Having a preference is one thing but honestly, if you go and say "A system is mora accurate than B system", that's just admitting you have a shallow understanding of astrology and you're probably never going to be an astrologer.
In context of sidereal practicioners (esp vedic) bashing on tropical; it's not the tropical system's fault if you can't go beyond modern pop astrology and get your info from instagram and twitter. It's a thousands years old system and personality natal chart is 1/10000th of the practice. Traditional tropical astrologers use the sects, triplicities, chronocrators, fixed stars, lots, bounds (terms), decans ETC. Mesopotamians, Romans, Byzantines, Seljjuks, Ottomans, Abbasids, Umayyads, Sassanians all used mainly tropical system, but often mixed both because a good astrologer expands. Tropical astrology was the astrology of power, empire, administration, and statecraft while Sidereal astrology was tied to ritual timing, cosmology, and spiritual cycles. So, just because you don't relate to being a tropical Cancer because you're not a crybaby as the IG astrologers call it, doesn't mean tropical is not as accurate. I hope that's clear.
The funny thing is, most of the time someone says "sidereal is more accurate than tropical" they are literally not good at either......If you don't understand a system by heart, you can't know how it differs from others and you'll mix up all the dichotomies. I see this even in so called sidereal "astrologers".
Debilitation / Exaltation in Sidereal vs. Tropical
Using sidereal astro is meaningless if you practice it while thinking from a tropical pov and many people (including some vedic astrologers) cant make the distinguishment...it's like writing in a phonetically incompatible alphabet. Most of the time people try to use tropical astro's understanding of these terms in sidereal and it just doesnt work. Esp in Vedic, "exaltation" heavily corralates to dharma, good deeds & spiritual fullfillment. It doesn't give the material success & happiness you imagine, debilitation does that instead.
Examples: Libra/Aries (Virgo/Pisces) & Sagittarius/Gemini (Scorpio/Taurus)
Libra Venus, which is domicile in tropical becomes debilitated Virgo Venus in sidereal for a reason, and vice versa. They are, contrary to popular belief, not contradicting each other. Both these placements tell you the same story and you reach the same conclusions with both, only if you know how to speak both languages.
Sidereal originates in Babylonia and eventually its philosophy became integrated within eastern philosophy meanwhile Tropical is based upon western philosophies.
Tropical works in very literal and straightforward ways. It's not focused on "dharma" as eastern philosophy Sidereal and vedic is, so when you have exalted/domicile placements in tropical you get direct results from it in the material world the way its described.
E.g tropical Libra venus; yes, as it is described in tropical you are most likely a fashion icon, can't be in non-aesthetic places, like to flirt with everyone and leverage social gains, meticulously beautify yourself and find yourself in complicated love affairs. As you see, the tropical manifestation is very much focused on worldly gains, its' obvious manifestation and self-benefits.
It becomes debilitated in sidereal because sidereal's concept of exaltation is not worldly success or ego satisfaction, it is dharma and spiritual ascension. This is why you see usually tropical malefic placements becoming benefic in sidereal, such as tropical scorpio turning into libra and tropical capricorn turning into tropical sagittarius. The worldly hardships they go through primes them for spirituality and moksha.
Also read this for comparison of sidereal virgo venus vs pisces venus
We can also compare Sidereal Scorpio moon (debilitated) vs Taurus moon (exalted) to understand how dignities work in sidereal.
As i've said before most scorpio moons are engulfed in maternal care and attention since birth and tend to have over sacrificial mothers who are willing to do anything for them, even put them on a pedestal. Mine for example does everything for me unprompted and glazes me for the smallest accomplishment or attempt - so why is moon debilitated in sidereal Scorpio?
That is because despite all the attention and care, Scorpio moon is deeply apathetic (co-ruled by ketu) and discontent. There's a void that's very hard to fill, and it's hard to make a Scorpio moon feel geniunely nourished and maybe that's why they are granted with such parents. They are also naturally more inclined to be repelled from their mother - unlike Taurus. Scorpio moon is generally restless and deals with oppression (especially about religion/freedom) from their family. It's noteworthy that in tropical also, sagittarius moon is peregrine position.
Taurus moons face a lot of discrimination and lack of nourishment/care from their mother. a LOT of taurus natives i know are either motherless or straight up have terrible mothers; volatile, abusive and negligent. despite this, they will still care and stand for their family. They are usually granted a very solid nervous system which prevents them from having extreme mood swings and they tend to feel fullfilled with even smallest things. they strive to be good to their family no matter what they go through, henceforth moon exaltation.
Neither tropical or sidereal are better or worse than e/o in terms of accuracy, they are both accurate and both work perfectly. The most skilled astrologers in history used a blend of methods from Hellenic, Islamic, Vedic and Mesapotamian studies.