“I was with Edwin Laughlin for his first experiments, before he became Phoenix. I collected his victims, and I his their remains in the walls of Ashtown. We killed so many Smiths. Too many to remember. More than have ever been found.” He flared his nostrils, his lip quivering as he spoke. “You all smell the same.”
“What is your name?” Cyrus asked.
“When the dragons arrive, I will consider it my duty to suck the marrow from your bones,” the man said. “You and that little girl-”
“Name,” Cyrus said. “For the Order of Brendan’s records.”
“Oh, well,” the man sneered. “For the records then. Willem Radulf Baldwin. Born the 14th of April, 1959. Transmortaled on the 8th of August, 1988.”
The Silent Bells, N.D. Wilson, Chapter Two
According to The Dragon’s Tooth, Lawrence’s sisters and Cyrus’s aunts, Harriet and Circe Smith, were killed by Phoenix; their bodies were not found until years later. So this bears up with canon.
What about the others? Willem Baldwin says that many, many Smiths have been killed by Phoenix. More than Harriet and Circe.
Was the plane crash Daniel Smith the elder died in perhaps not an accident? Was his body ever found?
It is stated that Lawrence’s parents “died of slow grief, mourning his siblings.” This is understandable - three of their children died during their lifetime, and a fourth, while safe, was forever beyond their reach; they never saw Hyacinth again.
But could their deaths have been...helped along, perhaps?
What about any other Smiths? How did the parents of Albert Smith, Cyrus’s grandfather, die? Did he have any siblings?
The Smiths seem to have been very notorious within the Order of Brendan for a family who was only properly reinstated within the last generation, for their members to have been targeted by Phoenix so much.
Either that, or Willem Baldwin was just trying to brag and intimidate Cyrus.