SSL: When I check via browser i get my purchased godaddy certificate, but when i check with openssl i get a self-signed certificate?

I have a website that has a valid wildcard certificate from Godaddy. When I view it in my browser I get a valid secure certificate (green padlock) and when I examine the certificate within the browser it says secure and signed by godaddy and everything appears normal.

However, if I use openssl s_client -connect my.site.com:443

I get a self signed certificate:

issuer=/C=AU/ST=Some-State/O=Inter…