Starry

Lilith wakes up human with no memories of anything after Eden. She doesn't know where she is or what anything is (Why can't I see the sky? What do you mean there's a ceiling blocking it? What are you talking about?). She has Lucifer but he looks different and he won't explain why. She has a daughter but she doesn't understand because she didn’t want to be a mother. Where's Eve? Where's Adam? Who are all these other people? She thought there were no other humans. Who is this other man that she was sleeping next to and why is he trying to hurt Lucifer?

Alastor woke up in a strange place with strange people. He doesn't know who Lilith is and he doesn't know what Lucifer is. He'd been trying to reach the other side but this is not what he asked for. He's wearing clothes that are much too big for him to the point where the pants just fall off and he's left in an oversized shirt. The demon won't let Alastor through the door and Alastor can't overpower him so he locks himself in the bathroom. He tears the place to shreds to look for something to defend himself with and ends up with scissors.

Lucifer wakes up and both his partners are humans and if that wasn’t insane enough they also have no memories of being in hell. He has to try to answer both their questions and comfort them while keeping Lilith clothed and Alastor from hurting someone.

Also Lilith: there's not actually a lot of empty warehouses in hell because even if they're not owned or rented out people will use them anyway mostly for drug operations

Charlie's main weapon shouldn't be a trident or a shield. It should be a chain because it fits so perfectly with her and her character and how she prefers to fight.

I actually kind of agree about the trident but not the shield.

I like to think that the trident was actually a gift from Lucifer. It had the apple and the snake which are mostly Lucifer’s motifs (though we do see her wear another snake in season two so maybe she just also likes snakes). It's also very clearly supposed to be the devil's pitchfork and I think it makes sense for Lucifer to arm his daughter seeing how much he hates sinners and thinks their dangerous. It really doesn't feel like something Charlie would choose for herself either.

The shield make a lot of sense for her though because shielding people is kind of her whole thing. She doesn't want to fight but she does want to protect. She doesn't want to hurt anyone but she desperately wants to keep her people, friends, and family safe. I actually love that she went into a battle against the exorcists with just a shield and not a more violent option like everyone else had. The only person she hurt that entire fight was Adam with the trident before that she was the shield to Vaggi's spear (which I also love because we learned from Carmilla that the exorcists don't really know how to defend themselves they only know how to attack so the two of them sticking together with Charlie defending and Vaggi attacking was SO good) and even when Vaggi tried to get her to be more aggressive all Charlie did was shoot fireworks that distracted the angels but didn't hurt them.

The chain IS an interesting option though because it's also a less violent option but it gives her the chance to get more offensive then a sheild would. I think it's also thematically interesting with her father being chained and her using a chain.

So yeah I would keep the shield but replace the trident with a chain. I actually think Lilith should get the trident. Hey maybe Lucifer gave Lilith the trident and then Charlie either took it or was given it by one of her parents after she left. It just feels like a very Lilith weapon.

I LOVE giving her Eden quirks. While I think she does have good table manners (at least around most people) because she's the queen I do agree about the clothes. I think she'd just casually walk around the palace with no clothes on and she absolutely sleeps naked. She sees nothing wrong with it because she doesn't view bodies as inherently sexual the way a lot of people learned to.

She also for sure has no filter when it comes to sex and not only because of Eden but because she's been in hell for so long. There's basically no such thing as a taboo subject for her and I do like to imagine Angel and Cherri ending up loving her because of this. (Cherri wants Lilith so bad btw and she's kinda mad about it but we don't have to get into that right now lmao)

I also think she's great with pretty much anything to do with nature and surviving in the wild. She can hunt and fish with her bare hands and create her own weapons out of sticks and stone. She can skin and gut and prepare food though she sucks at making it taste good. She can point out which plants are edible and which are poisonous. She can fall asleep literally anywhere because she spent the beginning of her life sleeping on the ground and sometimes in trees.

She loves to climb trees and make flower crowns and swim and play with animals and look up into the sky and spend hours finding shapes in clouds or stars.

A lot of these are also things that no one knows about her. She's the queen and she wants her people to see her in a certain way. She's compassionate but she's powerful and someone they should respect and look up to. They don't get to know her as the carefree woman who runs barefoot through fields. They don't get to hear her laugh at the shapes Lucifer claims the clouds are making or hear her harmonize with bird song. She has a perfectly crafted mask for people who aren't her family and it's not fake but it's not entirely true either.