I know it wouldve been weird for Shane to be in the livestream but once again, it hurts that he's as silent as he was last year during the protests
I think this ask really solidifies a deeper problem we have in the way by which we go about our activism, especially online activism. So much of the success of many social justice movements started by people of colour depends far too much on white acknowledgement. This isnât a judgement call on those who feel the need to spread the word to circles where people have the systemic power to make a difference (which are circles that are predominately white). This is more of a discussion about the nuance that comes with supporting a creator and demanding--perhaps even needing--their validation about things we feel they should care about. This need comes with a pedestal as well and while I am the first to argue that a platform with a lot of people looking at you immediately imbues your existence as a person with the power and obligation to be a good role model, I also feel that if a creator with a large platform is ill-equipped to perform those aspects of their work, they shouldnât force it.Â
So this is going to come across as very cold but know that I say this with the deepest sympathies I can afford right now as a fellow fan of the guy, but if Shane doesnât believe he has the words or the capacity to speak fluidly and effectively against racism as a person who has never experienced it, then he shouldnât do it because oftentimes pushing white voices to the forefront or asking them to weigh in simply because more people would listen or because it would mean something to you personally, can at times, do more harm than good.Â
Basically, guys. Stop looking to your white faves to do the work that people of colour are busting their asses to do more effectively. If Shane decides to do a retweet or make some kind of statement, good. It is the bare minimum he can do next to giving to organizations or stepping back so his co-founders can speak from a place of perspective.Â
Personally, Iâd just be impressed if he just said anything to the effect of âListen to Steven and Ryan right now. Theyâve lived it and I support them,â which technically, was covered the first few minutes of the stream when Ryan explained in clear terms that everyone at Team Watcher is sympathetic and supportive.Â