I think Heated Rivalry does an interesting thing with giving viewers just enough to be able to enjoy the chemistry between Ilya & Shane with or without engaging in the D/s dynamic of it. Thats my generous interpretation of whatâs going on.
My less generous interpretation is that heated rivalry is so compelling *because* the love story is made more electric with bdsm, but itâs intentionally made more commercially successful through plausible deniability to not alienate/scandalize a wider audience. Dog whistling if you will, while cloaking some of the more misunderstood aspects of kink in scenes like the Vegas bathroom / penthouse with a level of emotional turmoil that gives viewers a way to opt out of (and in some cases, blame) the bdsm of it all.
So thereâs one reading of those scenes where Ilya & Shane are roleplaying to artificially mask their true desire to be more emotionally vulnerable with each other. Like playing dress up to make things less intimate / real. Itâs hot but itâs keeping their hearts safe. Reidâs Vegas bonus/blog chapter makes reading this scene a bit blurry, and I find it fascinating that she decided to include it/release it after the book was published â did she feel pressure to clarify that Ilya was actually acting out of fear in those scenes? Did that justify his particular flavor of sadism in that moment? I think thatâs where the plausible deniability comes in.
Because for people who appreciate the sadism in those scenes, the way Ilya is acting feels more intimate than not. Heâs trying to understand Shane and himself and the ways in which they are sparking this hunger thats gnawing gnashing growling inside them; when Ilya makes Shane pout and cry and Ilya hears the quiver in his voice when Shaneâs shouting back at him, itâs Ilyaâs way of finding the crack in the shields theyâve both been using to keep themselves safe. His sadism is getting them closer, and Shaneâs submission to it is accepting that, rewarding that sharpness from Ilya with a softness he shares back. Itâs not a crutch to avoid emotional intimacy, it IS their intimacy.
But itâs also tangled up in the emotionally devastating reality of their circumstances, they can barely get to know each other because theyâre separated by the homophobia & racism & the injustices of their career, countries, families, and their respective traumas navigating all of that. So theyâre bonding through sex without enough of Everything Else â communication, hanging out, casual mutual enjoyment â to fully support each other as much as they each need, and they hurt each other in the process. This is true whether or not sadism is the main driver of the scene, as evidenced by Ilyaâs botched tunamelt-his-heart scheme, so itâs a bit of a double standard to say that ilyas sadism is less intimate / mature / loving than his âsofterâ side. But by giving the Vegas scenes an unhappy ending (Ilya not knowing how to ask for less emotionally charged pillow talk from Shane, Shane not knowing how to ask Ilya for a sweet kiss goodbye), there is an escape hatch for anyone viewing who doesnât enjoy / want to enjoy their D/s dynamics.
The plausible deniability extends to how ilyas sadism is portrayed throughout his narrative arc as well. His demeanor during Shaneâs first time anal is portrayed as gentle and encouraging and then he ghosts Shane for six months and the next time they fuck heâs big bad wolf-ing it, and Shane thumps his head on the elevator door and deletes his we didnât even kiss text. Itâs Good Ilya vs Bad Ilya and the bad Ilya is also kinkier. And then towards the end of the story, the domming and sadism become less stereotypical, which is refreshing for viewers who are enjoying the breadth of that portrayal, but can be more easily ignored by anyone who doesnât want it. Ilya forcing giving Shane a blowjob while heâs on the phone with Hayden is crackling with sadistic electricity, but thereâs giggling and the sun is pouring through the windows and theyâre at the cottage theyâre endgame theyâre about to tell each other I Love You and anyone who isnât looking for bdsm there doesnât have to see it.
So when someone tags these scenes âfor those with eyes to seeâ they are offering a perspective that is real, itâs based in the canon of the fictional lives of Ilya & Shane and the real lives of kinksters everywhere. But if you donât want to see it, Heated Rivalry says, well? Shane kneeling at Ilyaâs feet in times of stress could mean nothing. Make of it what you will.