I'm Afraid That I... | Benjamin Poindexter
Part Two of For a Minute, I Lost Myself | Read Part One here!
Pairing: Benjamin Poindexter x Reader
Summary: After all that had occurred between you and Poindexter when you saved his life, the anger, the tears, the touch, you knew that whatever this was, it wasn't over. And as Fisk's hold on New York City grows, Poindexter may be the only person you can turn to.
Warnings + Tags: MORE T E N S I O N, graphic violence, explicit language, use of Y/N, stalking, mentions of grief and death/murder, more debates about morality, hospitals, Dex is a mish mash of Born Again Dex and Daredevil series 3 Dex, based on episode 2x07 of Born Again, reader is in an ethical pickle, Dex really yearns in this one
A/N: Thank you so much for all the likes, comments, and reblogs on the first part of this fic, and for the encouragement to continue! I hope you enjoy the second part <3
Word Count: 4.5k
---
It had all gone horribly wrong.
You had heeded Matt's call for aid. Which, much to your dismay, had actually been for Benjamin Poindexter. Bullseye. The man you despised. And against your better judgement, you had stepped over the line that you yourself had drawn when you lost your temper with him. When you broke any distance between you and Poindexter, lunging yourself onto his thighs as you gripped his hair so hard that he had moaned. When you came to your senses, but still inexplicably refused to move away from him. When he had pressed his forehead ever so gently to yours, calming you down, and you had enjoyed it.
You had been so distracted by him that for the first time since assisting Karen and Matt, you had assumed their footfalls. And you had been wrong. You had heard the weight of Matt's boots against the concrete hallway, and had automatically taken for granted that Karen would be there also. But she wasn't.
You're standing by the doorway to the hideout, cheeks still flushed and fists clenched to ease the shaking, when only Matt staggers through, beaten and bloody. Your heart sinks at the sight. From behind you, you can hear Poindexter moving on that damned make-shift bed, curiosity getting the best of him. Immediately attending to Matt, you throw his arm over your shoulder and help him to the nearest seat.
"What happened?" You say softly as possible, trying to hide the panic in your voice but failing. "Where's Karen?"
"They got her." Matt winces. "She'd planned to expose Fisk at the protest, with the interviews we'd filmed from those he and the Task Force had imprisoned. She was gonna plaster them all over City Hall. But Powell found her. She's at the 15th Precinct. And it's all been done legally."
He pauses, and you can tell that he's trying to get his thoughts straight.
"Fisk means to hold her as an example- as proof of the legitimacy of his Vigilante Court, and as a consequence of those who act against him. He won't stop until this is over."
"Shit." The word escapes you before you realise. "What do we do?"
"Well if we break her out, we're the criminals he says we are. We're going to have to beat him at his own game."
He pauses again.
"For now though Y/N, it's best if you lay low. Keep to normality. We may need you if things go wrong, and they can't know that you're helping us. It'll only get you hurt."
You go to protest. How can I go back to normality when Karen's locked in Fisk's cell? When she's in danger?
Matt's words, however, interrupt your objection before you can even speak it. He turns towards Poindexter.
"You, however."
Matt rises from his seat, slowly moving towards Poindexter. Your eyes follow Matt's every move. You know what Matt is capable of, and it is for that reason that you're never quite sure what he will do.
And once again, he surprises you.
Poindexter's hands are released from the handcuffs. As he turns his wrists, the bones crack a teeth-clenching sound. You grimace at the noise.
"You wanted one good deed, right? So we could balance the scales?"
"Yeah. Sure." Poindexter responds nonchalantly.
"Well then, I've got it for you." But then Matt stops, his breathing uneven, as if he's trying to restrain himself from losing his composure. "But first, know this. I hate you for Foggy. I hate you for Father Lantom. For Agent Nadeem. And for every life you've wasted for no reason other than your own twisted soul."
Your chest aches at his words. Aches at the agony in his voice. Your hands clench into fists, the tremor still present.
"Part of me wants to kill you...And part of me needs to forgive you."
You're not surprised, however, at Matt's will to be kind, adamant to forgive and show grace towards others, especially to those undeserving of it.
"Well...thanks."
Poindexter's response seems to come off as if it's mockery, but to you, the tone strikes you as though he believes he is past the point of forgiveness. There's a sadness hidden deeper beneath his brief words, and it makes you feel almost pitiful towards him. But unlike Matt, you have not chosen to forgive just yet.
Poindexter stands from the bed, letting out a small groan as his hand covers the gauze on his abdomen. As he does, you're taken aback by just how tall he is, not to mention how toned his body is, which must be from the years of military and federal service Matt once mentioned. He holds such a presence just simply standing there. You dread to think what he must be like in action, be like as Bullseye. No wonder people fear the mere mention of his name. Even standing here, you can't seem to tear your eyes away from him. You're not afraid though.
You try to maintain your focus on Matt, who's sitting beside you, rather than stare at Poindexter.
"Don't do that. It's not for you. It's for them." Matt retorts back, whilst throwing Poindexter one of his own jumpers. "Now go, disappear, die, I don't care. But if you mean what you say, you wanna do one good thing in a life full of shit, then I've got it for you."
'You know I can't make any promises, right?" That stupid smirk is back on Poindexter lips, taunting Matt.
"Wouldn't believe you if you did."
As he looks down towards the jumper, his smirk fades. He seems lost in thought. Oh. It would be so easy for him, the thought appears in your mind without hesitation. He could finish what he started. Starting with us. You’re trying not to doubt Matt’s actions, you trust him completely, of course you do. This isn’t just anybody though. He should not be underestimated.
But then Poindexter’s eyes are lifting to fall upon you, softening as they catch your gaze. A small, gentle smile appears on his lips. There's no sense of malice or smugness in his expression, and you feel no fear, no dread, your thoughts quietened. You let out a breath of surprise. No one has quite looked at you like that in a long time.
His attention returns to Matt whilst he puts the jumper on.
"What do you need me to do?"
"We think that Fisk is targeting the Governor. She's the only one who has the power to stop him, and if he gets his hands on her, and puts one of his puppets in place then it's over."
"And you want me to protect her?"
"Yes."
Poindexter contemplates this, before his eyes flicker to yours again.
"I will do what I can."
Tearing his eyes away from you, Poindexter gathers his bloodied shirt and holster before making his way to the door. He looks back at you one last time, nods as if to say goodbye, and then he's gone. Your eyes linger there.
"What did he do?" Matt's voice catches you off guard, making you jump.
"What?"
"Your heart, it's racing. Did he hurt you?"
"No! No, he didn't."
"Did he threaten you?”
"No, he did not. Thankfully, he was unconscious for the most part." Until he wasn't. Until his large hands were on my thighs, and his forehead was on mine-
"Thank God." He murmurs. "I don't want anyone else to suffer. There's been enough of that lately as it is."
His words break your heart. Your hand finds his, and then you reach round to hug him.
"It's going to be okay. Karen will be okay. There's a whole bunch of people out there who care, who want to help. And we will help. You are not alone in this, Matt. You call me, I'll be there."
-------
It's mid afternoon now. You had left Matt at the hideout to head to your shift at Metro-General Hospital. So far, it has been a relatively steady morning, all things considered. You had checked in on a number of patients, and assisted a fair few emergencies.
You're passing through the hallway to collect your next patient, an elderly lady named Janice, to take her to physiotherapy, as you do weekly. You enjoy listening to her stories every now and again, as she keeps you up to date with her familial goings-on, and the latest gossip amongst her book club. Occasionally, she tries to set you up with a friend's grandson or her postman or someone, to no avail.
As you make your way to meet her, you hear Kristen's voice echo through the halls of the hospital. Looking across the corridor, you see the television on the waiting room's wall screening Karen's court hearing.
"Prosecution can now call its first witness." You hear the Judge speak.
"Your honours, before we proceed, I'd like to bring in my co-counsel." Kirsten's voice cuts through.
You roll your eyes as District Attorney Hochberg tries to berate Kirsten. What a prick.
But then the doors to the court open. And through them enters Matt Murdock. You hear some patients in the waiting room gasp at the sight. Oh God. He's thrown himself directly into the lion's den. You try to reassure yourself. He wouldn't do this if he didn't have a plan, surely.
It's at that moment you spot Janice in the corner of your eye, sitting across the room patiently waiting for you. Keep to normality Matt said. Focus on your work. Don't draw any attention to yourself. You make your way towards her, greeting her as cheerfully as you can and offering her your arm.
------
All Dex could think of was you. He can still feel the ghost of your hand tugging his hair, the weight of you on him, and your perfume is following his every step.
He had tried to control himself, he really had. Not with you, he had thought to himself. Must be better for you. History wouldn't repeat itself. He would do things differently this time. Not like Julie. It wouldn't, couldn't, be like that.
He had tried to be gentler, softer, compassionate. Just like you.
"I'm glad that you weren't there." He had said to you, earnestly.
But then the rage, the heartbreak, had been too much. He couldn't bear to see you with such expressions on your face. Not you.
He knew he'd lost control of himself as soon as he had pressed his forehead against yours. And after years of being so distanced from you, he couldn't help but want more. He needed you closer.
He thinks of how you relaxed in his arms. How you didn't pull away. He'd be lying if he said he wasn't pleased about that. That he had an effect on you. That he enjoyed it. And that you had enjoyed it too, he'd noticed. He caught the heat on your cheeks. He saw how you were desperately trying to conceal your trembling hands.
He hadn't left afterwards. Instead he'd remained within enough distance to hear Matt's interrogation. He had heard you lie to Matt, someone you considered family, for him. He had smiled to himself at that. That moment was yours and yours alone. It made Dex feel more protective over you than ever.
He enters Metro-General Hospital. He's searching every face for yours. It's risky being here, he knows that. Those AVTF bastards are everywhere.
But his mind replays your words that you spoke to Matt over and over again, burning them to memory, as you soothed him with a tenderness that Dex needs.
"It's going to be okay. You are not alone in this. You call me, I'll be there."
And suddenly as he turns the corner, there you are. Across the hallway, he can see you, listening intently to the elderly woman on your arm. He tries to ignore the jealousy creeping in at the sight of the woman's hand on you, and how she's clearly said something humorous enough to make you chuckle.
You look so beautiful.
In that instant, his choice is made. He knows what he has to do. He knows that he has to make things right, to balance the scales. One good deed for Foggy Nelson's life. One good deed for you.
-----
You're listening to the latest outrageous happenings of Janice's friend, Nora, and her visits to their local Zumba class when Janice abruptly stops her story.
Your laughter fades as you turn to look at her, concerned. She's noticed something across the room. All of a sudden, your stomach drops.
She leans into you, and begins to whisper.
"My dear, there's a very tall, very handsome man looking your way over there."
Oh no.
You don't need to look at him to know who it is. But you do nonetheless.
Poindexter is standing there, amongst the crowd. It’s alarming, the speed at which you find him. Even though he’s tried to disguise himself as an ordinary civilian, with his black baseball cap and his black bomber jacket on, you’d recognise him anywhere. His hands are crossed in front of him, making him look patient, polite, as if he's waiting for someone. You can't seem to stop the flashes that appear in your mind of those very hands on you.
But you can make out the blue of his tactical 'Bullseye' shirt peeking out from over the top of his jacket. Is he here as Bullseye, or as Benjamin? The uncertainty makes your chest burn.
What if he's going to help? What if he's going to do as Matt asked?
You could slap yourself, really. What a ridiculous thing to think. As if you could trust him. As if you would want to trust him. After everything he'd done to Matt, to Karen, Foggy.
He had said it himself.
"I can't make any promises," He'd said to Matt, with that goddamn smirk wiped across his face.
But after the way he'd acted towards you this morning, his rough hands holding you so securely yet so gently, and like some cruel joke, calming your fury, not to mention that look he’d given you before leaving, one so charged with affection, you couldn’t be certain.
What you are certain of, however, is that he's observed you before, of course he has. But being here, in front of you, making himself known to you. And in a public space. This is new. This is dangerous.
Though it feels like much longer, you must've only seen him for a brief moment before he disappears back into the crowd. Your mind is buzzing.
---
Since the night fell, Dex has been waiting for Fisk's latest puppet to break into the Governor's home. Finally after a couple of hours, the bastard decides to show up, sauntering in like he's already succeeded. He won't, Dex smirks to himself behind his mask.
Following him towards the Governor's office, he throws two of his blades at the man, one into his elbow and one to the back of his head, causing him to release his chokehold on the Governor and fall to the ground. The hits won't kill him instantly, no, he's needed as a witness. It doesn't stop Dex from making him suffer though. He deserves it.
The Governor turns to look at Dex, eyes wide and frantic in a state of shock. He gives her a casual salute, as if to say you're welcome, to let her know that he's one of the good guys now. His mask hides his smile.
You're going to be so pleased. He's done his one good deed.
He cheerfully strolls out of the Governor's home, with you on his mind once again now that his mission is complete. He's humming a tune that he's heard coming from your apartment on several occasions, one of your favourite songs it seems.
One night in particular, he had found himself on the rooftop opposite your apartment after a particularly shit assignment. Sent in as Fisk’s personal hitman, he’d been tasked to take out the latest gangsters and their mob boss. He hadn’t bothered learning their names. It was supposed to be quiet, a quick in and out job, as if he was never there. Then there had been a bullet aimed at his thigh, disarming him. That pissed him off. He had staggered out with blood oozing down his leg, two more wounds to his shoulder and bruises scattered across his face. He'd survive though, he always did.
He had arrived on that rooftop, the wounds still raw and bleeding, his suit now growing more red than blue, with an urge to see you. You were the only thing he felt that could sedate him.
He had watched you through his scope. You had seemed especially joyful that evening. Your hair was free, your pyjamas on, your makeup removed. He thought you looked like the image of perfection.
You were swaying to the music playing from your stereo system as you poured yourself a glass of something colourful. You had stopped suddenly, making your way towards the front door excitedly and returning with a takeaway bag in hand. He had chuckled at that, as he begun to stitch his wounds with shaky hands. It hadn't mattered that his blood had pooled on the concrete. Hadn't mattered that he'd massacred over fifteen men just hours before. You were here with him and that was enough.
---
By the end of your shift, you feel exhausted. What with the usual hustle and bustle of Metro-General, checking Karen's court case every now and again (especially after Matt's surprise appearance) and then to top it all off, everything to do with him that had all occurred in the span of one damn day, you were ready to go home.
You had clocked off your shift later than intended, staying longer to assist an emergency regarding a little boy and a broken ankle, and it was now pitch black outside. The closer you get to home, the less life there seems to be around.
Tugging your coat closer to you, you try to pay attention to the street ahead. You're very nearly home, just two blocks away. Thank God.
Ever since he had stepped foot inside the hospital earlier today, you had struggled to shake him from your mind. This was the first time he'd done this, but you knew it certainly wouldn't be the last. Why? Why me? It surely can't just be because of this morning, can it? Maybe it can. But you have the dreadful sense that this runs deeper. What had he said this morning?
"I'm glad that you weren't there."
He'd known you wouldn't be there to witness Foggy's murder. His surveillance of you was obvious, he did this with everyone. But somehow this felt different. Did he keep watch over you regularly? Aside from observing you with Daredevil? And the sentiment behind those words. It had sounded...earnest. Not cruelty, but relief in the way he'd breathed out the words. That look he'd given you. The gentleness of his forehead to yours. It had been so intimate. More intimate than anything you'd know before. Did you like that? After everything he'd done, and you had liked it-
Your thoughts are interrupted when your phone buzzes in your pocket. Looking over your shoulder subconsciously as if someone is there, you take out your phone to see Cherry's name pop up.
We've been compromised. The AVTF attacked. Do not go home.
Panic rises in your chest. You knew as soon as Matt appeared in the courtroom, that it would put an illuminated target on his back. The AVTF were brutal, unrelenting towards civilians. But for Daredevil, for Matt, it doesn't bear thinking about.
What do I do?
So you can't go home. You don't have anyone else who you can go to, no family nearby. Karen's locked away in a cell, and Matt's God knows where, probably fighting for his life. You suppose you could go back to the hospital, there are always trusted friends and colleagues around, always a safe space for you.
But they'd find you eventually.
You don't know what compels you to do it, you shouldn't have done it really, but it’s the only option.
Clutching your phone, you turn around to face the shadows of the street. The words leave your mouth before your brain catches up.
"Dex?" You speak to the shadows. "You there?"
There's silence. You hold your breath with anticipation as you try not to berate yourself for indulging in this stupid idea.
But then you hear his heavy footsteps. And out of the shadows, he steps. Bullseye. As he comes closer, he removes his mask for you, his blonde hair dishevelled but his face less bloody than it had been this morning.
"You know, you shouldn't be walking at night on your own." He says, and there's a small smile playing on his lips, not quite the smirk but close.
"I haven't been on my own since I left the hospital, have I?" Your response is quick. Challenging.
He doesn't respond to that. But the look on his face is confirmation enough.
You're trying to find the words to do what? Ask him for help? Ask him to protect you? You haven't got a clue. But his words fill your silence.
"I did what Murdock asked. He was right, Fisk is trying to kill the Governor. But she's safe now. I made sure of that."
Your eyes widen at his words. He did help.
"You can't go home." He says suddenly. How on Earth-
"What? Why?"
The assassin suddenly seems shy under your gaze. He's struggling to find the right words, awkward, like a child who's just been caught doing something they know they shouldn't have done.
"Fisk knows you're in connection with Murdock. Those AVTF assholes are there, waiting for you."
So he's been to your home tonight. Most likely between visiting the Governor's house and meeting you at work, you assume. You shouldn't have been surprised really.
You breathe out a sigh. A faint siren in the distance blares in the silence between you and Dex as you deliberate.
"What do we do?" You ask him, meeting his eyes.
We. Dex loves that you've said that. He begins to move closer to you, slowly, as if you may run from him if he steps too far. The gloves he's wearing are removed and tucked into his pocket. Your eyes don't leave his.
As soon as he opens his mouth to offer a solution, he closes it again, his head turning away from you as his stare darkens.
A bullet whistles between you, just narrowly avoiding you.
Before you can even begin to comprehend what just happened, you feel Dex’s hand on your wrist, wrenching you both away from the glow of the streetlights and into a nearby alleyway.
He's behind you. His hand that was holding your wrist now comes to wrap securely around your waist whilst his other hand rises to cover your mouth, his forearm against your shoulders, as his back hits brick. A small grunt escapes him from the impact, and the hand over your mouth softens the shock that escapes from your lips as your back hits his firm chest. His jaw clenches at the feeling of your soft gasp against his fingers.
There's a beat. The gunfire has ceased.
Dex's hand that is over your mouth shifts, his forefinger dragging over your lips until it stops against them, warning you to be silent. You close your eyes, nodding. He can feel your lips parting, a breath escaping you, but the touch feels like a kiss. He wills himself to pull his hand away from you, retaining any shred of self-control he has. But his other hand still remains on your waist, gripping with fierce possession. He can feel you shifting closer towards him, pressing into him, as you turn your head slightly as if to hide your face against him, your breath hitting his collarbone.
He reaches into his pocket, his fingers finding his knives. In his peripheral vision, he sees movement. He doesn't hesitate. The blade slips from his grasp, the body hits the ground with a thud.
You can hear a voice shout, rallying his squad to your whereabouts, but the voice is soon silenced. Another fire is shot into the darkness where you are. Without thinking, your hands come to grip Dex's arm that's around you as you flinch at the sound, attempting to ground yourself. You feel his hold on you tighten.
Two different voices shout at each other. You turn to spot them closing in on you. You don't even think you see Dex's hand move as he throws two blades at once, so effortlessly yet so precise. They fall.
Dex immediately notices the final man with the AVTF symbol on his chest. This one looks afraid. Good. He should be. The man is hesitant, his eyes alert as he surveys the shadows of the alleyway you're hidden in. It seems they're extending the search to find you beyond your street. Not on Dex's watch. The knife goes clean through his chest.
It's fallen silent, the air still. Your grip on Dex's arm releases, but his grip on you doesn't. Not straight away.
Only when his touch eases, when he feels it's safe for you to leave, do you. You're trusting him. You pull yourself away from his hold with heavy breaths. What the Hell just happened.
"There'll be more." You hear Dex say behind you.
Turning to face him, you note how he's not meeting your gaze. Instead he's blinking rapidly, whilst his eyes flicker between the bodies. There's a brush of pink dusting his cheeks.
"So what, are you my guardian angel now or something?" A small quip. Something to ease the tension. It's for your own sake, you tell yourself, or is it for his? You can't help the small smile that accompanies your words.
A chuckle comes from him. You like the sound. He likes to think he's been your guardian angel long before tonight. And finally, he's looking at you, his breathing more steady.
He watches your face turn serious. Concern or suspicion? It could be either. He’s tense with anticipation.
"Why are you helping me?" You ask, quietly. Of all the things, he wasn't expecting that.
There's many different ways he could respond to this. He could lie. He could hide. But he knows you would be honest. And so should he.
"You're.." You can see him thinking, treading carefully with what words he says next, and how he's saying them. He sighs.
"You're very special to me."
He watches your eyes widen. Oh no. He's fucked up again. He's dreading what you're going to say. Dreading that you're going to leave him. The last time he'd said those words, it had been panicked, desperate, the last resort.
But you haven't left. You're distanced from him, but still there. You're looking at him with emotions he can't quite decipher, and it seems like you're about to say something.
All too soon, sirens blare, significantly closer this time. You both jolt back to reality.
"Come with me." He says, reaching for your hand.












