Hello! I just wanted to say that I absolutely love your writing. Especially the way you write Elrond! So good. You've very quickly become one of my favorite tumblr posters :) I don't know if anyone has asked this yet, but if not, how would Elrond, CĂrdan, and Gil-Galad react to the reader rescuing them from being captured by orcs/bandits? Thanks!
Thank you so much for your kind words! It truly means the world to me to hear that you enjoy my writing. đ„čâ€ïžâđ„đ«¶âš
As for your question, I actually wrote something similar to this idea before the title called âElves reacting their you saving their lifeâsâ itâs on my Masterlist pinned at top of my page youâll find it in their, though I havenât explored a scenario with orcs or bandits specificallyâso Iâd be more than happy to write it for you. Itâs such a fun and dynamic setup, and I love the idea of exploring how Elrond, CĂrdan, and Gil-galad would react in that kind of situation. Thank you for the inspiration! đ„șđ€
how would the elves react to this?
â
â
â
Elrond, Gil-Galad CĂrdan Version below.
đ đđ”đ»đžđ·đ
Elrond might react to the reader/you swooping in to save them from a perilous situation like being captured by orcs.
The ancient woods of Eregion were silent, the kind of silence that came when predators were near. The golden light of dusk bled through the canopy, staining the forest floor in hues of amber and crimson. The wind barely stirred, as if the trees themselves held their breath. Somewhere within this tranquil facade, chaos brewed. Elrond Half-elven had been captured. The orcs had struck swiftly and without mercy, ambushing him and his small party as they returned from a reconnaissance mission. His guards had fought valiantly but were quickly overwhelmed. Now, bound and bloodied, Elrond knelt in a rough clearing, surrounded by the jeers of his captors. His silver-threaded tunic was torn, his dark hair matted with dirt and blood. Yet, even in this moment of vulnerability, his eyes shone like steelâcold, calculating, and unyielding.
The orcs had made a mistake. They had underestimated him. But even Elrond, for all his cunning, could not see a clear path to freedom. His hands were tightly bound behind him, the ropes cutting into his skin, a reminder of his helplessness. His weapons were gone, and though his mind raced with strategies, every scenario ended the same: with his blood soaking the earth. His pride and experience told him to fight, but in the quiet dark of the clearing, with the weight of captivity pressing down on him, Elrond knew he was out of options. For a fleeting moment, something close to frustration stirred within himâbut he quickly pushed it aside. Anger wouldnât free him, nor would it serve him here. He needed to think, needed to wait, but time was a luxury he no longer had.
The orcs were already bickering over their prize. One particularly large brute brandished a jagged blade and snarled something in their guttural tongue. Elrond didnât flinch. He met the orcâs gaze with cold detachment, refusing to grant them the satisfaction of his fear. He had seen this beforeâdeath in various forms, and in many guises. If this was to be his end, he would meet it with dignity. But even as he steeled himself, he could feel the weight of his impending fate, the very real possibility of this moment being his last. And then, a soundâa faint rustle in the underbrush. The orcs didnât notice, too consumed by their squabble, but Elrondâs keen ears caught it. His sharp gaze flickered toward the shadows at the edge of the clearing, where the fading light painted shifting patterns on the forest floor. For a moment, his mind raced. Was it a stray animal? A larger threat? No. The movement was too deliberate, too precise, to be mere chance.
A slight shift in the air, a tension, drew his attention fully. He felt a strange spark of hopeâa quick, unfamiliar surge, like a breath after being submerged too long. And then, his senses sharpened, pulling his attention entirely to the darkness beyond. Somethingâor someoneâwas coming. Someone was there. Someone you. You had tracked the orcs for hours, following the trail of broken branches and spilled blood. When youâd come upon the sceneâElrond bound and surroundedâyou hadnât hesitated. There wasnât time to formulate a grand plan or to consider the consequences. All that mattered was saving him.
From the shadows, you moved with practiced stealth, each step as quiet as the fall of a leaf. Your hand tightened around the hilt of your blade as you assessed the situation. The orcs were manyâmore than youâd expectedâbut their focus on Elrond gave you the element of surprise. It would have to be enough. Your attack was swift. The first orc didnât even have time to scream before your blade slid across its throat. The second fell just as quickly, your dagger finding its mark in the gap between its armor. By the time the others realized what was happening, you were already upon them, a whirlwind of steel and determination.
Elrondâs head snapped up at the commotion, his sharp gaze locking onto your form as you cut through his captors like a storm. Surprise flashed across his face, quickly replaced by something elseâsomething akin to awe. You moved with a grace that rivaled even the elves, your every strike precise, your every motion purposeful. The orcs snarled and lunged at you, but you were relentless. The clearing erupted into chaos as you danced between them, your blade gleaming in the fading light. One by one, the orcs fell, their cries echoing through the trees. Still, more kept coming, their brute strength and numbers threatening to overwhelm you.
Elrond, though bound and weaponless, wasnât idle. He twisted his wrists against the ropes, his sharp mind analyzing every detail of the fight. When one orc charged toward you from behind, he shouted, âBehind you!â His voice, commanding even in captivity, gave you just enough warning to sidestep the attack and deliver a killing blow. Finally, the last orc fell, its body hitting the ground with a heavy thud. The clearing was eerily quiet once more, the air thick with the stench of blood. You turned to Elrond, your chest heaving as you hurried to his side.
âAre you hurt?â you asked, your voice breathless but steady. âNothing that wonât heal,â he replied, his tone calm despite the ordeal. His eyes, however, betrayed the storm of emotions roiling beneath his composed exteriorârelief, gratitude, and perhaps a touch of disbelief. You knelt behind him, cutting through the ropes with quick, efficient movements. As the bindings fell away, Elrond flexed his hands, wincing slightly at the raw skin beneath. He rose to his feet with the grace of one who had endured far worse, his imposing presence undiminished by his injuries. âYou should not have come for me,â he said, his voice low but firm. âIt was reckless.â
âPerhaps,â you admitted, meeting his gaze without flinching. âBut I wasnât about to leave you to them.â For a moment, Elrond said nothing, his piercing gray eyes searching yours. Then, slowly, the corners of his lips curved into the faintest of smiles. âFoolish,â he murmured, almost to himself. âBut brave.â Together, you moved through the forest, leaving the carnage behind. Elrond insisted he was fine, though you couldnât help but notice the way he favored one leg as he walked. When you offered to slow down, he waved you off with a faint smirk. âI am not as fragile as I look.â As night fell, the two of you stopped to rest in a small, sheltered glade. Elrond sat with his back against a tree, his eyes fixed on the stars above. You sat beside him, the silence between you comfortable but charged with unspoken words. Finally, Elrond broke the silence. âYou saved my life,â he said, his voice soft. âI do not say this lightly, but I am in your debt.â
âYou donât owe me anything,â you replied. âI did what anyone would do.â âNo,â he said, turning to face you fully. âNot anyone. Few would risk their lives for another, let alone against such odds. You have my gratitudeâand my respect.â There was a sincerity in his tone that left no room for doubt. For all his wisdom and strength, Elrond was not one to offer his trust easily. Yet, in this moment, he looked at you not as a subordinate or even a savior, but as an equal. As the night deepened and the stars shone brighter, you realized that this momentâshared in the aftermath of dangerâwas the beginning of something far greater than either of you could have anticipated.
đ”ïžđđČđ”-đ°đȘđ”đȘđ
Gil-Galad might react to the reader/you swooping in to save them from a perilous situation like being captured by orcs.
The night air was cold, and the sky overhead was shrouded in a blanket of clouds. The dark, twisted trees of Middle-earth seemed to close in, casting ominous shadows across the forest floor. In the heart of the woods, Gil-galad, the High King of the Noldor, stood tallâhis regal bearing unshaken, even in the face of danger. The faintest shimmer of starlight glanced off his golden armor as he and his companions prepared for an ambush. His keen silver grey eyes scanned the surroundings, always vigilant, always prepared for what came next. But even the most vigilant of Elven kings could be caught off guard. The attack was swift. Orcs, crawling from the dark crevices of the forest, came at them like a tide. The clash of metal on metal rang out as Gil-galad led his warriors with strength and precision, a beacon of light in the chaos. His movements were fluid, his strikes calculated, but even he was not immune to the overwhelming number of attackers.
In the midst of the fray, one of the Orcs, taller and stronger than the others, launched itself at Gil-galad with terrifying speed. It knocked the King off balance, sending him crashing to the forest floor with a heavy thud. His sword fell from his hand, skidding away into the underbrush. For a fleeting moment, Gil-galadâs breath was knocked from his lungs, his vision blurred from the sudden impact. The sting of the fall reached deep into his ribs, and the sharpness of the pain reminded him that even a King was not invincible. The Orcs closed in, snarling, their eyes gleaming with malice. He could feel his heartbeat pounding in his ears, his pulse quickening as he struggled to regain his bearings. Gil-galadâs gaze sharpened despite the fog of disorientation, his mind already calculating his next move. He rolled to the side, narrowly avoiding a blade aimed at his heart. He reached for his sword, but it was too far away. There was a fleeting moment, a brief weaknessâsomething unfamiliarâthat passed through him. A flash of helplessness that he rarely allowed himself to feel. It was swiftly buried beneath layers of command and duty, but it lingered just a little longer than he would have liked. Just as the Orcs began to close in, something unexpected happened.
A rush of movement swept through the trees. In a blink, you appearedâyour form silhouetted by the faint moonlight that filtered through the canopy above. Without hesitation, you leapt into the fray, your blade flashing like a streak of lightning in the darkness. The battle paused for a brief second as Gil-galad, still on the ground, turned his head in your direction. His heart skipped a beatânot from fear or shock, but from an overwhelming sense of awe. With swift precision, you cut through the nearest Orc, your movements an elegant dance of strength and agility. The creatures fell back, surprised by the sudden turn of events, their snarls turning to fearful hisses. But it wasnât the Orcs that held Gil-galadâs attention. It was you. Your movements were effortless, your focus unwavering. You cut through their ranks, protecting the King as though you were born for this very moment. Gil-galadâs thoughts raced. He knew his warriors were skilled, but there was something about youâsomething about the way you moved, the way you fought with such certainty and graceâthat left him speechless. A profound sense of gratitude and admiration swelled in his chest.
His breath was still ragged from the fall, but he forced himself to push off the ground, his hand gripping the earth for support. His eyes locked on yours as you cleared the final Orcs with a grace that could only come from an elf with purpose. The moment you turned toward him, your gaze filled with concern, his lips parted to speak, but no words came. For the first time in many long years, the weight of the battle felt distant compared to the relief that flooded him at your presence. He could feel the adrenaline still coursing through his veins, but it was tempered by an undeniable surge of gratitude. You had been there when he falteredâwhen the weight of the crown, the history of his people, and the perils of the battle had threatened to pull him down. You stepped toward him, your voice calm and steady as you spoke. âAre you injured, my king?â Gil-galad, still shaken but steadying himself, nodded. âI am unharmed, thanks to you.â His voice was low, but the words carried a sincerity that he could not conceal. There was no formality in his words, no regal distance between you. Only an unspoken appreciation. He would have never admitted it aloud, but in that fleeting moment, he felt an unfamiliar vulnerability, one he did not know how to shield himself from.
You bent down to help him, extending your hand. He took it, and as you helped him rise to his feet, a look of quiet admiration crossed his face. For a moment, he simply stood there, his gaze softening as he took in the full depth of your actions. A flicker of something more stirred within himâa warmth he hadnât felt in ages. But it was the steadiness of your touch, the way you stood by him without hesitation, that left him in awe. The king, ever the leader, found his heart racing not with the weight of his title, but with something far simpler: a respect, perhaps something even deeper, for the one who had stood by him in the face of danger. âYou have my deepest gratitude,â he said, his tone rich with meaning. âWithout your intervention, I may not have made it out of this alive.â There was a weight in his wordsâan acknowledgement that, in this chaotic world of shifting alliances and countless battles, your presence had changed everything. He had long borne the weight of his kingdom, the responsibility of leadership, but tonight, that burden had been eased by you.
His eyes searched yours, and for a moment, the world around them faded. The sounds of battle, the crashing of blades, the cries of the fallenâall of it melted away as Gil-galadâs gaze softened. âYour bravery⊠it does not go unnoticed,â he added, his voice low and earnest. âI will not forget this.â As you stood by him, your hands still holding his, he felt the weight of the moment settle between you both. The connection was undeniable. He had seen countless lives lost in the wars of Middle-earth, witnessed the rise and fall of kingdoms, but in this fleeting moment, he felt something he hadnât allowed himself to feel in a long timeâtrust. Perhaps, even something more. The night was still, the threat of the Orcs momentarily forgotten, as the two of you shared a brief but significant moment. It was then that Gil-galad realized the depths of your loyaltyânot just as a warrior, but as someone who had saved him not for glory, but for the simple love of what was right. And as he returned to the fight, standing side by side with you, the Kingâs heart swelled with something he hadnât expectedâhope.
đ đŹĂđ»đđȘđ·
CĂrdan might react to the reader/you swooping in to save them from a perilous situation like being captured by orcs.
The salt-laden air of the Grey Havens stung the skin as the distant waves crashed relentlessly against the shore, their rhythm a cruel backdrop to the chaos unfolding on the docks. The normally serene harbor had become a battlefield, its once tranquil shores stained with the blood of the brave and the wicked alike. Orcs had struck swiftly, their guttural cries mingling with the clang of steel and the roar of flames licking the sky. A boat had been set ablaze, its wreckage casting an eerie glow on the water as smoke swirled into the darkening sky. CĂrdan, his silver hair flowing behind him like a banner, stood as an unyielding sentinel amidst the chaos. His movements were fluid, a dance of deadly elegance as he cut down the attackers one by one. Despite the ferocity of his strikes, his age was beginning to show. His breath, though steady, came with more effort now, and his movements were slower, less sharp than they had once been. The weight of centuries rested on his shoulders, and though his resolve was unbroken, fatigue crept into his limbs.
The orcs were relentless, and soon he was surrounded. A heavy cleaver struck his sword with a resounding clash, forcing him back against the stone wall of the harbor. The ground beneath his feet was slick, and for a brief moment, CĂrdan felt the full weight of age and weariness. His heart pounded in his chest, but still he raised his sword, determined to protect his people, to fend off the dark tide. Then, the soundâa rustle in the trees above, so faint it could have been mistaken for the wind. But not to CĂrdan. His sharp eyes flickered toward the movement, his heart quickening with hope. He knew what it meant. You were here. You had been tracking the orc band for days, following their trail with patience and precision. But when you had seen the smoke rising from the docks, when you had realized that the mighty Shipwright himself was in peril, there was no hesitation. You burst from the shadows, a whirlwind of action and determination. Your blade was already in your hand as you descended from the ridge above the harbor, landing with the grace of a predator.
The first orc never knew what hit it. You moved like lightning, your strike clean and efficient, the orcâs blood spilling across the stones before it even had time to scream. The second orc fared no better, falling at your feet with a single, well-placed blow. CĂrdanâs blue eyes widened in surprise at the sight of you, the flicker of disbelief in his gaze quickly replaced by something far deeperârecognition, relief, and perhaps even a touch of awe. You had come for him, risking everything to pull him from the jaws of death. âStay behind me!â you shouted as you moved toward him, your voice firm and unyielding amidst the chaos of battle. For a moment, CĂrdan hesitated. He had always been the protector, the one to stand between others and danger. But as he saw you cut through the orcs with such deadly precision, the decision was made for him. He gritted his teeth, his sword rising once more to meet the next foe. Together, you formed an unstoppable force, a seamless unity that struck terror into the hearts of the orcs.
The battle raged on, but your combined strength was a force of nature. At one point, a brutish orc captain, wielding a massive axe, charged at you. CĂrdan saw it coming before you did. Without hesitation, he stepped into the line of fire, his sword parrying the deadly blow that would have otherwise struck you down. The force of the strike rattled him, but his gaze remained as steady as the sea. âYou risk much for an old shipwright,â he said, his voice calm even in the midst of the battle. âIâm not leaving you here!â you replied fiercely, spinning to meet another attacker. âNot after all youâve done for Middle-earth.â For a fleeting moment, CĂrdanâs expression softened, and his eyes lingered on you with a new respect. Few understood the sacrifices he had made over the centuries, the countless battles fought in the shadows, the weight of leadership that bore down on him. But youâhere you were, putting everything on the line for him. And somehow, it stirred something deep within him.
With renewed purpose, you fought side by side, driving the orcs back, step by step, until their resolve shattered. The last of the attackers fell with a guttural cry, their bodies littering the stones of the harbor like discarded refuse. The once-bloody battlefield fell silent. The air was thick with the scent of salt and blood, but the clamor of battle had ceased. Only the gentle lap of the waves against the shore and the distant cries of gulls broke the stillness. CĂrdan stood beside you, his breath coming in measured, steady bursts. He was still strong, but the toll of the fight had left its mark on him. His cheek was bloodied, a thin cut running across his face, but his posture was unyielding. He looked at you with gratitude and something deeperâan understanding that had not existed between you before.
âYou have my thanks,â he said quietly, his voice steady but filled with unspoken emotion. His blue eyes held yours, and for the first time in your presence, he spoke not as a leader, but as a fellow soul who had witnessed your bravery firsthand. âFew would have risked their lives for me. Fewer still would have succeeded.â You nodded, feeling the weight of his words. âYouâve spent centuries helping others, CĂrdan. Itâs about time someone returned the favor.â A small, genuine smile tugged at the corners of his lips, rare and fleeting but filled with warmth. âThen I am fortunate it was you,â he said, his voice low but sincere. As the first light of dawn crept over the horizon, casting a soft glow over the harbor, you and CĂrdan stood side by side, looking out over the water. The battle had been long and fierce, but the bond forged between you in the heat of conflict was even stronger. There was no need for words now. The understanding between you was clear.
CĂrdan placed a hand on your shoulder, his grip gentle but strongâa silent gesture of respect. âYou have the heart of a mariner,â he said softly, his voice carrying the cadence of the sea. âFearless, steadfast, and loyal. I will not forget this.â And as the light of the new day broke over the Grey Havens, you knew that, in your heart, you had not only saved a lifeâyou had earned the trust and respect of one of Middle-earthâs greatest figures.














