#automatic positive feedback

eBay has rolled out changes to its search ads and seller feedback policy, including how Promoted Listings appear and the introduction of an automatic positive feedback system. The updates are intended to improve buyer relevance and trust, though many sellers are weighing potential downsides to the new seller feedback policy.

According to discussions in the eBay Community, the platform adjusted how Promoted Listings are shown in early October. From that point, ads appear only under the default sort options—Best Match and Top Picks. If a buyer switches to other sorts such as Ending Soonest, Newly Listed, Price + Shipping: lowest first, Price + Shipping: highest first, or Nearest First, Promoted Listings no longer display.

eBay says the change aligns search results with buyer browsing preferences to deliver a more relevant shopping experience. Some sellers welcome the shift, arguing that keeping ads out of non-default sorts helps buyers filter more precisely. As one seller noted, even advertisers don’t want ads to disrupt the experience.

At the same time, eBay announced it will implement an automatic positive feedback mechanism starting November 3. Per a seller update released in October, when a buyer completes a transaction but does not leave feedback, the system will automatically post a positive review for the seller. eBay frames this as a way to reward reliable merchants and address the long-standing issue that only about one-third of buyers leave feedback. Still, the move has sparked debate: some worry automation could dilute the authenticity and value of real buyer comments.

Sellers are more apprehensive about a parallel change to the seller feedback policy around handling negative reviews. Beginning in November, eBay will no longer remove negative or neutral feedback in the following situations: when the seller offers free returns; when the seller completes a return and issues a refund; or when a used or damaged item is returned and the seller deducts an appropriate amount from the refund. In practice, this means even sellers who follow the return process to the letter may struggle to get poor feedback removed—an outcome some say further raises the bar for seller protections.

Others take a more optimistic view, noting that automatic positives could increase total positive counts and improve overall ratings distribution. Given declining buyer participation in feedback, the auto-feedback mechanism may help rebalance the mix of positive, neutral, and negative reviews.

For now, eBay has not indicated whether additional refinements are coming. Many sellers plan to monitor performance metrics and dispute outcomes over time to judge the long-term impact—especially on buyer trust, marketplace fairness, and listing visibility tied to Promoted Listings, automatic positive feedback, and the updated seller feedback policy.