#burlexe

Originally published by Burlexe in April 2012. Link to the original article here.

After all the hype and anticipation, the numbers are in and the odds are in Katniss Everdeen's favour. The first feature film instalment of The Hunger Games is raking in millions at the box office and critics have been largely positive, especially regarding its star, Jennifer Lawrence, who has carved a new role as heterosexual pin-up and acceptable girl crush in the hearts of cinema-goers worldwide. You could call her The New Megan Fox, if you're into that sort of thing. But is she also the new poster girl for female empowerment? Is Katniss a guiding light for young girls lost in a patriarchal labyrinth? It's a lot of pressure for someone so distracted by trying to stay alive. Still, at least she's doing a better job than Bella Swan.

Comparisons between The Hunger Games and Twilight are inevitable - both are franchises based on books aimed at a young adult readership with hoards of teenage fans. Both have enjoyed incredible box office success. The urge to compare and contrast heroines Katniss and Bella is too strong to resist, as a quick Google search will prove, but it has to be done - so sit down and buckle up. If young people find role models in popular culture, and they do, then it stands to reason many will look to Twilight, having nothing else of equal scale. There hasn't been such a phenomenon since Harry Potter, which for all its majesty is male centric and offers an uninspiring idol in the bookish, sexless, serial teller-offer Hermione. Twilight's Bella is easier to identify with given her startling lack of character - the few descriptions offered in the original text are delightfully vague and could apply to almost any teenage girl, and even when transferred to the big screen and given Kristen Stewart's face she doesn't exactly sparkle (pun intended). There's nothing to aspire to beyond the possibility of supernatural romance and being so inexplicably captivating that powerful, dangerous boys will fight over you. I feel so very sorry for any girl growing up wanting to be Bella. But it's OK that she's in what is tantamount to an abusive relationship because he's drawn to her, yeah? Of course she should beg him to hurt her because he LOVES HER, yeah? Of course she wants to be domesticated - isn't that the point of having a fanny?

Sent into the cinemas in the break between Breaking Dawn parts 1 and 2, The Hunger Games's brand new female-centric franchise is a welcome injection of spirit, presenting Katniss as a face of rebellion to counteract Bella's pouty subservience. She is a tough cookie: brave and resourceful and more than capable of looking after herself. Suzanne Collins's text plays around with gender subversion, giving Katniss the hunting skills while her male counterpart sticks to baking and icing cakes. The romantic elements of her story haven't been key to its promotion - perhaps this is helping to attract a broader range of viewers, but it also reflects the heroine's own mind, which is rarely occupied by thoughts of romance. Whatever the reasoning, Lionsgate are onto a winner: the opening weekend grossed $155 million and was the third-best debut of all time. Both Katniss and her non-fictional alter ego have been catapulted into our collective conscious, and with three more films lined up, both look set for pop culture glory. If a hugely influential pop star (*cough* RIHANNA) will go back to a man who beat her up, then we could do with a bona fide action hero to knock some sense into everyone.

Having said that, The Hunger Games is not a feminist manifesto: Katniss is a likeable lead and a decent role model but there's nothing here to push any boundaries. There may be a lack of Twilight's abstinence porn narrative, but it's not exactly a hive of sexual activity either - if Katniss experiences any sexual desire, she keeps it secret from even herself. She seems unaware of the concept of birth control, which is incongruous (come on, they're in THE FUTURE) and downright unfair, given that access to condoms would make her life choices a hell of a lot easier. She spends much of the series declaring the traditional route of marriage and motherhood disagreeable but (spoiler alert) ends up following it anyway. To take Katniss Everdeen as a true example of female empowerment doesn't stretch to much beyond women possessing some typically masculine qualities and kicking some ass before whimpering a bit and apathetically conforming to the traditional female role. Ellen Ripley she ain't.