just a little oth vent with you cause i feel like you're my brucas bff somehow lol
my 84yr old auntie is watching one tree hill for the first time, and i'm catching episodes here and there and rewatching with her when i can, and lol 1) she's a brucas through and through so we love her for that; 2) i never add s4 to my rewatches but she's on s4 now and god... acting really changes everything because lucas can say whatever he wants and do whatever he wants, neither me nor auntie can believe that he didn't settle for peyton like lol it's def the way chad acted, i do think hil and chad had good chemistry in general but watching s4 right after s3 is such a blatant difference even in his friendship scenes with brooke like.
well. they forced the text to push for lp so hard too, but the build up to it was just not.good. their dumb attempt to 'level the playing field' with what brooke and peyton had done to each other was also not it. anyway i digress! s4 remains poorly written, lucas' hair remains ugly, and my 84 year old auntie knows what's up.
That's totally fine with me! Actually, it makes me happy because I don't have many Brucas friends LOL
Okay, I love your aunt. I used to watch One Tree Hill with my mom and she was team L*yton. Needless to say, we did not agree on that. I know how you feel about season 4. I struggle a lot with it. The first 8 episodes are garbage and extremely agenda driven. Even when the season picks up, I still resent a lot of what's going on and hate how they get there. RIGHT?! The funny thing about Chad and Hilarie's chemistry is that it works very well when they have to be angsty and are circling each other with the knowledge that it's inevitable they'll come together. But when it's time to be cheesy and very genuine about being in love? The chemistry is severely lacking. Everything Lucas says to Peyton in season 4 feels fake and like he's decided to settle because he managed to fuck up his relationship with Brooke again. I have no idea why the writers were obsessed with making Lucas in denial about Peyton all the time, but the big "reveals" didn't land as intended. Apparently because he flashed back to the pilot, it's supposed to mean something. But yes, with Brooke it all comes across as genuine. Their chemistry is palpable. Brucas is typically reduced to being about lust, but there's so much softness and emotional intimacy that gets overlooked. Even during scenes where Lucas is supposed to be emotionally distant, it still feels like Lucas is in the moment with Brooke because Chad and Sophia vibed too well together as actors. So while I understand that LP was allegedly meant to be the plan all along, the show was never able to recreate that chemistry with Chad and Hilarie.
Do not get me started on the sex tape retcon. I love the false equivalency when Peyton got over Brooke sleeping with Nathan in two episodes compared to Brooke still having trust issues over what Lucas and Peyton put her through well into season 7. It's one of the most forced attempts to convince the audience to root for one character/couple over another that I've ever seen. Ew, I don't envy you for having to look at the boys' hair that season. Anyways, I hope you won't have to watch too much more of season 4. Thank you for the ask <3













