gator believes that to be loved will solve the issues that keep him awake at night, unfortunately for the both of you, heâs so very wrong.
warnings: some foul-ish language, not a happy ending, honestly just sad the whole way through, not proofread
all the pretty girls in the foreground of my mind
Some nights, the memories of all the women Gator used to be able to get around with haunted him. Heâs had a lot of time to reflect since his release from prison, and heâs had a lot to think about since he started meeting with his court-mandated therapist, and despite what one might think, what he pondered the most wasnât his father. It wasnât even everything heâd done, or the time heâd spent in prison, or even the scars over where his eyes once were.Â
It was the complete deterioration of any sort of âlove lifeâ he once maintained. Honestly, saying it was a love life was a stretch; he knew it was mainly a hook-up here and there, and even those were sparse. Prior to the events that had overtaken the last few years of his life, Gator was entirely too focused on being his father's dog to care about anything pertaining to a woman, until he desperately needed his dick wet, that is.Â
What makes it so awful, though, is that Gator desperately needs his dick wet, and he canât even get that far anymore.Â
Being blind has stripped Gator of just about all of his masculinity. Granted, most of that feeling is due to his own twisted view on what makes you masculine, but he feels it nonetheless.Â
i thought iâd done enough, but they keep moving the line
He tried to do the self-improvement his therapist wanted from him. He really did, and most days he even thought it was working.Â
It seemed like no matter what he did, though, it was never enough.
At first, the women heâd meet brushed him off because he was blind. This was what he prepared for the most. He could charm his way in. He could pull the baseless confidence from his past and make them laugh enough to slither his way into their roster.Â
But as soon as heâd make his way in, theyâd learn about his past, or they knew him from before, and no matter what he did, he couldnât ever convince them that heâd changed enough to be worth their time.
The fact that Gator was even looking for a connection with a woman was proof enough to him that he had changed, which just made it all the more frustrating.Â
Gatorâs entire life had been racing to finish the line his father set for him, the illusion of acceptance as the prize that kept Gator pushing like a farm animal with a treat dangling in front of his face; out of reach despite how hard he worked.
He was healing from that; he knew he was. So what kind of cruel joke is it that the universe puts him in the same tiring race after taking away everything he had to give?
and all the nights i spent fighting bad thoughts in my room, feeling so alone, might as well be on the moon
To sit alone in your thoughts is hard. Especially when you have the kind of thoughts that Gator has.Â
To sit alone in your thoughts and reach blindly into the space around you is humiliating. The world feels so much bigger when you can't see the four walls that hold you in. There is no comfort in being home, because there is no difference when the only reason you know you're home is that neither your caretaker or fathers ex-wife has led you out anywhere.Â
What does make the difference is the sounds, the scents, and the feel of other people. A hug from Dot, the laugh of one of his buddies from prison over the phone, the smell of oatmeal cookies from his caretaker.Â
The touch of someone who loves you. The smell of her perfume. That is what comforts Gator when he canât see the coziness of a familiar place.Â
Or rather, he imagined it would be, if he could ever get that far.Â
 i thought i found the antidote with you
And he was right. The night he met you, he knew something was different.Â
His caretake had stopped by on a later night to take him grocery shopping. Gator was still getting used to walking in public places (that werenât the prison) on his own, and honestly, he wasnât quite comfortable with it yet, so heâd remained in place while his caretaker left to find something on an aisle theyâd already passed. You walked passed him and Gator thought he mightâve hallucinated and walked himself over to the bakery with how sweet you smelled.
It felt as though every other sense Gator still clung to had been heightened. He could hear your shoes hit the linoleum floor from across the aisle, like the sound was being played right next to his ear, and even though there was much space between you, his skin was tingling in the way it does after youâve touched someone that cares about you.Â
âExcuse me, could I just grab that really quick?â Your voice was polite, and Gator swears heâs never heard something so clearly before.Â
Of course though, he doesnât know what âthatâ youâre talking about, and in an effort to move out of your way, he steps directly in front of the box of cookies you has serious plans for later. It draws a laugh out of you that quickly fades once you see the cane sitting in the cart and the covering over his eyes. A very serious apology follows and you place your hand on his shoulder, gently guiding him forward so that you could grab what you needed.Â
âI donât think weâve met before, but I do think youâre awful cute. Would not knowing what I look like keep you from giving me your number?â
Your confidence almost startles him. The fact that you want his number definitely does.Â
Is this what it felt like to finally catch a break?
Of course, Gator gave it to you. The rest was history.Â
You were endlessly patient with him, with his growth and his lack of sight. The softness of your relationship was something that Gator never thought heâd ever feel, and he still woke up every morning feeling like it was all a dream.
His confidence was boosted all around. His confidence in himself, but also in his ability to live.Â
Losing his vision was something that Gator really thought heâd never be able to adjust to, but you pushed him in such perfect ways that after a while, he didnât need a caretaker anymore, and he found he could accomplish much more than he initially believed possible.Â
You were everything Gator dreamed of finding in his lonely days post-prison.Â
but my head is full of poison, and my heart is full of doubt
âDonât you wish you had a real man?â Gators voice is quiet as he hold you. Youâd said your goodnights about five minutes ago, and youâd finally found a comfortable position between his arms, the pillow, and his sheets.Â
âI have a real man.â You murmur back, voice laced with a hearty mix of confusion and drowsiness.Â
âYou know what I mean.âÂ
You sigh, then turn to face him, your hands settling on his jaw and thumbs tracing over his cheekbones. âNo Gator, I donât know what you mean. You are my man, and you look pretty real to me. Felt pretty real earlier too.âÂ
Gator lets out a firm huff of air through his nose. âI canât work, I canât drive..â he pauses âI donât even know what your pretty face looks like.â Something in his whisper breaks your heart into enough pieces that you believe you could spend your lifetime trying to put them back together, and youâd still be left with only pieces and shards.
âGator, where is this coming from? I thought you were feeling good about adjusting? You know I donât think any less of you because of your vision.â You hum, pressing soft kisses to any part of his face that your lips can reach. Youâve been together long enough now to know that touch is what grounds him in moments like these.Â
âYou deserve something better thisâ His voice is as soft as it is when he whispers into your ears in the morning, and something about the duality of the tone makes the situation feel even heavier.Â
âNo one loves me like you, Alligator. It doesnât get better than this.â You know that you havenât convinced him, but he stops fighting you on it, and you count that as a win and fall asleep in his arms.Â
Gator never stops feeling like he isnât enough. He never stops wondering why you arenât enough to make him stop feeling that way.Â
iâve got toxins in my bloodstream, you tried hard to suck them out, and it feels like medication, and itâs good for me, iâm sure
He canât see it, but he knows you're exhausted. Tired of dealing with him, tired of the constant reassurance and constant fear that lingers in him.Â
It is so unlike Gator to feel so vulnerable with another person, but no matter how much he hates himself for it, he canât seem to stop the way the words throw themselves out of his mouth.Â
âWhy do you want me?â
âAm I not too much for you?â
âDonât you get tired of helping me?â
âAm I enough?â
âAm I enough?â
You were tired. But not angry or frustrated, not yet. It just hurt your heart to see the man you loved repeatedly disregard the words of comfort that you told him and choose the lies his brain spewed instead.Â
But you tried. You tried really hard, for a really long time, to make him believe you.
but it donât matter how your love feels anymore
You stopped spending so much time in Gators home. He knew this was the beginning of the end, he was blind, not stupid.Â
His doubtful comments were no longer met with soft and delicate words, but rather a sigh and a kiss on the cheek, almost like heâd hit his limit and your comfort was now locked behind a paywall he couldnât afford. Or rather, locked behind emotional maturity and security he couldn't comprehend.Â
This space had Gator thinking, which is never, ever, good.
He thought back to the beginning, when the two of you were still fresh and everything still felt like there was a glittering gold bow on top. He realized that even then, he still felt this way.
He still felt like you were entirely too good for him, and that one day heâd wake up and realize it was all some practical joke. He felt like every time you went out without him you met twenty other men who made you feel much better than Gator ever could. And even then, he felt like every time you came home to him, you regretted your act of charity that day in the grocery store.Â
Nothing about the crippling insecurity is new. It was still with him even before he was blind, but manifesting in different ways.Â
The only thing thatâs new is the way heâs worn you down with it.
Your love has never been the deciding factor. It has never mattered how you love him, Gator ruins the relationship all on his own, just because thatâs all he knows how to do.Â
why canât you come stitch me up? why canât it ever be enough?
He was angry that he couldnât accept your thoughtful reassurance. Angry that heâd wired himself so poorly growing up that even when presented with the chance of a lifetime, he couldnât fix himself up enough to just be okay.Â
Deep down, Gator knew this would happen, and deep down, he feels like he did it on purpose. He shouldâve known that he couldnât call something as precious as you his own.Â
Your love was a lot of things to Gator, but despite his best efforts to make it so,
itâll never be the cure
There is no cure for him, that is fundamentally who he is.