Keen viewers of the Late Show with David Letterman were well aware of Bill Scheft â pictured above in pre-beard times â not only as a longtime writer on the show but also for his self-described role as Lettermanâs âcorner man,â stationed to the hostâs left off-camera (and sometimes on), then huddling with Dave during commercial breaks. Scheft, an avid sports fan, novelist and rock-and-roll drummer, chatted with us about his nearly two decades working on the Late Show and those âheadyâ days before Letterman retired one year agoâŚ
How has life been since the show ended? It was an abrupt transition as a viewer and fan so I can only imagine what it was like for you and other staff.
The biggest transition, and the one I think a lot of us are still getting used to, is not seeing the people you saw every day for so long. I mean, Iâve known and worked closely with Barbara [Gaines], Jude Brennan, Kathy Mavrikakis and Steve Young since the day I walked into 30 Rock in October 1991. Iâve known Nancy Agostini since she was 20 years old and she was the first writersâ intern at NBC and living in an all-womenâs hotel.
You have no idea how large a chunk of peopleâs lives this show was. When Dave had his 30-year anniversary in late night in 2012, we did a Top Ten comprised of staffers whoâd been there the longest. I was not even close to making the list.
In terms of the show itself, now that itâs over, so is the urgency in getting it on the air every night. I started as a newspaperman, and I always said the show was a combination of a daily newspaper, a weekly magazine and a monthly magazine. We would write stuff for that day, for the end of the week, and with the big prop pieces (like Halloween costumes), weâd do them three months in advance. Thereâs a velocity in working on the show that you take for granted because itâs your normal pace. The only time it remotely sunk in before this was after I came back from my hip replacement (July 2008) and I was on the floor the first day with my cane and my titanium implant and I couldnât believe how fast everyone was moving around me.
Any insider tidbit you can give us from your years at that spot beside him at the desk?
My job was just to keep him loose during the commercials. One time, he said to me he had just come from the ophthalmalogist. I said, âHowâd it go?â He said, âThe guy said I wasnât producing enough tears.â I said, âHave you thought about working for yourself?â
Any thoughts or particular reflections from that last day and show a year ago (May 20)?
No. I got it all down when I wrote my last diary post (âEnd of Davesâ) on my blog: (Final) Show Diary of Stuff Noteworthy Only to Me, Day 28 (End of Daves). Nothing more to add.
Is there one show or moment during that final run of shows that has stuck with you more than others?
Well, I started as a stand-up, so Norm Macdonaldâs last set, in which he closed with a line of Daveâs, was beyond perfect. The one thing comics love is when another comic does one of their bits to them. And that he got choked up doing it. Dave never understood how much other comics admired him.
The two other moments, interestingly enough, were both musical. John Mayer doing âAmerican Pie,â which was Daveâs idea, and the booking of Hootie and the Blowfish. Did I love that. We had them on like seven times in 1994 with different cuts from that first album, and to have them back was, I thought, an inspired piece of booking by Sheila Rogers, who did phenomenal work the last three months.
How did you and the staff take the barrage of media during those weeks? The show was receiving high levels of appreciation, which must have felt good and perhaps overdue.
It was a little heady. And, of course, it was lovely to have the show discussed for its content rather than the nonsense of ratings, which you have no control over. That said, I always felt Dave never got the credit for all the moments he created nightly.
I know you didnât want to comment much during the final run of Late Shows. And many were asked about Lettermanâs influence and the showâs. So how would you have answered that question for yourself, his and the showâs influence / significance?
I didn't answer it because it was Daveâs moment. Jerry Foley, the director, said a great thing. He said that by the time we were done, Dave and all of us will have left nothing on the table. So, the most satisfying thing is that we all went out knowing that there was nothing to regret. And when you saw more than a few reviewers use the word âperfectâ to describe the last show, that clinched it. And, of course, that explains why we won the EmmyâŚ. Oh, wait. We didnât. Never mind.
As for the showâs influence and significance, I hope Iâm wrong, but I donât think it will ever overcome the echo chamber of âIt was brilliant at NBC, then he sold out, then he got sick, then he got liberal, then he got in trouble, then he phoned it inâŚ.â The guy was on the air for 33 years. If you saw him on NBC when you were in college, youâre over 50 now. Youâve aged, and you resent it. So, the show canât possibly be as good and he canât be as good as when you first discovered each other. I fervently disagree. His weak points at NBC (monologue, interviewing) became his strongest points at CBS. His comedic sensibility adapted as he became older and the world changed. You can make the argument that he took many more chances as time went on. And as for the distraction of Leno? I like what Michael Keaton said. Words to the effect of âI like that Dave was number 2. It makes more sense, given that he was always up against it.â
Have you seen Letterman in person since? Any secret plans to do a Web version of the Late Show?
Iâve seen him twice. And the secret Web version is so secret Iâm not involved.
What were your favourite moments or guests during your time on the show? Youâre a huge sports fan so maybe an athlete. Those often seemed to give Letterman the biggest thrill.
When Paul McCartney was on, I wanted to say something to him during the break that no one else had ever said. What are the odds? So, I went up to him and said, âThanks for tonight. And thanks for everything before tonight.â And he looked at me and said, âAre you a writer?â And I said, âYes.â And he said, âHow did I know that?â And we both really laughed. And John Filo, the show photographer, got itâŚ.
What are you up to these days? I know you have a band, The Truants, and have published several books â any new works in the offing? (And one of your titles was The Ringer, which is the name of Bill Simmonsâ new website. Did his people get in touch with your people about that?)
I am working on two novels. One is the extension of the serial about bust-out comic Tommy Dash that I started on Nikki Finkeâs show-biz fiction website Hollywood Dementia. The other is a sequel to The Ringer, entitled Through The Ringer. And no, Bill Simmonsâ people did not get in touch with me. They donât have to. That's how big he is. I have one regret, and thatâs not buying the domain theringer.com in 2002. But who did that kind of thing in 2002?
Thoughts about the late-night scene since Letterman retired? Feel free to be as candid, even snarky, as youâd like.
Obviously, itâs a different sensibility. But this is what works now. It is not geared toward a 59-year-old Jew, but what is, other than high fiber? I will say, I like what Seth Meyers is doing.
Finally, any statement on Lettermanâs current look? Everyone has an opinion, it seems.
The only thing I can tell you is that he loves that everyone seems to hate it. Loves it.
Brian Teta
Barbara Gaines
Gerard Mulligan
Randy Cohen (part 1) (part 2)
Tom Shales
Don Giller & David Yoder