I wanted to request a sort of e2l with Castiel. But they’re not really enemies, maybe reader is way too careless and they end up bickering all the time, until Cas realizes he’s afraid of losing them and has feelings for the reader. Make it fluff/suggestive or however you’re comfortable with, love 🩷
𝐄𝐧𝐞𝐦𝐢𝐞𝐬 𝐭𝐨 𝐋𝐨𝐯𝐞𝐫𝐬, 𝐂𝐚𝐬𝐭𝐢𝐞𝐥
⋆。𖦹°‧★ You meet Castiel through the Winchesters, and don’t hide the fact that you do not trust angels. They’ve been historically absent when humanity needed them most, and you've lost faith.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ Castiel resents you because you confirm his worst insecurities. You acknowledge his every failure, and it rattles him. He tried to be cordial at the start, but celestial or not, the way your lip curls in distaste wears him down. Eventually, he goes stony too, matching your ice with his own.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ Sam and Dean awkwardly try to build morale, but nothing works. You and Cas will stand on opposite ends of the room and refuse to acknowledge each other at all.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ Your passion for the hunt makes you reckless, and often results in injury. Castiel offers to heal you once, and you recoil before he can. “Don’t touch me,” you growl, scrambling back on a twisted ankle. “Not unless you want to lose those wings.” After that, he stops offering, which only pisses you off more. He pretends indifference, but your aversion upsets him.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ Later, Cas asks Dean about your behavior. Dean tells him about your past. The unanswered prayers and silence when you called for guidance, and Castiel goes still. Suddenly, the bickering feels foolish. His place is to guide and protect, not indulge in rivalry. Somewhere along the way, he forgot himself.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ After that, he’s different. He steps between you and danger reflexively. When you’re angry, he tries for peace, stepping close to disarm the line you’ve kept so fiercely. His eyes meet yours, and his disdain has vanished. You snap, “Why do you care what I think of you?” And he replies earnestly, “Because your faith would mean more to me than Heaven’s.”
⋆。𖦹°‧★ You stop refusing his grace. Part of you wants to trust him. The first time he heals your broken ribs, you shudder hard, breath catching at the surge his touch produces against your skin. Your hand slips over his, and he studies you piously. His palm slides up your torso to rest over your heart, and you feel a tremor in his wrist. The light in his eyes softens. “You can let go,” you say. “I don’t want to,” he murmurs back.
⋆。𖦹°‧★ When he kisses you, he wants to forget the bad blood and start fresh. He leans down where you lie, forearms braced on either side of you. He whispers your name lovingly, and for the very first time, you whisper his back with faith.
A bit different from the initial request. Thanks so much for sending it in, anon!