Why are the shrinking scenes involving Ai Haibara (episode 129, 178, Black Iron Submarine) more detailed than the shrinking scenes involving other characters?
I'm so sorry β i asked for opinions on the discord and forgot to actually answer the ask. Will you forgive? I have been busy preparing my own CoAiWeek tributes! π
Also we all got sidetracked into discussing the latest Manga file(1165) spoilers. π«£ It had been a while since canon threw Haibara fans such food.
ANYWAY...
Some people didn't see a distinction - recalling Shinichi also having more detailed shrinking scenes...
I personally think a lot of it is to do with narrative perspective, focus and distance.
Shinichi's first shrinking was mostly first person β we fade to black and literally see through his eyes as the poison takes hold and he awakes to the guards finding him.
Shinichi's second shrinking occurs in the case introducing Heiji, a teenage detective investigating where his rival vanished off to. It's also a moment for Ran to get reassurance that Shinichi is alive. At this point Shinichi also doesn't know that his return is temporary... This time we get the external view of the friends and how his disappearance affects them. He's there one minute, the next... GONE. It's really dramatic.
In the manga, Sherry's initial shrinking is described in the background of a panel discussing the event β it makes sense for the anime to fully animate that sequence. Watching a character talk is not as exciting as what they're describing, and the drama of it means having Haibara talking on top of it might diminish the impact.
Haido city hotel is the first time we see Shiho shrink back βand the theme here is very much about vulnerability and danger. How better do you show that than by having the transformation sequence end with a gun to the head?
In contrast, we don't see Shinichi shrinking after the case with his doppleganger (episode 523?) afaik β ( I don't actually watch the anime, just the movies...) There's no narrative benefit to showing the scene there. Similar for Shiho's appearance in episode 700 (the camping trip with the hut on fire) β we already know what happens when she shrinks, and the focus was more on how hard she needs pushed to actually resort to the antidote, rather than its effects on her.
If anyone else knows of instances I've not covered, please reblog with the addition!
Thank you Anon for the lovely question. π«Ά














