The Case Between Us
Pairing: Tarun Saluja x reader
T.W: Based on Tarun Saluja from Article 375
CHAPTER 1
You had only come to drop off lunch for your father,
The tiffin was still warm in your hands, and at this point, you were told lunch break would be at 1:00pm but you've already been waiting for an whole hour.
You shifted your weight slightly, glancing at the closed doors of Courtroom 3 again before checking your phone.
âYaar...Kiti vel lavat ahet, tch...", you muttered under your breath, the impatience slipping out quietly. (Tch, they are taking so long)
A few seconds later, the doors opened.
People began stepping out in small groups, their conversations continuing from inside in low, controlled voices. You straightened instinctively, scanning the crowd for your father, he wasnât among the first to exit.
Instead, someone slowed down near you.
âExcuse me.â
His voice was calm and direct, not loud, but enough to pull your attention.
You looked up. âYes?â,you said, adjusting the tiffin slightly in your hands, your tone neutral but attentive.
He glanced briefly at what you were holding, then back at you.
âAre you waiting for someone?â,he asked, his expression steady, like he was confirming a simple fact.
âMy father-â,you replied, shifting your grip on the tiffin.
âName?â,he asked, without hesitation, as if it was the obvious next step.
âJustice Madgaonkar,â you said, watching him more closely this time.
There was a brief pause, you could tell he knows your father,
âHeâs still inside,â he said, his tone unchanged.
You let out a small breath.
âHaan, woh toh dikh raha hai,â
you said lightly, your eyes flicking toward the courtroom doors again.
A short silence followed. He didnât leave, and you didnât immediately disengage either.
âLong hearing?â you asked after a second, more out of boredom than curiosity.
âYes,â he replied, simply.
You looked at him properly then.
âBas?â you said, a faint hint of amusement slipping in.
He seemed to consider that for a moment.
âIt got complicated towards the endâ
he added, the slight shift making his answer feel more deliberate.
You nodded slowly.
âSounds like something went wrongâ you said, studying him a little more now.
âDepends on which lens you're looking at the case with.â he replied, his tone even, quite composed.
You gave a small huff of amusement.
âThatâs still a lawyer answer,â you pointed out, adjusting the tiffin again.
He acknowledged it without resistance.
âOccupational hazard i guessâ he said, the faintest dryness in his voice.
That actually made you smile, just slightly.
Before you could say anything else, the courtroom doors opened again.
Your father steps out, straightning his robes
âBaba!â you called, trying to get his attentions
Justice Madgaonkar looked at you, mildly surprised.
âTu ithe kay kartes?â he asked, his brows tightening slightly. (What are you doing here)
âLunch anla aheâ you said, holding up the tiffin.(I've brought lunch)
He nodded and reached for it. âTheek ahe, mi nantar khainââ he began, already half-turning.(Ok, I'll eat it later-
âNahi, aai ni sagitle ahe, atthach khaiche.â you insisted, pressing it into his hands before he could dismiss it. (No mother told me to, make you eat right now)
He took it, but his attention shifted almost immediately.
To the man standing beside you.
âMr. Saluja.â
You glanced between them.
The name didnât mean anything yet.
The tone did.
Tarun inclined his head slightly.
âYour Honourâ ,he said, his voice exactly the same as before,calm, controlled.
Your father held Tarun's gaze.
âI trust todayâs proceedings have made certain boundaries clearâ ,he said, his tone measured but firm.
You didnât fully understand what that meant, but it was clearly not casual.
âThey haveâ ,Tarun replied, without hesitation.
âEnsure they remain clearâ, your father added, the authority in his voice unmistakable.
âOf courseâ, Tarun said, just as evenly.
There was a brief pause before your father turned back to you.
âChalaâ he said, already moving.(Come on)
You nodded and followed him, but as you walked away, you glanced back once.
Tarun had already stepped aside, moving on like the interaction hadnât mattered.
_________________________________________________
A Few Minutes Later
You had just turned into another corridor after handing over the lunch when you walked straight into someone.
âSorryââ you started, stepping back...
then stopped.
âOhâ you againâ ,you said, a little embarrassed this time.
He looked at you, recognising you immediately.
âYouâre done?â he asked, his tone neutral but attentive.
âYeahâ, you said, nodding once.
âDelivery successful.â
He glanced at his watch briefly.
âItâs past twoâ,he said, more like an observation than a comment.
You frowned slightly.
âOkayâŠ?â,you replied, unsure what he meant.
âYou brought food,â
he said, looking at you again,
âbut you didnât eat.â
You paused, caught off guard.
âI wasnât planning to,â you admitted.
He held your gaze for a moment.
âYou should,â he said, simply.
You crossed your arms lightly.
âAur aapko kaise pata ki mujhe bhook lagi hai?â,you asked, a faint challenge in your tone.
âYouâve been waiting outside a courtroom for over an hour,â he replied.
âThat usually covers it.â
You let out a small breath, almost amused.
âThatâs a very calculated assumption,â you said.
âItâs not that complicated,â he said, like the conclusion was obvious.
A brief pause followed.
Then,
âThe canteenâs open,â he added, more practically than anything else.
You raised a brow. âYouâre inviting me to lunch?â you asked, still slightly unsure.
âYes..â he said, without overexplaining.
You stared at him for a second.
There was no hidden tone. No awkwardness. No agenda you could read.
So you nodded.
âFine let's goâ
_________________________________________________
The canteen was louder than the corridor, more relaxed but still full of the same people. Lawyers sat in groups, eating, arguing, discussing cases in between bites. The space felt lived-in, like this was where the formal structure of the courtroom loosened just enough.
He walked in like he belonged there.
You sat across from him, looking around.
âYahan ka khaana acha hota hai?â you asked.
âItâs decent,â he said, a more normal answer this time.
You nodded. âGood enough,â you murmured.
A waiter came by. He ordered quickly, then looked at you.
You added something simple.
A moment of quiet settled.
Then you leaned forward slightly.
âWaise⊠aap ho kaun?â you asked.
He looked at you directly.
âAdvocate Tarun Salujaâ
He shakes her hand as if talking to a client.
You nodded slowly. âMainââ
âI knowâ ,he said.
âYou told me.â
You paused, then exhaled lightly. âRight.â
Around you, the noise of the canteen continued, but your table felt oddly still,
You picked up your glass, taking a small sip just to break the stillness.
âSalujaâŠâ,you repeated faintly, like you were trying to place it somewhere.
He glanced up this time, not ignoring it.
âHaanâ ,he said lightly, almost like confirming something obvious, before going back to his plate.
That small response shifted something, He wasnât shutting the conversation down.
Just⊠not stretching it unnecessarily.
You watched him for a second.
âAap kafi direct ho...â,you said, your tone casual, but your eyes still a little curious.
He looked up again, this time properly.
âAur ye...Acchi cheez he ya buri?â he asked, the question coming easier than before, like he didnât mind engaging now.
You smiled faintly.
âDependsâ ,you said, echoing him from earlier without realising it.
That got the slightest reaction, a hint of amusement, barely visible but there.
âFair enough,â he said, leaning back a little in his chair, more relaxed now.
You rested your elbow lightly on the table.
âAap har baat itni carefully bolte ho?â you asked, tilting your head slightly.
He let out a short breath,almost a quiet laugh.
âNahi,â he said, shaking his head once. âBas aadat hai thoda filter rakhne ki.â
You nodded.
âCourt ka effect?â you asked.
âPartly,â he said, then added after a second, âbaaki logon ka bhi.â
You raised a brow. âMatlab?â
âZyada bol do toh log yaad rakh lete hain,â he said, his tone casual, like it wasnât a big statement, just something heâd noticed over time.
You considered that for a second, then nodded slowly. âThatâs quite true, I must sayâ, you admitted.
A brief quiet settled again, but it wasnât stiff this time.
You tapped your fingers lightly against the table.
âToh aajâŠka hearing âcomplicatedâ ho gaya tha kya?â you asked, bringing it back, but more lightly now.
He exhaled through his nose, leaning back slightly.
âHota rehta haiâ ,he said, like it wasnât worth overexplaining.
You narrowed your eyes slightly.
âThat doesnât sound convincingâ ,you said, watching him.
He glanced at you, a little amused now. âAapko convincing answer chahiye ya honest?â ,he asked.
You paused.
âHonest,â you said after a second.
He nodded once.
âThoda messy tha,â he admitted, his tone more open now, like he didnât mind saying it plainly.
You leaned back slightly, satisfied with that.
âBetter,â you said.
A waiter dropped the bill on the table.
You reached for it instinctively.
âMainââ you started.
He picked it up at the same time.
âRelax,â he said, a little more casual now, almost dismissing the formality.
You frowned slightly.
âSplit kar lete hain,â you insisted.
He shook his head lightly. âNext time,â he said, without thinking too much about it.
You paused.
âNext time?â you repeated, raising a brow, a hint of a smile forming.
He seemed to realise what heâd said a second too late.
âMatlab⊠agar kabhi,â he corrected, but there was no real urgency in it, just a quiet adjustment.
You let out a soft laugh.
âSmooth,â you said.
He shook his head slightly, a faint smile pulling at the corner of his mouth.
You stood up, adjusting your bag.
âStill,â you said, looking at him,
âlunch acha tha.â
He stood as well, more relaxed than when youâd first met him.
âHaan, decent tha,â he said, like the rating hadnât changed.
You took a step back.
âThanks,â you added, meaning more than just the food.
He nodded once.
âAnytime,â he said,casual, unforced.
You paused at that.
You shook your head, still smiling, then turned to leave.
_________________________________________________
6:00pm, MADGAONKAR RESDIENCE, MUMBAI
You finally return home, it had been a long day, between the going to court in afternoon to attending college lectures.
You dropped your bag onto your bed and sat down, staring at the wall for a moment longer than necessary. The moment with Tarun shouldâve ended when you walked out of court. It shouldâve stayed small, just a visit, just another afternoon.
But it hadnât.
Something about it had stayed with you. This Tarun guy was quite the interesting character, and there was just something appealing about the man.
You stood up abruptly, restless in a way you couldnât quite explain, and stepped out of your room.
The house felt too still.
As you passed the living room, you saw your father, sitting with his phone pressed to his ear, his posture straight, his expression unreadable from a distance. His voice carried faintly, low and controlled, the kind of tone that meant he was choosing every word carefully.
You slowed down for half a second, instinctively listening, but the conversation was too measured to catch anything meaningful.
So you kept walking.
You didnât plan to stop outside his study.
But you did...
The door wasnât fully closed. Just slightly open, enough to show the edge of his desk, the neat stacks of files, the familiar stillness of a room that wasnât meant for casual entry.
You stood there for a moment, your hand hovering near the door without touching it.
You knew better.
Youâd always known better.
And yet,
you pushed it open.
The study felt different the moment you stepped in, as if the air itself carried a certain weight. The faint smell of paper and polished wood lingered, clean and controlled, just like everything else in the room. Nothing was out of place. Files were stacked in multiple drawers and shelfs, books aligned precisely, and the desk held only what was necessary, no clutter, no distractions.
âIâm just looking,â you murmured under your breath, more out of habit than belief, as if saying it made the act less deliberate.
Your eyes moved across the desk slowly, taking in the arrangement without really searching for anything specific.
Until something stood out.
A file on your father's desk,
It wasnât misplaced, but it wasnât fully put away either. It sat slightly apart from the others, its position suggesting it had been used recently and would be used again soon.
That alone was enough.
You stepped closer, your movements quieter now, your fingers brushing lightly against the edge before you picked it up.
The title confirmed what you already suspected.
This was the case, he was presiding over when she arrived to the court.
You opened it carefully, almost instinctively aware of not disturbing anything more than necessary.
Inside, the pages were dense with information, typed documents layered with handwritten annotations in your fatherâs sharp, precise script. Entire sections were underlined, arguments circled, notes added in the margins with clarity that came from years of habit.
You flipped through slowly, your eyes moving across the text without fully processing it, catching fragments instead, phrases, names, legal terms, even if you didnât fully understand their implications
You leaned in slightly, adjusting your grip as your eyes scanned the layout, As you flipped the page you noticed,
There was this...formal document,
A listing of counsels.
Names arranged neatly, each paired with their roles, their details, their place within the case.
Your gaze moved down the page, unhurried at first
until it wasnât.
Tarun Saluja.
Your eyes lingered there longer than necessary before shifting, almost automatically, to the right side of the page, to the Contact details.
And there It was...his number.
Printed clearly, without hesitation, part of a document that was never meant to leave this room.
You shouldnât do this....
The thought came immediately, sharp and clear.
This wasnât yours.
This wasnât information you were meant to take.
But still... you didnât close the file.
Your gaze stayed fixed on the number, tracing it once, then again, as if committing it to memory would somehow be different from writing it down.
It wasnât, You knew that, but Your hand moved anyway.
You reached into your pocket and pulled out your phone, the screen lighting up too brightly in the quiet of the room. For a brief second, you hesitated, your thumb hovering as if giving yourself one last chance to stop.
Then you unlocked it.
Carefully, deliberately, you typed the number exactly as it appeared.
Your thumb paused for a fraction of a second before moving againâ
this time to save it.
Then you typed:
Tarun Saluja
For a moment, you just stood there, your phone still in your hand, the contact now sitting quietly among the others like it had always been there.
You locked your phone slowly and slipped it back into your pocket, the weight of it suddenly more noticeable than before.
Only then did you look back down at the file.
You closed it carefully, aligning the edges exactly the way they had been, placing it back in the same position with a level of precision you didnât usually bother with.
Nothing out of place.
Nothing disturbed.
You stepped back, your eyes scanning the desk one last time to make sure everything looked exactly as it had when you walked in.
______________________________________________
Happy b'day to me and Akshaye Khanna đ
Based on a request by @y0uneversawmehere
@softkissesandicecreams @qalamband @gracelovestars @layinglowkey @golgappalicious @euphorkive @twinblueflamee @tanipartner @kriti-ki-dulhania @goodnightkatherine @peonies7002 @ch3rrycok3s @saltedburns @sanpiece








