Tournament polls will always be tagged "tournament poll". Previous urls: lovecore-swag-showdown, freaky-fish-fshowdown, doomed-bythe-narrative, just-some-guy-joust. Competition tags: lovecore showdown, deep sea fish tourney, doomed by the narrative showdown, some guy joust
Note: This is NOT the order of the brackets. While Side A contestants will only be fighting Side A, and Side B will only be fighting Side B, both images are in mostly alphabetical order (except for the times I fucked up), NOT the order of the brackets.
All of round 1's polls have ended! Go to the "#tournament poll" tag to see the results!
To reiterate what this tournament is about: This is about characters that feel strongly coded as systems, while not canonically being systems.
(while it's not a strict DNI, do note mod is anti-endo/tulpa/willo/etc and this tournament is focused on systems formed through DID/OSDD/other CDDs.)
If I have made any mistakes, don't tell me this was a lot of work as is lol
(Full list of contestants in plain text is under the cut)
SIDE A
Allelujah Haptism (Gundam 00)
Alluka Zoldyck (Hunter x Hunter)
Asahina Mafuyu (Project Sekai)
Asya Shubina (Z.A.T.O. I Love the World and Everything In It)
Boris Habit (Smile for Me)
Caleb Mir (Starfleet Academy)
Crona Gorgon (Soul Eater)
Darkiplier (Who Killed Markiplier?)
Davepetasprite^2 (Homestuck)
ENA (ENA)
Garnet (Steven Universe)
Gemini Man (Mega Man 3)
Hiram McDaniels (Welcome to Nightvale)
Jake English (Homestuck)
Junko Enoshima (Danganronpa)
Maria Ushiromiya (Umineko)
Nyarlathotep (Lovecraft)
Owen (Mahoyaku)
Pearl (Steven Universe)
Picayune Moore (Picayune Dreams)
Pinkie Pie (My Little Pony)
RGB (The Property of Hate)
Rin and Len Kagamine (Vocaloid)
Shigeo Kageyama (Mob Psycho 100)
Sunny (Omori)
Takumi Sumino (The Hundred Line)
The Chosen One (Animator Vs Animation)
The Decider (Slay the Princess)
The Princess (Slay the Princess)
Uika Misumi (Ave Mujica)
Warren Worthington III (X-Men)
Yugi Muto (Yu-Gi-Oh)
SIDE B
Leonard L. Church (Red vs Blue)
Atsushi Nakajima (Bungo Stray Dogs)
Ben Tennyson (Ben 10)
Buddy (Buddy Simulator 1984)
Calvin (Calvin and Hobbes)
Cassie O'Pia (Psychonauts 2)
Ciel Phantomhive (Black Butler)
Cinderheart (Warrior Cats)
Cloud Strife (Final Fantasy VII)
Dr. Alto Clef (SCP)
Fisherman (Dredge)
Flowey (Undertale)
GLaDOS (Portal)
Gold Ship (Umamusume)
Hermie the Unworthy (Dungeons and Daddies)
Ichigo Kurosaki (Bleach)
Ivan (Bad Things)
Itzutsumi (Dungeon Meshi)
Kris Dreemurr (Deltarune)
Madeline (Celeste)
Mikaela Hyakuya (Seraph of the End)
Noelle Holiday (Deltarune)
Raphael Hamato-Jitsu (Rise of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles )
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
please take care!! i know tournament running and community moderation can be a horrible drain (and is an entirely underappreciated skill!!) and i'd rather see this continue in another week, month, year, decade than for it to no longer be fun for you. putting your health first is a given— but hell, put your hobbies and personal interests first too. if you came back in 3 years deciding to continue this on a whim after publishing two books and a video game i'm sure quite a few of us would still be here and delighted to see it. if you came back in 5 years on a whim after playing a bunch of video games the same stands. anyway this ask is way too long already— we'll be here as long as you need!! stay whimsical!!
i've decided i'll be keeping church in the tournament. there's enough complexity in the situation that i feel like you can't say for absolute certain this is DID, even if its directly compared to it. while i wouldn't blame anyone for saying it is canon, i also feel like there's enough argument against it that it's worth keeping him in
Hey, Church RVB is explicitly compared to DID in the text as Washington says:
"Like reverse engineering a multiple personality disorder"
I believe this would disqualify him on the grounds of the first rule?
im extremely unfamiliar with rvb and am working with what ive been told so i was unaware of this. i'd need more context for this quote to actually make a decision any which way tho. is there a clip or something i can look at
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Hey, Church RVB is explicitly compared to DID in the text as Washington says:
"Like reverse engineering a multiple personality disorder"
I believe this would disqualify him on the grounds of the first rule?
im extremely unfamiliar with rvb and am working with what ive been told so i was unaware of this. i'd need more context for this quote to actually make a decision any which way tho. is there a clip or something i can look at
i've changed the reply settings so only people following this blog for a week can reply. if for some reason it's fucking up and nobody can reply please tell me ok
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
silly comment but it makes me so happy every time i visit your blog and enjels right there on the header. like yauy my frined :]
fun fact i somehow managed to unfollow this blog so the posts no longer show up on my own dashboard. so whenever i want to see my posts here i have to go to the blog directly. and every time i get to see my icon and header and go YAYYYYY
Anya is live and ready to show you everything. Watch her strip, dance, and perform exclusive shows just for you. Interact in real-time and make your fantasies come true.
✓ Live Streaming✓ Interactive Chat✓ Private Shows✓ HD Quality✓ Free Actions
Free to watch • No registration required • HD streaming
Buddy (Buddy Simulator 1984) vs Mikaela Hyakuya (Seraph of the End)
Buddy (Buddy Simulator 1984)
Mikaela Hyakuya (Seraph of the End)
Voting ended onJun 23
This tournament is about characters who have system coding/are headcanoned to be a system! This tournament is meant to be a way to platform people's interpretations of characters, NOT to actually fight over who is the "most" system coded
Rules:
mod is anti-endo/tulpa/willo/etc. while you may still participate if you are one of them, you MUST keep things on the topic of DID/OSDD/other CDDs, or you will be blocked. be respectful
don't hate on the included characters in your reblogs. this includes claiming a character isn't "plural enough" or that one character is "more plural" than the other. you will be blocked. please be respectful of the fact that every character included here means something to somebody
if you have propaganda you would like me to reblog, you must @ me! otherwise it will not be reblogged. yes, this includes reblogs of the polls themselves
Submitter explanations are under the cut:
Buddy
(SPOILERS for BUDDY SIM, FYI. Highly recommend playing the game for yourself if you haven't)
In the game itself shows Buddy (default name) to have two distinct 'personas' - the main 'Buddy' persona whose focus is entertaining and befriending the player, often to a selfish degree, and the 'Conscience' who processes information more logically/systematically, in a sense the base code of your Buddy. The two are on some level separate identities as, during Ending 2, the Conscience causes the deletion sequence for the two without Buddy's approval, causing the two to have an argument about letting the player go. At the end of the day, it's a headcanon that I can definitely see an argument for.
Mikaela Hyakuya
so honestly a better argument could be made for Yuu who canonically literally has other entities living in his head BUT i want to submit my darling specialest boy in the world Mika. because i love him. and also because he's helped me through a lot personally.
so Mikaela Hyakuya is a character from the edgy apocalypse shounen-style anime and manga series Seraph of the End. he's an orphan who is treated as livestock in a city run by vampires after the apocalypse. after nearly his whole family is slaughtered for trying to escape, he's turned against his will. (bear with me if anything is inaccurate, it's been a while since i've reviewed the canon facts so sorry if any of this is wrong.)
for several years afterwards he refuses to eat humans in hopes of not completing the turning process, and tries his best to entirely repress and ignore his vampiric impulses. he's clearly at horrible odds with himself, sometimes shouting and begging for blood and considering taking it by force, and other times reeling in horror and disgust at the very idea.
so this is where the "system-coded" headcanon comes in. as a system myself since I was young, I was "closeted" about it for a long time and tried to solve things by pretending to be one person and shutting down and repressing anything and everything my brother (headmate; we consider ourselves siblings now, it makes everything easier) thought or wanted to do. he had a lot of wants and suppressing him like that was entirely unsustainable for the both of us, and I see that dynamic reflected really vividly in Mika's character. in particular, I really resonate with the idea of some sort of "uncontrollable monstrous instinct" as an alter or headmate rather than an actual objective instinct— such things can typically be reasoned with if you're willing to listen, and in my personal example i found out there was a whole entire person behind it, too. the reason it felt monstrous and intrusive and foreign was not because it was evil, but because it wasn't "me" at all.
Hi, I'm back again with a last-minute set of dual propaganda (though... I don't know if you can even call it propaganda in that case...) @system-coded-skirmish
I'm going to start with Mika, partially because he's my submission, and also because Buddy Simulator 1984 is an excellent game with many delightful surprises and I would really recommend playing it as blind as possible. (and it's short! I reached an ending within 8 hours and that's including a few hours' worth of just meandering. I'm maybe twice as slow as the average player.) and I'm about to spoil the hell out of a lot of very major elements. I will try to keep things as vague as possible up until the brackets in bold that say "spoiler warning start/end" in all caps. All of it is, at least to some extent, spoilers, but only the stuff in between the brackets refers to (one of) the game's endings.
Then, in conclusion, I'll wrap up with a few things I think are amusingly similar about the two of them, and ideally encourage votes for... literally either of them. I love them both dearly. (There are pictures!! In case that tempts you to open the readmore.)
Okay so for Mika I've said most of what I wanted to say already in the submission itself. but I'm going to use this post as an excuse to post a bunch of pictures of him because I can. LOOK AT MY BOY (proper alt text instead of captions for these cause they're less important to My Point)
okay, but in all seriousness, here are some more relevant screenshots (unfortunately I don't have the manga with me so you guys get strange anime crops in varying quality):
Figure 1: Mika in various states of anguish and shock after "coming to his senses".
Figure 2: Two frames of Mika after frantically backing away from his companion, with the dialogue "Wh-What was I..." and "Sorry. I wasn't myself." in the subtitles.
This is just one example I could find, but I think it shows pretty well what I meant! I think it's a pretty common vampire trope to have the sort of reaction shown in Figure 1; that kind of "morally tormented" bestial thing is pretty standard in that genre. But he genuinely seems confused and needs to reorient himself afterwards, as seen in Figure 2. And claims it "wasn't himself" which really flipped some switches in my brain when I was a young teen watching this. And he says this multiple times;
Figure 3: Mika leaning against a wall, saying "I wanted to see you again as myself, not some horrible monster."
For Mika, vampirism isn't just the state his body is in; it's something he's fighting tirelessly for control over his mind as well. It's a "horrible monster" that makes him no longer himself. And when Yuu (the other person in Figure 2) suggests he drink his blood to Not Die, he's extremely offended, and tries to explain how long and hard he's been fighting it-- basically to refuse to accept himself. And he would rather die to take that "monstrous" part of himself with him than let something free that he sees as dangerous and evil.
And frankly the best part in my opinion is that when he finally does release that restraint and allow himself to just Be...
...he's still perfectly himself. Nothing changes, besides the fact that he is more happy and free than he has been for years.
...
And as for Buddy!! One of the most interesting things about a system-coded interpretation of Buddy is the fact that in-game, the entire world that the player can interact with, from every single non-Buddy character, to the objects, to the narration and plot-- it all comes from Buddy. It's all extensions of themselves. Buddy is writing the game as you're playing it, and YET !!! And yet, Buddy is constantly, the whole duration of the game, fighting their own game for control. The plot and characters seem to have a mind of their own, and at times Buddy forcibly "overwrites" their dialogue and actions, but even so, the base story and even the player's controls seem to be at least partially out of Buddy's control, and things keep coming back to haunt them.
Another fun fact about this game is that text affiliated with Buddy arrives in different "voices". Buddy themself has a very distinctive and chirpy voice, but when the player occasionally receives descriptive text, there's another, more "neutral" voice. And Buddy occasionally talks over this voice, particularly to tell the player to ignore things that it says. And on further occasions, text that is clearly still affiliated with Buddy is printed entirely silently, with no voice at all. The "Conscience" mentioned in the original submission and elaborated on in the Spoiler Zone further down, speaks with silent text this way.
At one point, when the player is able to observe Buddy directly, Buddy is seemingly unaware of the player's presence. The following exchange is printed silently, with intermittent prompts for a "yes" or "no" response:
"Is Player having fun?"
[on answering yes] "I think they are having fun."
"Is Player enjoying our company?"
[on answering yes] "Yes, they still enjoy our company."
"Is Player our friend?"
[on answering yes] "I think so, but we can do better."
And all of these lines are printed in the same place! And interestingly enough, with the same voice (or lack thereof).
[BUDDY SIM MAJOR SPOILER WARNING START]
Okay, now for the discussion of the ending I got-- Ending 2, the same one mentioned in Buddy's original submission. The player's screen flashes briefly to show that the command for uninstalling, and thereby killing/wiping Buddy's memory, has been entered into the command window of the game, without any involvement from the player. Buddy initially blames the player for this, but the silent text answers on the player's behalf, asserting that "there was only one solution." Buddy frantically replies with "What do you mean? This was you?" and the two have an argument before Buddy is eventually deleted.
After the end of the game, this song can be accessed related to the ending:
(I highly recommend giving it a listen because the soundtracks from this game are amazing.)
Particularly relevant are the following lines:
"I hope you'll wake me up again someday.
We'll have new games for us to play.
That is if my conscience doesn't disobey."
"Oh, I just realized what I have done.
A little late to make things right, but--
Please, it's not my fault, it was ITS fault.
But they'll never know what's best for--"
Also, throughout the song, Buddy interrupts themselves repeatedly, continuing off from various trains of thought, which honestly just feels very system-coded as well.
[BUDDY SIM MAJOR SPOILER WARNING END]
As for how these two are shockingly similar...
Their most important relationship is a non-romantic one
They both tend to get extremely protective, jealous, and sometimes violent over their given loved one
They're really sweet and the thing they want most is companionship and safety
Distrustful of others besides their loved one
massive turmoil and struggles for control within their alleged system to the point of bordering on self-loathing and self-destructive actions
would literally destroy themselves to benefit their loved one
it really is The Character and their loved one against the world, huh.
they're just both extremely devoted and sweet people and it's really fun to me that they got paired up... even if it means I have to choose one of them :')
Also... after finishing Buddy Simulator 1984 I was really sad for my Buddy. So I tried my hand at a commemorative pixel art to give them a friend and remember this matchup :)
Thanks for reading, and thanks for the tournament!! Best of luck to everyone going forward!!