Scar Tissue - A Henry Cavill Fan Fiction
Warnings: 18 +, implied smut, breakups, anxiety MDNI
Authorโs note: Itโs been a while since I wrote fan fiction. I hope itโs good! Any other warnings I need to add, please let me know!
The heavy rumble of the train isn't loud enough to drown out the static fuzzing across the grooves on my brain. I flit between closing my eyes against the stimuli โ the laughing families, the groups of friendsโฆ the couples, and taking in the beautiful countryside. For a Tuesday, the train is relatively busy, which is irksome since the only reason I am travelling on a weekday is to avoid these annoying crowds. There arenโt any bank holidays, as far as I am aware, so why are all of these people here? Why am I here?
I lean my head against the window, extend my legs out, going as far as to sneak my foot up onto the empty seat facing me. Iโm not supposed to. Societal custom dictates it. The train conductor dictates it. But society has pissed me off today by being on this train, which I was sure was going to be empty. I can just take my foot away if the conductor comes along. I keep my headphones on, even though Iโm not listening to anything. I want to give off an air of mystery because even though I donโt want to admit to myself, I want someone to notice me today. Someone to flirt with me and I want to act coy in response. Itโs not a newly single thing, because I wanted that to happen even when I was with Matt.
I shift in my seat at the thought. I donโt want to think about how Matt should have broken off things with me rather than the other way around. I donโt want to be in love. I want to be in the idea of love. I donโt know. I just want to get there now. This is taking too long.
Keeping my head against the glass, I watch the countryside morph into a small dwelling with cute houses. I spot their Main Street where all the shops are, the one pub that probably closes at 11. I let myself smile at the domesticity of it. This will be good for me, I think. Living in the city has made me angrier. Numb to all things good. Maybe the simple life with the one street with all the shops, the designated pub, the one decent restaurant is exactly what I need. Somewhere nobody knows me and there arenโt any places for me to be found.
The train ambles onto another stop in its route to its destination. I donโt bother looking for any signs that indicate where we are. I counted the number of stations between where I started and where I need to get off and after this one, there are four stops left. I look beyond the people lining up at the doors into the station itself.
Itโs small. One of those where there are only two platforms. Small town, small station, small houses. Small life? Surely not. I bet itโs one of those places where the kids graduate school, go out to uni in the nearest city thinking itโs the start of their lives only to find out that they miss their one cafe where they hung out with their friends. Or where those kids came back, met someone they went to school with but never spoke to them until right then, fell in love and stayed. Because at their core, people want to love and be loved. Everyone has their version of the ideal domestic life and almost always, it involves another person who prioritises them and loves them. What the hell is wrong with me that I can have all of that and not want it?
I donโt have time to dwell on it, because there is a massive hand waving in front of my face, wrenching me away from my thoughts. Couldnโt have come sooner, I was ready to spiral out completely. Without looking up, I take my foot off the seat in front of me, thinking the man just needs a place to sit. I sit up straighter in my seat to give him more space for his own legs.
From the corner of my eye, I see a large figure settle in the spot where my foot had been. I sneak a glance at his face to see if heโs looking at me. He isnโt. What he is, is fucking handsome and built like brick shithouse.
He is also Henry goddamned Cavill. My knee starts bouncing, and I know he sees it. Without looking directly at him, I place a hand on it to get it to stop. He used to do that when Iโd rest my legs on his lap and theyโd start shaking. I shiver a bit.
Should I say something? Would it be cute if I gave him a smile? Or would he think Iโm some stalker?
From what I apprize of him with a quick look, the years have caught up to him. He still looks great. But there is aโฆ tiredness that has settled under his eyes. Has he seen me? Silly question, of course, he has. Does he recognize me? He probably does, and he isnโt saying anything because he doesnโt want to stir up the past. Or he doesnโt want to get caught up in the whirlwind of neediness that was the nineteen-year-old me. Iโd laugh if that thought didnโt make me want to cry. Iโd move if the train wasnโt filling up. Or if it didnโt seem like I was moving because of him.
God, I wish heโd look at me and smile. He knows heโs pretty so I canโt be coy with him. I avert my eyes again. It feels like a cruel joke. Itโs not like I donโt know what he looks like naked. But here he is, sat right in front of me, close enough that I could touch his foot with mine, if that wasnโt the creepiest move in the world, and I canโt even look at him. If I do, then heโll eventually look at me and see another fan. Worse, heโll recognize me as the undergrad he once slept with ages ago. If I look at him, I might actually try to flirt with him. I put a hand on my knee to make stop bouncing, uncontrollably. If it wasnโt super obvious, I would have pressed two fingers on my pulse to check my heart rate to confirm that itโs beating so hard that it makes my ribs hurt.
Fuck, is this punishment?
The next hour goes by much in the same way as the rest of the trip. The only exception is that more and more people stop at my seat, either to ogle at the movie star in front of me (who wouldnโt) or to just go up to him to ask for a picture or an autograph. I keep my headphones on and pretend to sleep, so nobody would ask me to take the picture for them. God, why am I like this? Just say hi. Or I could tell him that I get it. Iโm a lot to deal with and itโs okay. That would be weird if I said that. I keep quiet.
Matt always said that I always psyched myself out of a good thing. I tried doing it when I had been writing my first book and god knows, Iโd done it before I started querying agents. Much like this situation, I had asked myself, do you really think this is going to work? Itโs not a story. I have no control, here. I have no control anywhere. Whatโs the point? It had been Matt to convince me to do it. And despite all of that, I couldnโt bring myself to love him the way he loved me.
My eyes snap open, and I bristle in my seat for a moment. I donโt think itโs big enough to disturb anyone around me, but my sudden movement catches his attention. I can tell that I have eyes on me, in my peripheral vision. Iโm probably making it up. My brain doing its brain things. I donโt turn. I barely breathe. After what feels like eternity, the train begins to amble to a halt at my destination.
I get up before it stops completely. I feel the heat of someoneโs attention at the back of my neck. I shake my head, convincing myself to get out of la la land. Heโs not looking at me. Itโs a struggle to get to the baggage hold, weaving through people. Living in a major megapolis for the better part of ten years has made it easier to shirk off the guilt of being rude. So, I gently place my palm on strange shoulders to signal them out of my way. I feel their annoyance directed at me when they have to squeeze in the limited space to let me pass. I wish I could tell them I feel it too. But theyโre strangers, and theyโre probably going to the countryside for a relaxing holiday rather than tucking tail and scrambling for a fresh start somewhere nobody knows them. So I keep it to myself.
Luggage secured, Iโm ready to make a break for it once these doors finally open. City life has made it so that my nerve endings feel like theyโre on fire. There are no deadlines, no opening hours or appointments that I am late for. Iโm still bouncing on the ball of my toes. Iโm going to need to take a cab. Iโm going to have to get a car, eventually. I donโt like driving. Maybe a motorbike. Can I afford one? Is it feasible to just have a motorbike? What about groceries?
The train doors opening interrupt the beginning of my spiral. I hop out on the platform, lugging my two huge suitcases. Everything is a tick box exercise. Eyes forward, ticket scanned, cab stand located. The air is cleaner, but I donโt take the time to appreciate it. I jump into a cab, rattle off the post code and sit back. The driver begins talking to me, asking where Iโm coming from, have I been here before? I keep my answers short. People are chatty here. Itโs the polite thing to do, and itโs what you do when all the hurry in your life has dwindled away in the country air. Iโll need to remember that.
Maybe a motorbike isnโt the worst idea, after all.
When the driver catches on that I am not one of the chatty ones, he quiets down and rolls down his window. The cleaner air stings against my skin, laying goosebumps in its wake. The view is more of the same from the train. Grass, houses, some cows. I see horses, too. I smile and give them a little wave. The houses make me think about whatโs inside them. Years of memories and care, probably. Everything carefully placed, every space with a purpose. My own house, purchased in a hurry, not to mention, exorbitantly marked up than asking price, is blank. Do I have the same care to fill it in these ways? Matt did most of the decorating at the flat in London.
He bought flowers for the balconies. Petunias, because I had asked for something colourful. I never asked him what flowers he wanted. Did he take them with him when he left? I never checked. Maybe I should have taken the sofa. Or the bed, but he bought that too. He cared. So much. Why couldnโt I? Fuck.
Thereโs a loud buzz and I lose my train of thought again. Iโm glad to, but it takes me a second to remember where I am. Itโs a text from Margo. Sheโs checking in. Because she cares too.
Margs: Are you there yet?
Me: Almost. In cab.
Margs: Decent journey?
I start to type out the words to tell her about how Henry fucking Cavill was sat right in front of me. But I delete it halfway. I lived on this womanโs sofa for over two months while I sorted out this move. My escape, more like. I want to tell her about our history, and that I wanted to flirt with him. That I feel so silly for wanting to flirt with him. But sheโs probably had enough of my boy drama for a while, I think.
Me: Not too bad. Slept most of the way.
I put my phone away and donโt check when it buzzes again. My minds too fuzzy to comprehend anything right now. Maybe when I actually feel something, Iโll respond to her. To the number of friends who found out about the break-up and have been checking in. Asking if Iโm okay. Asking if I need anything.
Silence. Thatโs what I want to tell them I require. Quiet and peace. But itโs rude. I also donโt know how I need to be right now. I know I should be sad about it, but I am decidedly not sad. Not about not being with him, any more. That part is a bit of a relief actually, but theyโre expecting sadness. A broken me that they can help put back together. Itโs too complicated to tell them that I am broken in a different way to what theyโre expecting. That more than anything, I feel nothing, and I am scared that itโs all I will ever feel.
Margo gets it. Sort of. She gave me space when I stayed with her. Talked to me about books and food and only brought up Matt when she saw me looking out into space, thinking I was thinking of him.
I had been thinking of him, actually. But not in the way that she thought. I had been thinking about whether I should tell him the truth. That I could have lived with the drinking, which is why I told him that I was breaking up with him, but I couldnโt live with the feeling that this whole thing was wrong. That every time I thought about my life ten years from now, he was nowhere near that picture. That would be cruel. Best to let sleeping dogs lie, I had told her. She had gone quiet, then. I knew she didnโt know what to say to that. Maybe Margo started looking at me differently, then. For now though, she still cares enough to check in.
I take my phone out to check her last text.
Margs: Let me know if you want to have a call later
I smile a little.
Me: I will
By the time I look up, the cab has pulled into a cul-de-sac, and it stops at the little mews house that I recognize as my own. I have a house now. Itโs not massive, which I like. It actually has a back and front garden. There arenโt any neighbours in the strictest of sense. No houses beside my property, but a few scattered about, so itโs not abandoned. When I step out of the cab, I see another car pull up to another house on the street.
The cabbie has pulled out my heavy suitcases from the boot by the time I have turned around. I hand him the cash, the man smiles politely, tells me to have a pleasant evening. I say thank you and smile back. Heโs back in his car before he can see it though. Itโs fine. Maybe I should have chatted to him a bit more. Asked him his name or something. But heโs reversing out of the driveway now.
I hear another car door slam shut, and I know itโs my neighbour. I could say hello. It would be the polite thing to do. Only, the person who steps out of the vehicle is him. Blood rushes down my legs, and my spine stiffens. There he bloody is. He definitely sees me, because heโs looking right at me. No pretending I donโt see him now, frozen as I am in place. Ice water is spilling across my back, and Iโm not sure whether Iโm not breathing enough or too much.
Shakily, I raise an arm and lift up a hand in a silent wave. Thatโsโฆ polite. Right? When he does the same, his eyes are wide and eyebrows upturned, as though caught by surprise.
Does he think Iโm here for him?
Shit. He probably does. Thatโs what this looks like.
It looks like I am not over our little fling from way back when, and that I have followed him here. Wait. I couldnโt have followed him because I got here first. He followed me. No, he definitely lives here. His front garden is all done up, unlike the mews house behind me. Iโve only come up here once for a quick walk around before I put in my offer. It had been the middle of the day. There had been people on the streets, none of them had been him.
Shit. Shit. SHIT.
He takes a step towards my direction. I move. Without looking at him, I pull the handles on my suitcase and roughly pull them. The gravel under our feet gives me some resistance, but I yank, needing to get away from this. Usually, Matt would have taken the heavy bags, but he isnโt here. Because I left him. Henry is here. After I tucked his memory away in a box and shoved it into the back corner of my mind. And now itโs crawling out. The memoryโs cold tendrils are beginning to fog my mind, slowing my thoughts, causing chills along my arms, my legs, my chest.
I hear another crunch of the gravel. It isnโt me or my bags. Iโve turned away from him to pull the suitcases towards the house, but heโs behind me. I squeeze my eyes shut and open them again.
โYou need help?โ His voice is so deep. I remember thinking that when we first met. I think it every time I see him in something. I remember telling him that night when he had taken my earlobe between his lips. Heโd chuckled a bit, and heโd continued to kiss down my throat. His voice changes when he moans. Iโd told him that, too. Heโd smirked. Heโd probably thought of me as naive, little thing who was somewhat amusing.
My jaw stiffens.
โHey.โ I say, not responding to his question. Finally, looking at him, his expression doesnโt give away anything. โJust need to get these in there. Iโll be okay.โ
โYou sure?โ Voice like honey, it sets my teeth on edge and my blood on fire, โthey look heavy. Are you moving in?โ
โYep.โ A response to both questions. Good. Small responses. Anything more and he will know that I am a mess in front of him. Be strong, carefree, unbothered, I tell myself. Did I seem unbothered on the train though, or did I shuffle too much? If I did, did he notice? Did he think it was because of him?
โWelcome to the neighbourhood.โ He says with his usual ease, slips his hands in his pockets and justโฆ stands there. I wait for him to say something else, because it looks like there is something else he wants to say. I could break the tension by asking him something or say anything else, but I donโt want to. I sort of want him to stew in this feeling. Like I had on the train or when I used to check my phone incessantly, waiting for his next text, โHow have you been?โ
There is both tension and relief that flood through me and I canโt decide which one I should focus on. I was convinced that he didnโt remember me. Is it relief? Or some elation of the validation that I was a decent enough lay that he at least remembers my face. But I canโt tell him the truth to answer his question. Not if I want to seem unbothered. I am, of course, extremely bothered. I am nothing if not just so, so bothered.
โBeen fine.โ Iโve ceased yanking on my suitcase and the lack of movement is making me want to break into a sprint away from him, โBought my first house.โ I gesture with my head, to the house behind me.
โWow. Congratulations.โ
I nod. I should ask him how heโs been. I donโt want to know, though.
โHow about you?โ I ask, anyway. My forefingerโs nail starts to scratch at the plastic handle that is still in my death-grip, โhowโs all the acting and stuff going?โ
He chuckles lightly. The same one as before. My toes curl in my shabby sneakers.
โItโs going well.โ He says, โI just wrapped a project.โ
โIโll be sure to catch it when it comes out.โ I say without thinking. I want to hide my face in my now-sweating palms. He just nods. I wait for him to turn around and leave. He doesnโt.
โWell, Iโd betterโฆโ I trail off as means to end the conversation. When he only smiles wider in response, I turn, beginning to yank my suitcase again. When it barely budges, I curse under my breath. Can I at least exude some semblance of coolness? Please?
Another chuckle. If I hadnโt had the last few months I had, or if my brain was someone elseโs brain, I would have found it cute. But right now, it makes me want to scream into a pillow. Or take a bat to something big and expensive. Like his car.
โAre you sure, I cannot help you?โ I hear him say behind me. I sigh. Unbothered. Calm. Collected.
You are an author. You have a four-book deal. You bought this house with your own money. You are independent. You are not less than him just because he is older, better-looking, or more suave than you.
A moment of consideration.
But these bags are fucking heavy, and youโll be here all night if you do this by yourself. My internal voice concedes. Traitor.
Another sigh. One of resignation.
โIf you could grab the other end there and help me get it up to the porch, that would be very appreciated.โ My voice is squeaky. I hate this.
He nods and gets to work. Grabbing the other end of the bag I was just fighting with. He lifts it up with nothing more than a slight oof sound. The other bag abandoned, we both begin to lug the one weโre carrying towards the front porch. I put in as much effort as I can. The train journey, despite being seated for most of it, has taken a lot out of me. The summer day is nowhere near ending and the sky is as blue as it can be, but the earlier heft I felt in my body hasnโt left me. If anything, my bones feel heavier now.
We get to my front door, eventually. I turn to get my other bag too, but heโs beat me to it. Heโs already jogged to where it is, and is now picking it up with one hand, muscles flexing and veins popping.
โI would have helped!โ I scold when he plops it down on its wheels in front of me, โwhat about your leg?โ
He has a bum knee. Heโd told me that during one of our text-conversations. Weโd been flirting, or I think we had been. I thought I had been flirting. Ribbing playfully by calling him old, and he had probably thought it was rude and annoying. It was probably the latter. I shouldnโt have mentioned it.
โEh, itโs fine.โ He says, โIโve had lots of physical therapy.โ
I hum in response. Right. What now? Heโs still standing there. Does he want me to invite him inside? No, right? Because why would he want that? Unless he wants another โcasual thingโ, as he had called it then. Surely not. We canโt do the casual thing, now that weโre neighbours. Unless we can? No, that doesnโt work for me. I know that. Why would I even consider it?
โSo, Iโll let youโโ He starts to say.
โI would โโ I say at the same time.
We both stop. He gives me an embarrassed smile. I return it. He nods at me to silently tell me to say my thing, first. Now, I donโt want to.
โOh, I was just going to say โ um โ Iโd invite you in for coffee or something, but I have no furniture or appliances or anything.โ
โOh,โ he shuffles on his feet. Itโs the first sign of any discomfort he has shown in this entire interaction. Which is odd. I donโt think Iโve said anything to put him off-ease. Unlessโฆ Wait, shit, does he think I want to invite him inside as inโฆ invite him inside? But Iโve just said I canโt invite him inside. But itโs in his head now, isnโt it? Also, is he uncomfortable because he wanted to be invited inside, and Iโve told him no, or because he wasnโt even thinking about it and Iโve โ
โNo, thatโs okay.โ He cuts off my spiralling. Still not clear about whether he wanted or explicitly didnโt want an invitation into my house, โYou probably want to rest after a long journey, I suppose.โ
I guess thatโs true too. I donโt say that. Instead, I repeat the lie I texted to Margo, earlier, โThe journey was fine. I slept most of the way.โ
โNo, you didnโt.โ His response is instant, and it makes my stomach drop, โYour eyes might have been closed, but you werenโt sleeping.โ
Son. Of. A. Bitch.
โHow would you know?โ I challenge.
Heโs back to smirking. He doesnโt respond to my question, though. He succeeds in making every nerve-ending in my body snap and bolt in a seething rage. My back teeth grind together a bit more. I should get inside, but heโs making no moves to leave.
Instead, he asks, โYou moving in with someone then or just you?โ
What the hell do you mean by that? Is what I want to ask him as I take a hold of his collar to either shake him or kiss him. Instead, I just ball my hands into fists behind my back, and focus on the feeling of my nails biting into my palm.
โJust me. I moved down for work. Thought it was time to stop living in flats.โ
I donโt tell him that I was living with a boyfriend for the last three years. That we were discussing getting married, what our wedding would look like, who weโd invite. I donโt tell him that I probably dropped the surprise of a lifetime on my almost-fiance when I told him that I wanted to break up. That I am more cruel than he remembers me being. Or that Iโve grown up and wonโt be chasing him like I used to. The words feel like theyโre seared into my scalp, but they donโt materialize on my tongue.
โOh yeah?โ He continues like this is just a friendly, neighbourly chat. Like I havenโt had his thumb and other appendages in my mouth. Like he hasnโt seen me on my knees, โwhat do you do now? I donโt think Iโve ever asked.โ
Itโs an effort not to bite back, You havenโt. โI was working in public relations. Nothing fancy, just corporate reputation stuff. But Iโm doing something else now.โ
He looks at me, expectantly, silently asking me to go on.
With a small smile I say, โI just got a book deal, so I quit my old job -โ and my old life, I donโt say, โ - and Iโm working as a resident author and adjunct professor at the local university.โ
He nods, looking impressed. I ignore the feeling of pride that blooms right at the centre of my chest, erasing the anger that I had felt a moment ago.
โSo youโre an author now?โ
โI guess you can say that now, yesโ I let myself sound a bit smug.
โCongratulationsโฆ again.โ
Another hum. I swing my backpack off a shoulder for two reasons. The first, to dig around and find the keys that had been mailed to me. The second, is to put something in between my body and his. As I dig through the contents of my backpack, grateful that I have something to do with my hands and hinting towards an end to this whole interaction (hey, three reasons!), he still makes no move to get the hell off my porch.
โSo, what are you going to do for food?โ He asks.
โHm?โ Iโm not looking at him. I have my keys in my hand, but I make it look like Iโm still looking for them.
โYou said you have no furniture or appliances or anything,โ He explains, โwhat are you doing for food?โ
โOh, the movers should be here sometime tomorrow morning, but I think tonight is just going to a take away night.โ
โYum.โ
โYum, indeed.โ
Who the fuck talks like this? Carefree. Unbothered. Why is it so hard?
โAny good places around here?โ I ask, finally pulling my keys out, โfor take away, I mean?โ
โWhat are you in the mood for?โ Isnโt he getting tired of this? This is the longest conversation we have had without it getting dirty, or one of us, usually him, having to step away from their phone. It is also the first conversation we have had in a goddamned decade.
โPizza, probablyโ I can find somewhere on the internet. His recommendation does not matter. Why am I still standing here talking about this. Why is he?
โOoh, there is actually this place I always get pizza from, they arenโt online, so โโ He looks at me for half a second before he pulls his phone out, โIโll give you the number.โ
โOh. Um, sure. Thanksโ Is he about to pull up our old text thread? Or has he deleted them? Heat blooms at the back of my neck as I struggle to remember the last text I sent him. I know it was me who sent the last text. He never responded.
โI have a new number now,โ he says as he extends his phone out to me, giving me a sheepish smile, โIโm afraid I didnโt move your contact details over.โ
Asshole. Of course, you didnโt. I give him a tight-lipped smile as I take his phone from him and feed my number in. I could have just pulled my phone out and asked him to dictate this pizza placeโs number to me. That would have been the coquettish thing to do. Might have intrigued him more to keep trying. Damn.
I hand the phone back to him.
A moment later, my phone buzzes in my pocket. I make no move to pull it out.
โThanks.โ I say, โIt better be good, Cavillโ
He chuckles, โIt will be, they donโt do jalapeรฑos on their pizza, though.โ
โSo, youโre saying itโs bad?โ I say with a smile.
โNo,โ Heโs raking a hand through his curls, โtheyโre just Italian and real Italian pizza doesnโt have jalapeรฑos on it.โ
โYeah, that still sounds like โnot goodโ to me.โ Am I being too annoying with this? Is it going too far? Where does it stop being banter, and where does it become plain rude? He just gave me the name of his favourite pizza place. Why canโt I just say thank you? Why canโt I just invite him for a slice?
โJust because you like to burn your mouth off every time you eat something, doesnโt mean the rest of us do.โ His tone is still playful. He doesnโt sound pissed off. He doesnโt even sound like he wants to leave. But he should.
โWell, not everyone has my spice tolerance.โ I say, turning around and sliding the key into the door, โcause everyone else is a wuss.โ
I hear him laugh a little louder at that one. As nice as this is, I canโt let myself get too comfortable here. Itโs too fucking easy to slip back into old habits, especially with Cavill. And now heโs going to be so close. All the time. I get the door unlocked, but donโt open it.
โWellโฆโ I say with a finality, โit was nice to see you.โ
โRight, yeah.โ He looks down at his feet, โIโll see you around.โ
โYep.โ
He nods. Again, not moving. Heโs actually not looking at me at all. I used to do that with Matt, especially at those times when I wanted space from him, and he would just be there. Iโd speak with him about whatever he wanted to speak to me about, but I couldnโt look at him, because I couldnโt find the right words to tell him to leave me alone for an hour or two, without sounding like a bitch. Cavillโs doing the same thing. Only if he wanted space from me, heโd fucking leave.
โWhat?โ I finally ask, โWhat is it?โ
โOh โโ He looks like a deer caught in headlights. Good. โNothing, I justโfuckโI wanted to see if you wanted to come around for dinner, cause of theโerm, the appliances and things. But youโre getting pizza, so โโ
โYou want to cook for me?โ I ask. Is he nervous because this sounds like a date or is he nervous because asking me might give me the wrong impression?
โNot like โโ He clears his throat, โJust that, if you want a home cooked meal, Iโd be โ erm โ happy to share some of mine.โ
โAre you okay?โ I ask because that sounded like he was going to vomit. Also because I am usually the flustered one in these situations, and itโs nice to be on the other end of it. It definitely is a bit cruel, but seeing as he led me on for almost two years, I think I am somewhat entitled to seeing him a bit flustered.
โYeah, Iโm good.โ He rakes another hand through his hair. He used to do that when we were in bed, talking and joking. I always thought he was tired of me, and that he wanted me to stop talking. But heโs done it twice now, and heโs the one who isnโt moving off my front porch, โSoโฆ how about it?โ
โYou cooking for me?โ I check.
He nods. Heโs still not looking at me. I wait until he does.
โWhat are you making?โ I canโt say yes off the bat. I really want to. But he canโt know that yet.
โI was going to make some linguine with a garlic confit butter. I donโt have any meat, otherwise I would have smoked some steaks on The egg.โ
โThe egg?โ I know what heโs talking about. Of course, I do. Iโve seen his instagram.
โOh itโs just a fancy grill.โ
โAh.โ I simply say. This is fun. โFancy.โ
โI can run out and get some steaks if you want?โ
How has this happened? How have I become the person who makes Cavill nervous?
โThatโs okay.โ I say, feeling a bit bad about how Iโve been toying with him, โthe pasta sounds delicious. I can have bland pizza another time.โ
โHey, they have good pizza.โ He says. I might have been nervous that I have offended him, but heโs smiling, so I know heโs being playful, โYou donโt have to make everything spicy.โ
I grin. He looks away again.
โI need to take a shower, though.โ I tell him, finally turning the door handle โIโll come over in a few hours?โ
โSure.โ
โGreat.โ Iโve swung the door open.
โOkay then.โ I wheel one of the bags into the house.
โRight.โ
โWonderful.โ The other bag is in.
โMagnificent.โ That one makes me giggle. He laughs too.
โIโm closing the door now, Cavill.โ I tell him, peaking through the narrowing creek of my front door.
โOkay.โ Heโs still standing there.
โGet off my porch and get cooking.โ I tell him before I finally close the door.
I hear another laugh from the other side. I smile.
I have a warm, fuzzy feeling inside my chest. It lasts for about a minute or so before my smile drops. Is this a date? Another hook up? Should I shave my legs?
Fuck.
I pull out my phone to send Margo a quick text. I see the text that Cavill sent with the phone number of the pizza place. Iโm saving his number as a new contact when another text from him pops up.
Cavill: Do you have any allergies? Sorry, should have asked before you kicked me off your porch!
Me: Shellfish.
I try not to smile by using my thumb and forefinger to physically squeeze the sides of my lips. It doesnโt work.
I want to respond to the ribbing too but I refrain. I could say something without being flirty. I am lying to myself โ one doesnโt just rib Henry Cavill without a sexual undertone.
Cavill: Damn, there goes my prawn cake.
I donโt even try containing my smile at that one.
This is familiar. This texting banter. This warm, fuzzy feeling. I have deluded myself into thinking this means something more than it is, before. And coming back down to earth was a crash landing. I canโt do casual. I know this. He knows this. I catch feelings, he doesnโt, and then I end up feeling like ass. Thatโs how it goes, every fucking time. So why is he doing this now?
Matt pops into my head again. Turns out, I canโt do relationships either. Even when they love me like I wanted Cavill to love me. We were in touch for over two years, and he doesnโt even know that I have a shellfish allergy. What does that say about this whole thing? It says that I was nineteen and naive. He was this older, sexier, unattainable person. Not even a person, an idea. Just like I was an idea of a person to Matt.
Matt knew all about my allergy though. He knew everything there was to know about me. Except the fact that I didnโt love him. What does that say about me?
Another text.
Cavill: Iโm looking forward to seeing you.
Cavill: Again.
Damn. Heโs got me hooked. That will absolutely not do.
