Yn's bikini top falls off in the hot tub; JJ's ogling of her doesn't help matters.
The hot tub at the Chateau had seen better days. Better decades, actually. It was the kind of relic you'd find in a junkyard and think, wow, that's a health hazard, before walking away. But JJ Maybank had dragged it onto the back deck, patched a leak with flex seal and a prayer, and declared it "the pinnacle of Pogue luxury." The water was perpetually a few degrees too hot, the jets sounded like a dying walrus, and the filter hadn't been cleaned since the Obama administration.
But it was theirs, and on a humid North Carolina night with the fireflies blinking lazily over the marsh, it was perfect.
Yn-- was elbow-deep in the water, her hair piled into a messy bun that was already starting to unravel from the steam. She had her eyes closed, letting the too-hot water scald the tension out of her shoulders. Finals were over. The Kooks had been surprisingly quiet for a whole forty-eight hours. For once, nothing was actively on fire.
JJ was across from her, lounging with his arms draped over the cracked plastic edge, looking like a wet raccoon that had just won the lottery. His blonde hair was plastered to his forehead, and he had that particular grin on his face—the one that meant he was either about to say something incredibly stupid or incredibly charming. Usually, it was both.
"This is nice," Yn-- murmured, not opening her eyes. "Peaceful. Relaxing. You're being quiet."
"Don't jinx it," JJ said, his voice a low, satisfied rumble. "I'm savoring the moment. The silence. The ambiance. The view."
Yn-- cracked one eye open. "The view of the marsh?"
"Sure," JJ said, his grin widening. "The marsh. That's definitely what I was looking at. Very scenic. Lot of... mud. And grass. Beautiful."
Yn-- snorted and closed her eye again. "You're a menace."
"Menace is a strong word," JJ said, shifting in the water. "I prefer 'visionary.' Or 'chaos architect.' Or 'the best thing that ever happened to that bikini you're wearing.'"
Yn-- felt her cheeks warm, and it wasn't from the steam. She was wearing a tiny red bikini—the one she'd had since eighth grade, which was a testament to either her dedication to thrift or her refusal to admit she'd grown since then. The top was a triangle situation held together by a single, questionable string around her neck and another flimsy string between her shoulder blades. It had been a gamble when she'd put it on.
Because as she shifted to swat at a mosquito buzzing near her ear, she felt the unmistakable twang of the neck string snapping.
And then, in slow motion, the top drifted away from her body like a scarlet leaf in autumn, disappearing into the bubbling, murky depths of the hot tub.
For a solid three seconds, there was silence.
Yn-- froze, her arms still half-raised, her brain buffering. The hot water lapped at her collarbones, and she was acutely, painfully aware that she was now chest-naked in a hot tub with the single most unhinged person on the Outer Banks.
She looked down. The water was too cloudy with chlorine and who-knows-what to see anything.
His mouth was slightly open. His eyes—those stupid, impossibly blue eyes—were wide and fixed. His brain, she could tell, had short-circuited. The grin had vanished, replaced by the slack-jawed expression of a man who had just witnessed a miracle and wasn't sure if he should pray or take a picture.
"JJ," she said, her voice dangerously calm.
He didn't respond. He blinked once. Slowly.
"JJ," she repeated, a little sharper. "My top fell off."
He nodded. Still staring. Still not blinking.
"Can you... help me find it?"
Another nod. Another blink. "Mhm."
But he didn't move. He didn't even look for it. His eyes, the traitors, stayed locked on the general vicinity of her chest, which was now partially obscured by a few bubbles and the faint, shifting shadows of the water.
"JJ," she hissed, snapping her fingers in front of his face. "Eyes up here. Up here."
He blinked several times, and for a second, his gaze flicked to her face. Then it dropped back down. "Nope. Can't do it. Sorry. The pull is too strong. I'm like a moth to a flame. A very pale, very wet, very... topless flame."
"Oh my god." Yn-- made a grab for the water, sweeping her arms in a wide arc, trying to feel for the fabric. The jets chose that moment to kick on at full blast, churning the water into a frothy, opaque mess. The sound of the dying-walrus motor filled the night, and whatever hope she'd had of locating the bikini top by feel vanished.
"Little help here?" she said through gritted teeth.
JJ leaned forward, resting his elbows on his knees, his chin propped in his hands like he was watching a nature documentary. "You know, I'm getting a really good look at the marsh from this angle."
"You don't hate me," he said, utterly unbothered. "You're just saying that because you're naked and I'm being an unhelpful gremlin. Which, fair. But also—" he gestured vaguely with one hand, "—this is a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity. I'm not gonna rush it."
Yn-- felt a hot flush of embarrassment, but underneath it, there was something else. Something that smelled a lot like amusement. This was so classic JJ. Any other guy would have fumbled, apologized, gone into a panicked search mode. Not him. He was treating this like the highlight of his year.
"Once in a lifetime?" she repeated, arching an eyebrow as she sank lower into the water, letting it rise to her chin. "You say that like you're expecting me to spontaneously combust after tonight."
"No, no," JJ said, waving a hand. "I'm saying you're gonna get wiser. Smarter. You're gonna start wearing bikinis with industrial-strength clasps. This is the last time I'll ever see you in a flimsy, poorly-constructed, incredibly—" he paused, tilting his head, "—generous piece of fabric. I'm savoring the moment."
"Very generous. Top-tier. A+ material. The strings were doing the lord's work, and they finally gave out. RIP to those heroes. They died for a noble cause."
Yn-- splashed a wave of water at his face. He didn't even flinch. He just sputtered a little, wiped his eyes, and grinned at her with that crooked, infuriating smile.
"You're not even a little embarrassed, are you?" she demanded.
"Embarrassed?" JJ's brows shot up. "Babe, I'm thriving. This is the best thing that's happened to me since I found a hundred-dollar bill in a dead fish's mouth."
"That's luck, Yn--. Don't knock the fish."
She shook her head, but a laugh bubbled up in her chest despite herself. The situation was so absurd, so unbelievably JJ, that she couldn't even stay properly mad. Here she was, topless in a disgusting hot tub, while her pseudo-best-friend-slash-crush sat three feet away, watching her with the unhinged delight of a raccoon who'd just discovered a trash can full of leftover pizza.
"You realize I can't get out of the hot tub now, right?" she said, gesturing with a frustrated hand. "I'm stuck here until you find my top. Or until I drown. Whichever comes first."
JJ considered this, tapping his chin. "Hm. So you're saying... you're trapped. In a hot tub. With me."
"I'm saying I'm trapped in a dirty hot tub with a menace to society, yes."
"That's the best news I've heard all week." He settled back against the edge of the tub, stretching his arms along the rim, looking like a king surveying his domain. "Alright. We've got options."
"Option one: I look for the top. I find it. I hand it to you. You put it on. The magic ends. We go back to being normal friends who wear clothes in hot tubs."
"Option two," JJ continued, ignoring her, "I don't look for the top. We stay here. Maybe I order a pizza. We make a night of it. You get out of the tub in a towel. I die happy."
Yn-- pinched the bridge of her nose. "Those are not options. That's one option and a hostage situation."
"Hostage situation is a strong word. I prefer 'staying put for the aesthetic.'"
He sighed—a long, dramatic sigh that seemed to come from the depths of his soul. "Fine. Fiiiiine. But you're gonna owe me for this."
"Owe you? It's your hot tub that ate my bikini!"
"My hot tub is innocent," JJ said, holding up a hand solemnly. "It's a neutral party. It was just doing its job—providing a warm, relaxing environment. It didn't ask for your strings to betray you."
"My strings didn't betray me! They were old! This bikini is ancient!"
"Now you're blaming the victim," JJ said with a disappointed click of his tongue. "Classic. Very classy, Yn--."
She splashed him again. He laughed, throwing his head back, and for a split second, the tension broke. It wasn't even about the top anymore. It was just them—two idiots in a broken hot tub on a summer night, one of them completely unbothered by his friend's nudity, the other desperately trying not to laugh.
But then he made a move, and she forgot to breathe.
He pushed off from his side of the tub and started wading toward her, his movements slow and deliberate, a predator in board shorts. The water sloshed around his chest as he got closer, and Yn-- instinctively pressed her back against the tub wall, her arms crossing protectively over her chest.
"Easy," he said, his voice dropping to something softer, more amused. "I'm just looking. Remember?"
He stopped directly in front of her, close enough that she could see the water droplets clinging to his eyelashes. His blue eyes were bright, lit up with a mischief that was pure, undiluted chaos.
"Relax, Yn--. I'm a gentleman."
"You once stole a golf cart and drove it into a Kook's pool."
"That was a social experiment," he said, waving a dismissive hand. "And for the record, the golf cart was fine. Mostly. The pool wasn't, but that's not the point."
"The point is you're not a gentleman."
"The point," JJ said, leaning in just a fraction, "is that I'm not gonna look if you don't want me to. I'm a lot of things—a menace, a nuisance, a low-level felon—but I'm not a creep."
Yn-- stared at him. For once, he was serious. The grin was still there, but it had softened into something real, something that made her stomach flip.
"Then what are you doing?" she asked, her voice coming out smaller than she'd intended.
He tilted his head, considering her. "I'm enjoying myself. You know how rare it is for something good to just... happen? No plan, no scheming, no universe conspiring against me?" He glanced down at the water, then back up at her. "This is a gift, Yn--. A weird, slightly awkward, very poorly timed gift. I'm not gonna waste it by acting like it's a big deal."
"It is a big deal. I'm—" she gestured vaguely at herself, "—I'm naked. In a hot tub. With you."
"And?" JJ shrugged. "It's just a body. Everybody's got one. Some of them are cooler than others. Some of them have—" he made a vague gesture near his own chest, "—you know. Features. But at the end of the day, it's just skin. I'm not gonna freak out about it."
"You're not gonna freak out about it," she repeated flatly. "You literally just said you were 'thriving' and called it a 'once-in-a-lifetime opportunity.'"
"I said opportunity, not disaster. There's a difference. Opportunity means I'm enjoying the surprise. Disaster means you're crying and I'm apologizing. Different vibes."
Yn-- wanted to be annoyed. She really did. But the way he was looking at her—not like a piece of meat, but like a puzzle he was having a lot of fun solving—made her chest feel tight in a way that had nothing to do with the water temperature.
"You're impossible," she muttered.
"Impossible to ignore, you mean." He grinned, the mischief flooding back. "Now. About that top."
"I could try to find it. But I gotta warn you—my hands are gonna be all over the bottom of this tub. I'm gonna be poking around. Feeling things. It's gonna be a whole thing."
"Feeling—" She sputtered. "You mean feeling for the top, right?"
"Sure," JJ said innocently. "What else would I be feeling?"
"You keep saying that, and yet you haven't gotten out of the tub."
"Fair point." He waggled his eyebrows. "Alright. I'll do the noble thing. I'll search. But I want compensation."
"Yeah. I find the top, you buy me a pizza. And not that cheap stuff from the gas station. I'm talking full-on, hand-tossed, extra cheese, pepperoni situation. The works."
Yn-- stared at him. "You're blackmailing me for pizza."
"I'm negotiating for pizza. There's a difference."
"And yet, you keep hanging around. Must be my charming personality." He gave a little bow, then dropped his gaze to the water, squinting into the murky depths. "Alright. Here goes nothing."
He reached down, his hand disappearing into the water, and Yn-- felt her breath catch. He was inches away from her, his shoulder brushing her knee as he leaned forward. The jets were still churning, making it impossible to see what he was doing.
"Oh, I feel something," he said, his voice muffled by the water. "And it's... warm. And... stringy."
"Wait, no. That's a leaf." He surfaced, holding up a soggy brown leaf between two fingers. "Gross. This tub is a biohazard."
"I'm focusing! I'm searching! You don't rush a treasure hunt, Yn--. That's how you miss the good stuff." He ducked under again, his hand sweeping across the bottom. She felt his fingers brush her ankle, and she yelped.
"Did you just touch my foot?"
"Accident," came his muffled voice from under the water. "Maybe. Could've been on purpose. I'll never tell."
She kicked out, splashing him, and he surfaced with a sputter, water streaming down his face. His hair was a wreck, plastered to his forehead in chaotic waves, and his grin was so wide it was almost cartoonish.
"You're a menace," she said.
"You're the reason I can't have nice things."
"The only nice thing you had was that bikini, and it gave up on you, Yn--. That's not my fault. That's bad craftsmanship. You need to shop at better stores."
"I got it at a thrift shop."
"Ah." JJ nodded sagely. "The thrift shop. Where dreams go to die and bikinis go to betray their owners. Makes sense."
Yn-- laughed despite herself. She couldn't help it. There was something infectious about his energy, something that made even the most mortifying situations feel like an adventure. Here she was, topless in a broken hot tub, and she was laughing.
"Alright," JJ said, rubbing his hands together. "One more try. If I don't find it this time, we're gonna have to come up with a new plan."
"I'm thinking towels. Maybe a dramatic exit. I'll carry you out of the tub like a damsel in distress. You'll be wrapped in a towel, I'll be the hero, and we'll never speak of this again."
"You'd enjoy that way too much."
"Probably." He grinned. "But you'd enjoy it too. You love being carried. You've got that princess energy."
"I do not have princess energy."
"Babe, you literally demanded I find your bikini top like I'm your royal subject. That's princess energy."
"That's common decency energy!"
JJ just laughed and dove under again, his hands sweeping across the bottom. This time, she felt his fingers graze her thigh, and she jerked back with a shriek.
"I'm looking!" His voice was a little too gleeful.
"You're just feeling me up!"
"I'm feeling for the top," he said, surfacing with a scandalized expression. "How dare you accuse me of such impropriety. I'm a gentleman. I told you."
"You are not a gentleman."
"I'm a gentleman adjacent. I'm in the neighborhood of gentleman. I can see gentleman from my house."
Yn-- grabbed a handful of water and threw it at his face. He took it like a champ, shaking his head like a dog and blinking water out of his eyes.
"Okay," he said, wiping his face. "I'm starting to think this top is a lost cause. It might've gotten sucked into the jet. Or it's dissolved. Or it's in another dimension."
"I'm serious! That thing is gone, Yn--. It's gone, and you're gonna have to accept that. We're gonna have to adapt. Evolve. Move on."
"Move on," she repeated flatly. "You want me to move on from my bikini top. The thing that is currently covering absolutely nothing."
"Look at the bright side," JJ said, gesturing with both hands. "You've got a great story. 'That time my bikini betrayed me in JJ's hot tub and he was absolutely no help.' It's a classic. You could tell it at parties."
"I'm not telling anyone this story."
"You will. Trust me. It'll be your go-to icebreaker. 'Hi, I'm Yn--, and I once flashed a guy in a hot tub.' People will love it."
"Your hatred is noted and will be ignored." He settled back against the edge of the tub, crossing his arms behind his head like he was on a tropical vacation. "Okay. New plan. We wait."
"For the top to resurface. It's buoyant, right? It's got to float eventually."
Yn-- looked at him with an expression of pure disbelief. "You want me to sit here, in this hot tub, naked, waiting for a tiny piece of red fabric to float up out of the depths."
"Exactly," JJ said, nodding encouragingly. "Patience, Yn--. It's a virtue."
"It's not a virtue, it's a trap."
"A trap that involves you staying in a hot tub with me. How is that a trap? That's a gift."
She wanted to argue. She really did. But the absurdity of the situation had fully settled in, and she was tired of being embarrassed. It was JJ. He'd seen her at her worst—covered in marsh mud, screaming at a Kook from a moving boat, sobbing over a failed test. This was just another notch on the weirdness belt.
So she leaned back against the tub, letting the water lap at her shoulders, and tried to relax.
"You're not going to help me at all, are you?" she asked, her voice resigned.
JJ tilted his head, pretending to think. "Define 'help.'"
"Help like 'looking for the top.'"
"Help like 'offering me a towel.'"
"Help like 'not staring at my chest.'"
JJ considered this. "I don't think that's in my skill set. I'm gonna be honest with you, Yn--. I'm a visual learner. I need to see things to understand them. It's a medical condition."
"Impossibly infuriating."
"Same thing, really." He grinned at her, that stupid, crooked grin that made her stomach do flips. "You know, for someone who's currently topless in a hot tub, you're handling this remarkably well. Most people would be screaming or crying or making a scene."
"Most people have dignity."
"And you?" JJ asked, raising an eyebrow.
"I've been hanging around you too long. My dignity got lost somewhere in a marsh two years ago."
"I'm honored," he said, pressing a hand to his chest. "I've been a bad influence. That's goals, honestly. That's the legacy I want to leave behind."
"Your legacy is going to be 'he annoyed everyone to death.'"
"Better than being boring," JJ said with a shrug. "I'll take it."
They fell into a comfortable silence, the only sounds the churning jets and the distant chirp of crickets. Yn-- had stopped trying to cover herself—it was pointless in the murky water anyway—and JJ had stopped actively staring, which was progress. The tension had shifted from mortifying to something almost... natural.
And then, because the universe had a sense of humor, the top floated up between them.
It rose out of the churning water like some kind of mythical creature, a soggy scrap of red fabric that had clearly been through a war. It bobbed gently on the surface, strings trailing behind it like a sad little jellyfish.
Then, in perfect synchronization, they both looked at each other.
"Would you look at that," JJ said, his voice dripping with false surprise. "It resurfaced. Must be my lucky day."
"JJ," Yn-- said, her voice flat. "Give. Me. The top."
He reached out and grabbed it, holding it up by one string like it was a captured flag. The soggy fabric dripped water onto his face, and he didn't even seem to notice.
"You know," he said, turning it over in his hands, "I've got to say, this is a lot less impressive wet. It was doing some heavy lifting earlier, but now? It's just... sad."
"I'm just saying! It's like seeing a magician's trick revealed. The illusion is shattered. The mystery is gone. This flimsy piece of fabric was holding all the power, and now it's just... wet."
He looked at her, his eyes dancing. "Okay, fine. But I want something first."
"A thank you? For what? You didn't do anything!"
"I provided moral support," JJ said, holding the top just out of her reach. "I was your emotional anchor in a time of crisis. I kept you calm. I made you laugh. I deserve a thank you."
Yn-- stared at him. "You just want to watch me squirm."
"I want a little gratitude," he corrected. "There's a difference. Squirming is a bonus."
She took a deep breath, counted to three in her head, and then said, through gritted teeth, "Thank you. For absolutely nothing."
JJ beamed. "You're welcome! I accept this praise in the spirit in which it was given."
He held it out to her, and she snatched it from his grasp. The fabric was cold and wet and completely useless, but she clutched it to her chest like a lifeline.
"Turn around," she ordered.
JJ raised an eyebrow. "Babe, I've been looking at you for the last twenty minutes. What's one more second?"
"Turn around or I will drown you."
"Fine, fine." He put his hands up in surrender and turned his back to her, but she could hear the laughter in his voice. "Don't take too long. The view back here is terrible."
She fumbled with the strings, trying to tie them behind her neck. The knot was slippery, the strings were too short, and her fingers were trembling with a mix of exasperation and something she didn't want to name.
"Need help?" JJ asked, not turning around.
"Suit yourself. But the offer stands. I'm very good with knots. I can tie a mean bowline. A hitch. A—"
"Just saying. I've got skills."
She finally managed to tie the top—badly, but it would hold—and took a deep breath. "Okay. You can turn around."
He turned, and his face fell into an exaggerated pout. "Aww. It's back. Boo."
"Never." He waded closer to her, and she instinctively backed up against the tub wall. He was in her space now, close enough that she could smell the salt and chlorine on his skin, close enough that she could see the little flecks of green in his blue eyes.
"Thanks for not making it weird," he said, his voice softer.
"You made it incredibly weird."
"Yeah, but not bad weird," he said. "Fun weird. Weird weird. The best kind of weird."
She shook her head, but she was smiling. "You're lucky I like you."
He grinned. "I know. I'm the luckiest guy in the Cut."
Then, before she could say anything else, he reached down and scooped her up out of the water. She yelped, grabbing onto his shoulders for balance as water streamed off both of them.
"Princess energy, remember?" He was grinning that stupid grin, water dripping from his hair onto her face. "I told you I was gonna carry you out. I'm a man of my word."
"Nope. This is happening." He started walking toward the edge of the tub, his grip firm around her legs. "You're gonna be wrapped in a towel, I'm gonna be a hero, and we're never gonna speak of this again."
"You just said you were never gonna let me forget this!"
"New plan," JJ said cheerfully. "I'm gonna remind you every single day. For the rest of your life."
And as he carried her out of the hot tub, dripping and laughing and absolutely ridiculous, Yn-- realized she wouldn't have it any other way.