Can I request jealous Agatha x fem reader? Reader and reader’s friend aren’t doing nothing even remotely romantic, Agatha is just over analyzing everything they do together and driving themselves crazy over it
Thank you so much for this request!!! I really hope you enjoy the way I wrote it <3
Staying In
Agatha Harkness x Reader
summary: when you insist on going out with a friend who is clearly into you, Agatha takes matters into her own hands
tags: red flags with hints of mutual obsession, Mistress Agatha, sub Reader, jealous Agatha, magic bondage, light impact play, overstimulation, fingering
Words: 2,066
authors note: suspend your disbelief for not having a crush on Darcy. I’ve had to as well 😔
she/her pronouns used to refer to r
ao3 | masterlist
You’ve decided that Agatha is being silly. Mainly because her being insecure feels impossible. You aren’t into Darcy. You have never been into Darcy. It’s never even crossed your mind. Something Agatha is well aware of and yet she insists that something is there. At least on Darcy’s end. Which you highly doubt since she would have said something during the decade you’ve known her.
“It doesn’t matter,” you finally snap at her. “Despite what you may believe Agatha, I am my own person. I’m going to go to a nice restaurant with my nice friend and have a nice, platonic night with her.”
Agatha’s face goes blank in a way that makes you nervous. It turning into a slow smirk has you shifting on your feet. Agatha is rarely wrong. It’s a fact that you usually enjoy. Right now it’s too hard to think of your best friend seeing things differently to accept it. Plus, the fact that you have zero interest in Darcy and Agatha has made her claim very clear should defuse things. And yet.
“It’s not what you think, Agatha,” you insist.
“Of course, dear,” she says with that same deadly look and you swallow harshly.
You have to look away otherwise that traitorous warmth inside you is going to take over your rational brain. It’s not fair that she still has such a strong effect on you when you’re frustrated with her.
“I think I’ll retire to my lab for the night,” she says, already turning. You enjoy your nice night.”
You fight the urge to follow her and instead watch her go quietly. That had been a little too easy, especially with your earlier claim. You’re both well aware of how deeply Agatha owns you.
You only debate with yourself for a moment before moving to get ready. Your and Darcy’s schedules haven’t lined up enough for a proper meal for weeks. You’re both busy enough it’s likely to take even longer for them to line up again. You can survive one night of Agatha’s wrath.
—————-
Every other item you try to use disappears. It starts out subtle. Some things not being where you thought you left them, others being in odd but not impossible spots. It escalates until your perfume disappears right out of your hand.
“Agatha!” you finally shout in frustration.
Of course, you don’t get an answer. She’s three floors away. Not that it stops her from watching you but she so does love plausible deniability.
You’re about to rummage through her own drawers (more to make a mess than anything) when her personal perfume bottle appears in a little puff of purple smoke right in front of you. You huff a laugh. Of course.
You don’t try and refuse it. Or deny how much you want it. Every bit of Agatha entices you. Her scent is no different. Even if the perfume doesn’t quite contain every hint of her, it’s enough of a reward for her to use it against you often.
It’s hard to concentrate with her scent surrounding you but it’s something you have to contend with every time you’re around her. You have enough practice to still complete your goal, just not without thinking about her every time you take a breath.
Since Agatha has yet to bind you to the bed, you believe you’re consequence free, at least until you return home. Then you reach the door. The handle turns but the door doesn’t open. You try to flick the lock but it doesn’t move. Frowning, you try to tug it free but it’s too small to get a good grip. It jiggles a little but remains stuck. It’s weird and annoying but nothing Agatha can’t fix. Later. It’s not the best idea to go down to her lair while you still want to leave.
A thought crosses your mind but you don’t genuinely believe it until the back door does the same thing. She really has locked you in. You prefer it when she throws you into bed and traps you there. Huffing, you wonder if it would be too crazy to go out the window. It feels too crazy, and a bit silly. You aren’t a teenager anymore and this is technically also your house.
Instead of creeping out of a window, you creep down the stairs to her basement. While the house may equally be yours, Agatha’s lair is entirely her own. It’s a dangerous place for anyone that isn’t Agatha.
She’s standing at one of her benches, going between a book and some vaguely-witchy item in her hand. You risk a few steps inside.
“You locked the door.”
“Did I?” Agatha asks neutrally, not bothering to look up from what she is working on.
“I could be wrong,” you shrug casually. “If I am then you’ll have no problem forcing it open.”
“I’m very busy, dear.”
“It’s very convenient for both doors to be stuck on the night you don’t want me to go out.”
Agatha finally turns around. “Careful,” she says in a low voice.
You swallow hard. It’s not a smart idea to push her but you’re annoyed enough to do it anyway.
“I guess I’ll just go out the window,” you jut your chin out.
Her eyes darken but she doesn’t move. You know she’s waiting to see if you actually try or if you’re bluffing. It pisses you off enough to turn around. You get two steps before your arms are jerked behind your back and purple lifts you off the ground.
“Agatha!” you yell more in surprise than anything else.
“I did say to be careful.” She tilts her wrist and you fly towards her. “Look at you, all dressed up for her.”
“I’m not,” you snap.
What you’re wearing is nicer than usual but it’s hardly your dressiest outfit. You’re going to a higher end restaurant than the usual casual lunches you do with Darcy.
Agatha flicks her wrist and you whimper at the pain that lashes across your thigh. Sharp enough it’s like you aren’t wearing clothes at all.
“Agatha,” you half-whine, not wanting to admit just how turned on you are.
She flicks her wrist again and you squirm in the air.
“Tell me to stop,” she says as she slowly circles you. “Tell me to stop, and mean it, and I’ll send you on your pretty little way.”
You hate when she does this. You can never refuse her attention. It’s all you think about.
Pain lances again when you don’t answer quickly enough. You debate purposely staying quiet longer to feel it again but you doubt this will be the last of your punishment for tonight.
“Stop,” your voice wavers.
Agatha strikes you again and you can feel yourself begin to drip down your thigh.
“Try again.”
“I want you to stop,” your voice comes out a little firmer this time and Agatha raises an eyebrow.
“I almost believe you,” she says, which you highly doubt. “Unfortunately, you’ve always been a terrible liar.”
“I- I want to go to dinner,” you try instead because you both know you don’t truly want Agatha to stop.
“Maybe. But you want me to fuck you more.”
You swallow harshly. There’s no denying that. “You won’t though,” you say quietly.
“Aw, is that what has my pet all upset? She thinks I won’t fuck her silly since she’s been so naughty?”
“Think?” you ask hopefully and Agatha smirks.
“Why, of course. I want my girl to stay, don’t I? Denying her isn’t going to that.”
It sounds like a trap. It feels like a trap. Agatha’s face is telling you that it is a trap and yet, that heat within you rises. With the way your games usually go, she’s probably going to fuck you. There’ll be some sort of catch, especially after you’ve denied her so much. But just the idea of her touching you when you were so certain she wouldn’t has you giving in.
“I -” you lick your dry lips. “I do want you to fuck me more.”
“Well, now you’re just stating facts,” Agatha flicks her wrist and your clothes disappear. “I suppose it’s better than lying.”
Anticipation surges through you as her eyes run over you. They snag on the red welts caused by her earlier lashes before they stray to the wetness soaking your thighs.
“Oh, you poor thing,” she coos and steps closer. “No wonder you’ve been acting out You’re too desperate to think properly.”
You don’t even contemplate protesting with her hands on you. When she looks up at you for a response you nod eagerly. Her amusement doesn’t settle the voice saying there’s a catch somewhere but her touch soothes any growing anxieties.
“I can certainly help with that,” she says and trails her fingers over the red marks as she makes her way towards your soaked core.
Her fingers lightly run through your soaked lips and you shiver. Agatha has been so annoyed about Darcy that she hasn’t touched you like this in days. You hadn’t realised how much the lack was affecting you.
“There we go,” she murmurs as she runs her fingers over your clit, making you gasp. She circles there for a moment before moving down and smoothly entering you with two fingers. “Empty that pretty little head of yours.”
Nodding, you try to spread your legs further apart but Agatha’s magic keeps you still. You wish she would let you down. Let you touch her. But it’s a miracle she’s touching you at all so you don’t risk asking.
Agatha’s pace remains slow until you’re whining with need. She’s so mean, only giving your clit a quick swipe every now and then until you’re begging incoherently.
“Are you going to behave for me now?” she finally asks with a raised eyebrow. Long past words, you nod desperately. Anything, you’d do anything for her. “Good girl,” she says gutturally and you fly over the edge.
She speeds up for the first time and you writhe in pleasure as the orgasm flows over you, the slow build to it having heightened the intensity. She doesn’t slow, even as you come back down.
“Mistress?” you gasp in confusion when she doesn’t stop.
“Don’t worry. I’m just making sure no silly thoughts linger in my pet’s head.”
You don’t protest or plead. You don’t want her hands to leave yet. It’s been too long without them. A second orgasm won’t hurt. Especially when she pays so much more attention to your clit.
As she makes firm circles around your clit, you wish once again that you could touch her. You want to feel her warmth against you and use your teeth to encourage her to fuck you faster and pull her hair when she doesn’t. Instead, you’re stuck whining in the air as she has her way with you.
Her fingers curl and hit that special spot inside of you. Your head drops forward as you moan. She does it again as she makes firmer circles around your clit and you’re coming before you even realise how close you are.
Finally, finally she lets you touch her. Her magic lowers you down and wraps your arms around her. You cling tight and whimper when her fingers curl again.
“One more,” she murmurs soothingly.
You meant to speak but what comes out is a low whine that’s quickly taken over by a moan.
This one is slow and soft. You’re sensitive enough that Agatha’s slow pace builds you up easily. You whine into her shoulder as the overwhelming feeling of coming a third time floods you.
You tend and shudder in her grasp before going entirely limp.
“There we go. You know where you belong, don’t you?” she asks.
She cradles you like you’re something precious. You nod weakly, holding onto her. There was never a question of who you belong to but you don’t mind reminding Agatha. Or, well, Agatha reminding herself.
“You mistress,” you manage to say.
“Good girl,” she says and kisses the side of your head.
You shiver again.
“So mean,” you mutter light heartedly.
Agatha gives you an amused look.
“Three was getting off lightly and you know it.”
You snort at the pun.
“Can we go lay down?” you ask after a moment. “I’ve missed you.”
The dizzying sensation of teleporting envelopes you a second later.
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Okay just thought of a fun little idea while working.
Witch Agatha and familiar wolf Rio.. Agathas taken a interest in reader (probably wanting another pet) but doesn't have the time at the moment to do what she does best and watch her from the sides so while she's busy with whatever she's busy with she sends Rio to spy on reader for her. Reader thinks Rios a stray helpless puppy hybrid and has been looking for a companion and takes her in thinking it's gonna be easy.. Its not. Rio let's reader believe she's just a puppy hybrid and starts getting away with things agatha doesn't let her since reader has no idea Rios supposed to keep her hands to herself idk just a rough idea of it -💫
Ohhhh this is good
I don’t imagine this to be a stereotypical (fandom-wise) witch/familiar because it’s Rio but them being linked??? Yes please!!!
Wolf Rio who helps Agatha out with her spells and originally there to keep her company but has turned into much more <3 Wolf Rio who goes on wanderings through the forest they live in/by but always always comes back <33
Agatha likes the roleplay of power she has over Rio, especially when Rio breaks it (based on that fight they have in episode one <3) so reader and rio have been playing together for a while before Rio turns the tables. Reader is not prepared. Where is her submissive pup who rolls her eyes and bites and growls but always gives in eventually? Nowhere to be seen as she mounts reader <3
I really like the idea of Rio getting away with more than just touching ahshshsjsj I’m not sure what though. Maybe just lazing around watching out the window? She’d still go on her wanderings, she is a wolf after all, and sometimes she’d return to Agatha covered in hickies just to enjoy Agatha’s wrath (who would be experiencing jealousy from both directions! But also couldn’t stop Rio because she has such a craving for reader and Rio is now her best way in)
Rio x reader- who is a bit of a dummy. BUT they have Spider-Man powers! And is constantly lucky and unlucky at the same time! Like they get into life lie death situations on a regular and almost dies so much! For example almost gets hit by a bus or som.
Rio gets annoyed and confronts r about it and is like wtf hon and reader is a cafe and shares chocolate or something with all powerful death because again they’re a bit silly- hence is romanticy
-feel free to ignore this! Love youuu <3
This was so fun to write! I need to do more silly reader. You may have started something ashdhfjfjns thank you so much for the request!!
Valentine’s Day Event 2025
Tags: silly reader, injuries mentioned, ficlet
You aren’t doing it on purpose. Or you weren’t doing it on purpose. Being clipped by a train had been an accident and so had the ocean incident but the bus…well, it looked like an accident. It was mostly an accident. You hadn’t sensed it coming until the last second and you maybe-purposely flipped at the wrong angle and still got very slightly hit. It wasn’t your fault! Mostly. It had been a while since you last saw Rio was all. And there have maybe been a few more instance like that. But there’s been more where it hasn’t! You are still a superhero. You aren’t going to put people in danger just because you want to see your crush.
The fact that you’ve been toeing the line with them possibly thinking they are is easily ignored. Usually, they are in actual danger and most don’t stop believing it until you’ve got them well away from it.
Your latest shenanigan had Rio follow you home, which you’re trying not to be obviously gleeful about. You only ever saw her out of the corner of your eye as you swung home but still. A win is a win. It’s also probably a good thing she didn’t want to come in. Your healing factor only works so fast and your last fight was rough.
One clean up and a craving later, you found yourself at your usual cafe. Your civilian one, anyway.
Sliding into a booth with a mug of hot chocolate, you slurp happily at the warm liquid. The walk from your apartment was freezing.
“I know what you’re doing,” Rio says impassively, appearing from nowhere beside you booth.
You don’t startle, despite the fact you can never seem to sense her like you do everyone else.
“What do you mean?” you give her your most innocent look.
“Your recent stunts.”
“Stunts?” you ask with the same innocent tone.
“Recklessness.”
“I’m not sure what you mean. I am a superhero. I run into danger all the time.”
“You didn’t run into this much danger before I started visiting you,” she says.
“You used to watch me?” you ask, delighted. “For how long?” Then a thought occurs to you. “Tell me you didn’t see anything embarrassing.”
“I’ve seen you do plenty of embarrassing things with full knowledge of my presence,” Rio says, unimpressed.
“I was showing off,” you pout.
A smile pulls at the side of her mouth. “Badly.”
“You wound me,” you say dramatically. “If you’ve been watching me for so long surely you’ve seen me do something impressive.”
She makes a noncommittal gesture and your pout grows.
“I’m not sharing my hot chocolate with you anymore,” you declare. “Meanies don’t get hot chocolate, especially ones with little marshmallows. It’s a rule.”
The amusement on Rio’s face grows and you find your hand suddenly empty. You stare at your hand for a moment before turning your head to find her sipping from your stolen mug. “Fine. Meanies can have one sip. To stop thievery.”
She raises an eyebrow and takes another long drink. You pout again. “This is how you treat me after a long, gruelling day?”
“People who needlessly puts themselves in more danger don’t deserve hot chocolate. It’s a rule,” she says and disappears before you get a chance to protest.
It was not on purpose. Mostly. You had to convince her. But she was already gone, taking your delicious hot chocolate with her.
Fic request for scarlet witch wanda kidnapping virgin reader 🙌🏻
Oh what a classic!! I can't not do that. The real question is do I use the "yay more cakes!" philosophy and do with with stalking and kidnapping (...and breeding kink) or should I go another route hmmm...
hi my dearest birdieeee! <3 had a fun idea for basement bunny for later chaptersss >:3 there isn't enough comfort out there (it never will tbh, we're all traumatized lol) so what about R is feeling a little down the weather, just overall blue-y and overstimulated and mistress is up for training or perhaps even some playtime. when she finally notices, maybe we physically can't get enough, "misbehave" or explode, she comforts us greatly or even communicate to know what caused the reaction so it doesn't happen again? many many kisses to uuu and thank you so much regardless 🫶
Hiiiii my dearest flower 🌼
There’s never enough comfort real and true!!! Agatha being the master manipulator she is means she knows body language (especially her bunny’s 💜) so she catches on quickly but her initial reaction is New Behvaiour = Sus. Of course comfort is quick to follow when she realises 🫶🏻 I probably won’t go the explode route otherwise a punishment will be required later but something that toes the line of misbehaving would be fun. Or like bunny trying so hard to follow what mistress says but they just don’t have it in them 💔 and it’s so obvious bunny is trying to be good that no punishment is warranted only softness 💞💞💞
I think I will put this either before or after the lazing in the sun one shot 🤔 Really give an overload of softness.
MWAH MWAH MWAH you’re amazing. Thank you for request!!!
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
im a sucker for aftercare/softness sooooo..... maybe some of that involving wanda/agatha/rio/reader? maybe mama wanda and praise? hypothetically, of course
Hypothetically…I am thinking a post-fucking scene where you end up your usual boneless self after being under the attention of three cosmic entities and Agatha bratted too hard so she is also a weak mess. Wanda and Rio do a good cop/bad cop but it’s more a soft cop/firm cop where Wanda coos and coaxes and Rio carries you to the (truly massive) bath to clean up after the scene. Rio is still very comforting but her quiet reassurance is different to mama Wanda’s tooth-rotting softness. The sweetness evolves from there with a grumpy Agatha (her ass hurts) and the puddle-of-a-person reader who both want to reassure the doms that they took such good care of them <3
heyyy, could you maybe write Wanda x Agatha x Rio x reader that takes place during Wanda’s hex. Reader is a young girl who starts falling in love with Agnes and Wanda is intrigued by this new development and supports it by basically getting a threesome (dom!wanda).Then Rio shows up and Agatha gets out of the hex and Rio takes charge of all three of them. Agatha as a switch? Wanda and reader sub. Thank you! Love your work!
This is so fun! And also feels like it's going to be long (which means I get to explore the dynamics more yay!). Here is the not so little brainstorm I did and will be using to write the fic :)
Reader is young and falls in love with Agnes (who wouldn’t) which catches Wanda’s attention. She makes it a side plot and slots herself into the dynamic as well (will probably do away with Vision in this - just no mention of him). This leads to a very interesting threesome of Agatha keeping up her Agnes facade while fucking with Wanda (literally and figuratively, she can’t help herself), Wanda trying to keep her magic under control while getting lost in pleasure, and you being completely unaware anything else is going on.
Dom Wanda, switch Agatha (brat sub for Wanda but puts reader in their place), sub reader.
Rio comes to collect her wife from the hex. Maybe the hex stops hiding her or Wanda steals the Darkhold. She’s not surprised about the situation Agatha is in but the fact Agatha hasn’t killed Wanda and kinda doesn’t want to anymore brings up conflicting emotions all around.
Rio: everyone but me is supposed to be a conquest to you.
Agatha: this feelings thing isn’t supposed to be happening anymore.
Wanda: you don’t find my powers horrifying or darkening morals wrong/repulsive?
Reader: wait when was murder a thing in this relationship.
May or may not end in fucking (it will if Agatha has a say)
if you can PLEASE I BEG OF YOU. add this in the basement bunny fanfic. i am a PURE SUCKER FOR THE BELLY BULGE KINK AAAHAHSHSGSH. your writing oks so amazingly detailed i genuinely feel like im living in the fic no joke
WAH you’re too nice!!!!
Main fic is already locked in however there may be some post-fic writing happening 👀 and if there were I’d add this to the list ☺️
BB Agatha would absolutely stretch out her bunny. She’d want to see not only how much her bunny can take but how good her bunny can be 💞