāre the first to agree to play with the rest of the team following your lead. The questions started out innocent enough, like your first and current celebrity crush, any current crushes, and once everyone was tired of āboring questionsā, someone decided to start asking more scandalous ones. Since you were first to agree to the game, you were the target of the first question.Ā
āSo⦠Y/N, tell us about when you lost your virginity. What was it like?ā Your eyes widened at the boldness of the question, and you quickly scrambled to make up an answer.
āIt was okay, I guess. You know, it was a first time, probably the exact same as you guysā.ā The words came out jumbled and rushed, and Penelope looked at you with concern written all over her features. She turned to you and mouthed āyou okayā before you nodded and allowed the next person to ask a question. The game continued until everyone was ready to go to their respective homes and sleep off their drunkenness. Previously, you had asked Penelope if you could spend the night, so you were making up the couch when she re-entered the living room.Ā
āY/N. You know youāre not sleeping on the couch in my house, grab your blanket and come to bed, itās big enough for both of us.ā Immediately following her instructions, you grabbed your stuff and followed her to the bedroom. You got settled into bed, and turned towards Penelope to see if she was still awake. Only in the darkness of her bedroom would you dare to say what you were about to say out loud.Ā
āPenny⦠you know how we tell each other everything...ā You werenāt sure if she was asleep, and if she was it was actually better for you, that way you could admit it without actually admitting it. āWell, I acted so weird when the topic of my first time came up during the game because I havenāt had one yet. I know itās embarrassing, but I havenāt had the time to do it, and I guess I just didnāt feel comfortable with anyone.ā After your admission, you took a few deep breaths, the words taking all of the air from your lungs. For a few moments, you didnāt receive an answer and assumed she was asleep. You were going to turn over, but then she grabbed your hand. Penelope was gazing into your eyes lovingly, you assumed, the only light coming in was from the moon outside.Ā
āWould you want to⦠now?ā Penelope murmured the question in such a soft whisper that if Y/N declined, it couldāve just been the wind. If she was being completely honest, the idea of her best friend being a virgin and Penelope being the one to open her eyes to the amazing world of sex. Y/N nodded sheepishly, feeling a bit embarrassed by her confession, and a bit shocked that Penelope offered to do something about it. She loudly cleared her throat.Ā
āYeah⦠Pen⦠thatād be nice, but tonight, can you justā¦ā she trailed off nervously and took a deep breath. āEat me out?ā The latter part of the question was almost a whisper, and she couldnāt believe how crude she was being. Penelope motioned for her best friend to lay on the bed, lightly tapping her outer thigh so she would spread her legs. The literal second Y/N asked, it was like Penelope transformed into a different person.Ā
āSpread your legs, pretty, I donāt have all night to ravish you⦠although I wish I did.ā Penelopeās pupils were blown with a hunger that was simply primal. She slid Y/Nās shorts and panties down her legs, throwing them in the corner. Penelope used two fingers to spread her friend open, blowing a testing stream of air on her center. She gauged her need, and her pussy was practically pulsating in Penelopeās face. Penelope decided to end her suffering and immediately dove in, placing a couple of licks on her clit before taking the entire bud in her mouth and sucking. Penelope moaned at Y/Nās taste, āmm⦠so good, canāt believe Iām the first one to taste this pretty cunt, itās so rude of you to keep it hidden from everyone.āĀ
Y/Nās back arched in pleasure as Penelope ate her like it was the last meal of her life. āMore. Please more.ā she whined, unable to believe she was begging and that her best friend was eating her out. Penelope hummed and immediately obliged, plunging one finger into her and quickly turning that into two.Ā
āSo tight, so pretty. Iāve got so much to teach you love. Iām going easy on you tonight⦠for your sake.ā Y/N let out a chorus of moans at Penelopeās words, getting closer to her peak. She felt it embarrassing how quickly she was about to cum, but it turned Garcia on even more. Penelope looked at her friend with a wicked smirk. āCome on⦠I know youāre close, and trust me, this is going to be completely different than anything youāve done by yourself.ā At her best friendās command/permission, she finally let go. Penelope was right, the orgasm racked her body and was unlike anything sheād felt by herself. Penelope removed her fingers slowly, putting them in Y/Nās mouth.Ā
āPenelope⦠please. Fuck me.ā Y/N whined around her fingers. She had left all of her self-respect and dignity when she decided to fuck her best friend.Ā
Penelope shook her head in denial. āBaby, you did so good, but I canāt fuck you tonight, thatād be too much for you to handle. Thereās always tomorrow.ā She winked.Ā
A/N: Possible part 2 incoming??
















