WOULD ERIC CARTMAN SHIP SHADOWZEL: A SPECULATIVE ANALYSIS
Hello, Tumblr. I cooked up some bullshit for you. In this post I would like to finally answer the question we’ve all been dying to know: would Eric Cartman ship Shadowzel?
If you are unaware, Shadowzel is the ship between Shadowheart and Lae Zel from Baldur’s Gate 3. I’m not really into BG3 ships, but from my layman’s knowledge it’s a little toxic and often written as enemies or rivals to lovers, due to the fight between Shadowheart and Lae Zel at camp.
Now what does Eric Cartman have to do with this? I’m glad you asked.
Eric(a) Cartman plays BG3! This is a plot point in the Panderverse special. Panderverse Cartman has the exact same personality as regular Cartman, except she lives in a universe where everyone is a diverse woman, according to her counterpart’s recollection of his visions of this universe. Both of these characters are the same person, and regular Cartman has a love of D&D, LARP, and other fantasy rpgs like Warcraft (S6E13, SOT, S10E8, S23E7). It can be assumed that regular Cartman would also play BG3, there’s really no reason that this would be a trait exclusive to Erica, because they are the same person.
Seeing that Eric Cartman also played one of my favorite games was a terrifying experience actually. He could be in my fandom spaces and I wouldn’t even know. I’ve thought a lot about what kind of player he’d be, and what kind of DM (in terms of standard D&D, he’s a DM in S23E7). The obvious choice is that he’d only play Durge murderhobo runs and kill any of the companions he didn’t like, but he has said himself (in S23E7) that he heavily prefers story-centric campaigns, so I doubt he’d be doing anything to ruin the story for himself like that. No. He’s got to be invested, especially so if Erica was upset about her save file not transferring between universes. This is where I started considering the horrifying possibility of Eric Cartman engaging in traditional fandom activities…
But isn’t Cartman homophobic? This would surely disqualify him from shipping Shadowzel, as it is a WLW ship. The answer to this question is surprisingly no. Cartman rarely talks about queer people in general, as most of the queerphobia in the show is reserved to Mr. Garrison’s character (heavily closeted homosexual). The main episode people bring up in favor of Cartman is homophobic theory is S1E4, where Cartman makes fun of Stan for his dog Sparky being gay. In this same episode he says “No way, dude. My mom says God hates gat people.” Cartman is an 8 year old in this episode (he turns 9 only six episodes later actually) and just parroting what his mom tells him. As early as S5E2, Cartman has grown past this. He participates in the protest against discrimination towards his Mountain Scouts leader, Big Gay Al, on the basis of his sexuality with his friends. People also bring up the fact that he uses the F slur sporadically through seasons 1-13. In S13E12 every single character in the show says it 100 fucking times and it was established in-universe that none of the kids, including Cartman, use it towards queer people, instead as an insult to people who are annoying and disruptive. After the mixed reception to that episode, the word has mostly disappeared from the show as a whole. You can ignore this entire paragraph because Cartman himself has directly stated his opinions on this in S19E6.
There’s no catch or added context to this one, you can watch the episode yourself.
Since we have established that Cartman is not homophobic, what is there to suggest that he might be interested in shipping? There are actually two episodes about this. The entire plot of S16E7 is Cartman shipping Tolkien with the new girl, Nicole, and meddling with things to get them together. He even cries over their temporary breakup with Butters. Cartman is … very, very invested in his ships. Nicolkien is not even the first ship he’s made canon, apparently he shipped two background characters named Luke and Maria. The second Cartman shipping episode is S19E6. This is the legendary yaoi episode, where Cartman takes the role of the stereotypical deranged fujoshi (though he’s a fudanshi instead obv). No, I’m not kidding. Watch it for yourself. He becomes extremely invested in the ship between Tweek and Craig. Cartman made Creek canon.
He keeps the ships he’s forced together in a scrapbook. You can see it better in S16E7 if you watch it yourself. I chose this picture because he’s being cute and I MUST push the adorable Cartman agenda.
Cartman plays BG3, is not homophobic, and is heavily invested in both queer and straight ships, so the idea that he would ship Shadowzel is clearly possible. But why Shadowzel specifically? Cartman’s shipping practices in his ‘real life’ are pure fluff. He becomes upset over any conflict. But in fiction, Cartman’s ships are as toxic as can be. In S13E10, Cartman invents a female persona called Bad Irene and roleplays a love triangle with Kyle and Stan’s personas. It’s extremely overdramatic and messy as hell. She rejects both her lovers by saying her one true love is abortion. I’m not kidding. I can not describe Bad Irene to you please just watch the episode. Cartman has also shipped himself with his own enemy/rival before, in S16E7 (again) Cartman spreads the lie that he and Kyle are a couple so Kyle won’t be able to interfere with Nicole/Tolkien, as Kyle has a crush on Nicole. Cartman performs a love song directed to Kyle in front of an entire stadium of people.
Including this screenshot because I think it’s REALLY funny. While Cartman doesn’t really want to date Kyle in the show (yes I know Kyman has basis but it isn’t canon don’t kill me ok), he seems to be having a lot of fun / putting in a lot of effort into roleplaying it. Much like the relationships he portrays when he’s playing pretend, Shadowzel is a bit toxic, messy, and it is usually written as rivals or enemies to lovers as I mentioned earlier. Of all of the BG3 ships, I think this one would be the one Cartman is most interested in. If you can think of a better one, please tell me. I don’t know much about BG3 shipping because my favorite is the Emperor and he has zero popular pairings lmao.
It is thus my humble conclusion that Eric Cartman WOULD in fact ship Shadowzel. He might even doxx you if you disagree with it publicly. Thats all, goodbye Tumblr.
(Sorry for the imgbb links btw, this was originally on my web blog.)
Dear fucking lord. Why are you like this.





















