ffxiv 6.0 notes again 4: the aetherial sea again
half of the scions have gone swimming in the aetherial sea already. gotten maimed too! uh isn't krile the most sesitive to hydaelyn she'd have the best chance at contact. this doesn't fit with krile's established role and trajectory. Like this entire expansion has had a focus on Krile's relationship with Hydaelyn, she's always been in the lead when it comes to Hydaelyn stuff until now.
if we think of this as a flux equation then this star is permanently bleeding out aether that will never be regained.
there is a surprising amount of 2.0 arr in this section. To list all the characters that make an appearance:
Papalymo: wisdom, principle
Livia: undeterred. girl give it up. he did nothing but exploit you.
Moenbryda: affection, valor
Haurchefant: delight, kind-heartedness
Rhitahtyn: unshakable. there was nothing to his character in arr he was just a random flunky. it was sb that made him important, wish he had had that in arr.
I'm surprised hermes/amon is the only ancient we met in the aetherial sea. I was actually expecting Hades to show up in the aetherial sea. I'm going to assume the devs are saving that for the end.
that's like literally the quote from p3, you strawman nihilist. the arcana is the means by which all is revealed. where's that quote.. "the Arcana is the means by which all is revealed... Beyond the beaten path lies the absolute end. It matters not who you are... Death awaits you"
SAYS THE GUY LITERALLY MAKING THINGS MISERABLE FOR EVERYONE. I'm going to kick him fr. how many times do you we got to kill you to teach you this lesson. I'm actually mad having to sit here and listen to this sad sack wax on and on about everything is doomed so he's going to make things worse for everyone. thing is fandaniel is fundamentally a sensitive soul, he would do so good reincarnated as a dog in a loving family. he would love it if his purpose in life was to love and be loved. Being pet a few times would fix him. like one of those small dogs that shake uncontrollably. or a hamster
where have i heard the voice before. it's not asahi is it? gay rat man. oh wow i was right. i was joking when i said asahi would be malding from beyond the grave for fandaniel stealing his zenos alone time
Hydaelyn: To live is to suffer.
hold up this is literally the premise of buddhism. cant believe i'm actually looking up the japanese translation for duhkha. "suffer" in the jp text here is zetsubou (despair). duhkha in Japanese is 苦 Rōmaji: ku from chinese written and pronounced the same, lit. bitterness.
hmm is venat a bodhisatva figure? well not quite, she only resembles on in the sense that she chose to remain in the circles of the world in order to shepherd the rest of humanity.
don't get me started on the buddhist subtext it's what's been spinning in my mental microwave all week. buddhism is inherently existential so pretty much any work that touches on existentialism coincidentally or not touches on buddhism. given that ffxiv has a japanese dev team and buddhism is highly influential on japanese culture it could be partly from that. it probably isn't that they were intentionally writing a buddhist story so much as "that buddhist values of karma and rebirth are culturally important" (saba sabaton).
the upcoming hydaeyln fight feels counterproductive plot wise. Testing us to see if we're worthy of fighting meteion seems like a waste of time and energy. kind of a let down really. we're just wasting her strength the entire game for several expansions now has established that hydaelyn is weakening.
I liked it better when shb was implying that hydaelyn and zodiark were equally "bad" and this was all basically a gang turf war were caught in the middle of, that time the devs teased the idea of hydaelyn tempering before backing down on it.
so our answer to despair is grit your teeth and go on on strength of will? I'm not satisfied with that answer. ok graha has a way better answer (writer's little favorite boy).
G'raha Tia: Never─in the past, present, or future─have I found only happiness. To live is to be ever beset by hardships great and small. G'raha Tia: Yet it is in adversity we find the strength to strive for the next moment of peace, and the next, no matter what trials we face. G'raha Tia: By this strength have the will of gods been defied and the fortunes of men been forever changed. May it be so again this day.
hmm so power of will yes but hope one step at a time
if only we didn't need to prove anything...
well i aoed alisaie but then got aoed by someone else. let's see how many pity points it takes for me to beat this.
it was 3 tries. that took half an hour...
So sundering was for 2 reasons: making zodiark easier to seal, and making people more able to use dynamis. lit "god works in mysterious ways", "he sets us tests of faith", getting big christian level delulu vibes. “To ignore the plight of those one might conceivably save is not wisdom─it is indolence.” all so that suffering she could gatcha gamba reroll stats until that one person who could wield enough dynamis to defeat meteion. this was a terrible plan.
the arr devs totally intended for the giant crystal to be hydaelyn. but ha. ha. she was just hiding on the other side. well at least it's not as bad as the earlier "oh you just misunderstood what she said". these sorts of blatant changes really annoy me it's one of my most hated story aspects of ffxiv.
uh is the star going to be ok is we take the mothercrystal to power the space ship. didnt they almost kill the planet in ff7 by doing this. Just from genre conventions, taking the mothercrystal feels like it's going to kill the planet. Weird take xiv but ok
Hydaelyn: Though I knew failure after failure, by recalling thy tales─and my promise to thee─I found the strength to carry on.
kubera did this plot point first, where the mc timetravels into the past and the hope of seeing the mc again is some ancient being's reason for living. yeah, really, instead of using up the rest of her lifeforce to fight us, she should have done something productive with it.
I was really expecting the writers to do more with Venat being a former Azem. With what is currently established, it would make more sense for her to have been Elidibus. The white robe mechanic would have been much cleaner too just for Elidibus instead of Elidibus and those who refused the call. And Themis being new and losing himself would have made more sense.
G'raha Tia: If dynamis is ruled by emotion, perhaps prayer has more tangible results than I suspected─albeit ones that are not always obvious to us.
Primal summoning was one of the main themes of ARR. The story of FFXIV all the way through SB was all about how anything can be a primal with some prayer and aether. It's weird then that Etheirys is supposedly the aether planet not a dynamis planet. With how easy primals are to create you'd expect there to be lot of dynamis and little aether according to the mechanics established in EW. Of course this is another product of changing writers and visions, the writers of the earlier expansions had different ideas about the mechanics of the setting or maybe didn't think it through at all. Have I mentioned dynamis' mechanics remind me a lot of the Fade from Dragon Age where everything is memory and emotion, objective reality does not exist only what people believe to be true.
Sharlayan is abandoning evacuation?? Why?? even if we take the ship, they still have the Garlemald teleporter/elevator thing. They don't need to completely abandon their plans. Having a backup is always a good idea. Hydaelyn is shit at planning, changing her mind after hundreds of years of prep. Either you split the resources and preparations or you go all in and stay the course. If she had planned on fighting Meteion from the beginning the PC would be way better equipped and she might not be dead. Going all in on one plan and then last minute pivoting to go all in on a different plan is so stupid.
Now that I've had time to think, even if a subset of the population boards the moon arc, after the star is destroyed why wouldn't meteion attack the ship? Beyond Etheirys is less aether and less protection from the dymanis vibes attacks.
I need to summarize all the hydaelyn stuff and like sift through it analyzing the effects of adding stuff in ew to existing material. Hydaelyn has always known Meteion's location and spent the last 12000 years sitting on her thumbs and getting weaker. The point that bothers me is that Endwalker highlights the tragedy of Sundering and all the pain and death it has caused but offers no real reason why Hydaelyn let the state of things continue. “To ignore the plight of those one might conceivably save is not wisdom─it is indolence.” Krile says Hydaelyn "has been waiting... .... For mankind's answer to Hermes's question" which is ridiculous on several levels. How are people so suppose to answer a question they don't know is being asked. That answer also just doesn't seem worth it. Who cares about some abstract ideological battle when you're playing with the lives of actual people you could help. Maybe this is just Krile rationalizing for Hydaelyn since she is a believer, it really reminds me of delusional Christians when they say stuff like "god works in mysterious ways" or "god is testing us" when something horrible happens as justification for why their god would let such awful things happen if he's so good and powerful, to shut down debate and critical thinking of doctrine. big vibes of "i could fix everything but want you to do the work". It's just unnecessary suffering. And speaking of unnecessary, is the fight against Hydaelyn. That was such a waste of everyone's time and energy. Was the Zodiark fight not a good enough test of strength, I'm not a powerleveler but she can't have been much stronger given how she died because of the fight. If she didn't fight us she could have lived a little longer to help even if just to advise. And if she was going to die anyways she could have done something actually useful with her reserves, like idk cool energy sword.