꒰১ strawby ໒꒱

SATAN

Okay, as much as it pains me to say I feel like he would reaaally prefer a wilder mc. While i see room in all the kings to like a shy mc cause, cute, i think satan would see it as just a "phase" the most. I mean, he's the one always encouraging our mc to do the things they want to do. Also, having a shy mc takes away the pleasure of making you crash out (not to say shy people can't crash out... but, im picturing someone who is very reserved and perhaps quieter). In terms of sex, he'd prefer a wild mc even more. I feel he's the type to prefer sexyness over cuteness, and y'know he gets really rowdy and likes mc to match his freak. Sooo yeah.

MAMMON

It's a bit hard for this one... I see him liking both equally. He can obviously loove a really out there, sex-driven wild mc as we know, but I feel like he also adores cuteness. I feel like a shy person would give him cuteness agression the most of course, and he'd be more inclined to see you as a cute pet rather than an equal partner. In a way, and I don't know how to put this better, but... I feel like he'd see a shy mc as inferior to him. Since you're just so cute and demure, he can't help it. This isn't bad (to me at least lol) but it'd be different. During sex, again, he'd like both. He'd find a way to like manhandling you and encouraging, and perhaps lightly teasing, a shy mc, and he'd also enjoy being really rowdy. Hm.

LEVIATHAN

I'll just rip the bandaid and say that he'd find a shy/reserved person as weak and would not want to give them the time of day. There... Okay. Wild mc is his go to. BUT I do also think Levi deep, deep, deeeeep down finds shyness really freaking cute. Like really. If mcs reserved side was way too much to ignore, especially being a devil, he would get annoyed pretty quickly. He's not going to waste his time trying to make you open up more. But, if he were to like you, I feel like he'd accept it more. In a way he'd still find that side of you sliightly pathetic, but, he'd also end up thinking it's endearing. During sex, I feel like he can enjoy shyness more than in a daily basis. He'll 100% insult you, yum, but a part of him will also try to help you be more vocal with your needs. He likes having the upper ground.

BEELZEBUB

Our first shy mc lover~ for the sole reason that I think he has a HUGE corruption kink. Or maybe a silly human kink is a better word for it. Lol. It's already canon that beel gets super turned on when mc gets all embarrassed, my brain really goes brr whenever I remember. So, obviously while he likes you all wild and wet, having mc all cute and shy, covering their face and whining in embarrassment when he's fucking them is really just perfection to him. (aughhh) Generally, outside of sex, I think he'd prefer you being reserved as well. Similar to mammon, I feel like beel has a tendency to see mc as less of an equal and more like an exotic pet or toy to have around. And, a shy mc would very much satisfy him. He'd tease you nonstop, though. Lol.

BELPHEGOR

This one isss a hard one as well. I'd say he'd need both. In terms of preference, I feel like while he can love both a sex freak and a cute bnnuy, but he'd prefer cutie shy mc, cause it reminds him of his eromangas. Lol. So, yeah... Especially since he's big into maids, a quiet n reserved mc would really suit his taste. He'd be able to do whatever he wants with you, and he does like the cuteness of it all. BUT. If you are even slightly annoying to him (for example, pushing him away from embarrassment), he'd probably disengage. Just cause he's lazy and doesn't really wanna waste his energy on soothing you. He's a bit of an asshole. Also, if you're really really shy, that means he'll have to do all the work since you won't initiate and/or won't do the motions of sex for him lol. So, a cute mc would make his bone hard, but it'd be annoying in practice.

LUCIFER

Aaaanother shy mc lover, for the only reason that his inner ego would be sooo stroked. Now, in terms of him initally, like Levi he'd probably not engage a lot. But I feel like he'd be distant and act like a bit of a jerk anyways. And, he's drawn to mc no matter what, so he'd warm up eventually. He'd end up seeing the shy side or the sexy side as endearing in different ways, and he'd like you anyways lol. Once he's in better terms with you though, he'd favor the shyness. He would try to coax you into being more open, but deep down he loooves feeling superior to you. He's not ashamed by sex or intimacy, so having you be a blushing mess in his hands (or just in your day to day life) would give for a great show and he'd feel very superior.

ASMODEUS

This one is hard because we know damn well Asmodeus does not gaf. I can't see him having a preference because he likes EVERYTHING. But, I can at least point out what he'd like about each type of mc. With Asmo you don't have to worry, he'll fuck you no matter what. For a wild mc, of course he'd be happy. I feel like everyone who gets with Asmodeus ends up just mindbroken and gets in this kind of state. It won't be much difference to him during sex, but he likes a rowdy person on casual times too. He enjoys seeing you do stuff so straight-forwardly and being out there. He also enjoys seeing a shy mc do things, and again finds all of it really cute and endearing. A shy mc reminds him more of humans and we know he luuuvs humans. During sex, you probably won't stay shy for long let's be honest... but he likes your hesitance. We know he's banged Amy especifically because he liked his reactions (pure horror) and you're somewhat similar. Yaay. Good luck bro

As a little conclusion, I think all of them would end up favoring a mix of both the most! They love getting cuteness agression from a blushy, very human mc, and then get blown away by a wild sex-crazed side. Basically, our mc. Lol. This is a very self indulgent post, srry, lool. Hope y'all enjoy it anyways :3