Young waxed poetic about prepubescent fantasies not only in "I Am a Child" but in "Sugar Mountain," where you can't be twenty--calling bullshit on his self-infantilizing, Joni responded by writing a song in which the child survives in the adult, "The Circle Game." The melancholy she brought to her lyrics was in fact also present in the aching melody of Young's song, grounding his whimsical words. The happy-sad attitude infused the many songs that took up similar themes. Phil Ochs traced his arduous journey from the tube of his mother's birth canal through other narrowing passages in "Half a Century High." Cat Stevens, Beatles wannabe turned hot young sage, voiced the doubts of a boy leaving home for the first time in "Father and Son." Tom Rush, covering Murray McLauchlan, did the same in "Child's Song." Janis Ian, barely out of her teens, mourned the dreamy days of youth in "When I Was a Child." Pop craftsman Neil Diamond showed his songwriterly side in "Shilo," which celebrated a boyhood imaginary friend. These are just the most obvious examples from a playlist that could run hours long.
Traveling on the Path of Joni Mitchell, Ann Powers (1989)













