Labor politics: it can be bloody brutal
No Labor minister or leader has ever had an easy job. The urgency that rests behind the Labor movement, pushing it on to do things, to create new conditions, to reorganise the economy of the country, always means that the people who work within the Labor movement, people who lead, can never have an easy job. - 1949, Ben Chifley, ALP Prime Minister
As Julia Gillard wakes up on the first day of the rest of her life, Iâm sure she would agree. Faced with scrutiny and criticism that didnât just go over the line - it ripped the line up, then pretended no line ever even existed and whoever thought otherwise was just being unreasonable - it finally came down to this: a more engaging day in politics not witnessed in some time.
From the early morning announcements that key independents Robert Oakeshott and Tony Windsor would not recontest the federal poll, to the falling of a Prime Minister by dayâs end, it is a political junkieâs twisted form of heaven. But at the same time, a reminder of the brutal world of modern day Labor politics. With corporate, vested and media interests largely stacked against you, the going is tough.
In the end, the third serious move on the Prime Ministership by Kevin Rudd would be a successful one. After two failed attempts and one non-attempt, the cat was once again in possession of the cream.
As a Prime Minister, Julia Gillard achieved much more than she was ever given credit for. In the face of cruel and absolutely unnecessary spiteful criticism, she delivered reforms that will serve us well for years, decades to come.
DisabilityCare is the Medicare of the modern era, and a reform whose impact cannot be understated. Much like we cannot imagine a world without Medicare, in time, Australians will view DisabilityCare similarly, and the impact on the more than 400,000 Australians with a disability is considerable. And they will have Gillard to thank. On education, the Gonski reforms will bring benefits to children that we canât even fathom yet. Once in a generation reform - that actually passed through the parliament yesterday, but was, like many other achievements of this government, overlooked by a media seemingly focused elsewhere.
Putting a price on carbon was gutsy, and ultimately politically costly for Gillard; the âtaxâ that never truly was a tax. While pricing carbon pollution remains the most efficient way of dealing with the global challenge of climate change, such sense was seemingly lost in the story of a âlieâ. And such reforms were undertaken while keeping unemployment low (5-6% is the envy of the modern world), the economy growing (14% bigger than it was in 2007, despite the GFC), inflation low, interest rates low, as well as the third lowest rate of debt in the OECD meant that receiving a AAA credit rating from the three leading agencies was no fluke.
That many of these achievements occurred despite a hostile minority government, makes them all the more commendable. As Prime Minister, Gillardâs negotiation skills, intelligence and work ethic, could not be questioned. Matched almost, by a sheer resilience to stare her opponents down and beat them, time again.
She was not without fault though. Her approach to asylum seekers disappointing; to marriage equality, curious. Policy gaffes like the watered down MRRT (mining tax) and cuts to sole parent payments, and questions on judgement (read: Slipper) and her back-tracking on pokie machine reforms, did not help. Together with hostility from across the chamber and even within her own ranks (that includes the incoming PM Rudd and his backers), the message of a positive agenda was seemingly lost. Australians heard a different tune.
â
From menus, to her cleavage, to her shoes, to her knitting, to the size of her behind, ears or jacket, Ms Gillard put up with more than she would have ever thought she was signing up for. That so many people refused to show the Office of Prime Minister the respect it deserves is a blight on us as a society. That we are ridiculed overseas for this maltreatment, is testament to that.
Why? Why did so many resort to cheap name calling? In what country could you ask the PM whether they were in a marriage that was essentially a fraud? Ask yourself whether Messrs Rudd or Abbott would ever be asked such a question. If not, why not?
But Ms Gillard took it with the grace and aplomb that she was rarely given credit for. She stared the hate and vitriol in the face, and stood up to it. Her misogyny speech, which many will opine as being a highpoint of her tenure, put a fire into the belly of many women and girls across the country, and indeed, across the world.
Were Australians ready for a female PM? In the end, probably not. As the outgoing PM said herself though, âit will be easier for the next woman, and the woman after that and the woman after that. And I am proud of that,â she said.
As a media performer, Julia Gillard - while direct and on message - seemed to struggle to connect on a personal level through the barrel of a camera. In person though, the steely resolve that perhaps put some offside was lost, replaced with an engaging, articulate and delightful warmth.
â
It is most likely that the next twenty-four hours will determine how far away an election is. It will hinge on whether Rudd goes to the polls swiftly in the hope of riding on the back of any honeymoon period, or whether he stays the course previously decided by his predecessor and wait for September 14. Keen to make a break from the past, the former seems the likely bet. Either way, the next few weeks and months will test both Mr Rudd, and the Leader of the Opposition, Tony Abbott.
To date, Abbott has managed to escape considerable scrutiny during his tenure, campaigning on a simple platform of âgovernment badâ, while providing little in the way of policies. Outside of a watered down and widely criticised national broadband offering, and a workplace relations policy that has little backing in Liberal party circles due to the claim that it doesnât go far enough, Abbott has been a policy-lite zone.
In the interests of a democracy, with voters making informed decisions on polling day, this needs to change. As Rudd himself said last night, âAbbott shouldnât be allowed to come to power by default.â In short, a glossy pamphlet does not a policy make. Abbottâs negativity and sloganeering in coming weeks will get old, quickly.
That we are potentially weeks away from an election and the Opposition has offered nothing in the way of policies relating to key areas such as education or health, is breathtaking in the Liberal Partyâs confidence. Two key policy areas, both with significant impact to the budget bottom line, and there has been nothing.
There are differences elsewhere too, the key one being that for the first time, we will have in Kevin Rudd, a Prime Minister that supports marriage equality. While this is an issue that has generally had widespread public support, it will be interesting to see whether it translates into votes. If Mr Rudd is keen to reclaim the excitement and fervor of Kevin07, this may very well be a key plank of it. A fresh, progressive and positive pitch, compared with the more conservative and traditional views of the Leader of the Opposition.
If the polls are correct, Mr Rudd has a sizeable task ahead of him to even make the election a contest. While the difference in support is not as wide as some polls suggest, it nevertheless remains to be seen whether it can be overcome. He will also need to try and heal the party, bringing back into the fold those supporters - and they exist - angered by the treatment of our first female Prime Minister, who feel that Ruddâs undermining was in the end, rewarded.
While Rudd was unable to go quietly into the night in 2010, one thinks Gillard will do exactly that, and do it in style. While Rudd gathered with his family and spoke for thirty minutes, fighting back tears after being deposed in 2010, Gillard spoke for barely half that last night, her delivery efficient, resilient and disciplined. Even right to the end, she did not crack.
She will bother no-one, undermine no-one, and will leave politics with what it needs - some grace and class.
Outgoing Treasurer Wayne Swan said it best last night when in an impassioned resignation speech, showing a side that we probably didnât see enough of, he referred to the outgoing PM as "one of the toughest warriors who have ever led the Australian Labor Party".
One only hopes that history is kinder to her than far too many Australians ever were.
(pics faithfully reproduced from Fairfax)









