Flipping the Vinyl PT 1 (Eddie x Henderson!Reader)
Warnings: mentions of weed, other drugs, angst, mentions of eating disorders, death
"Hold your god damn horses Dustin, I am coming!" You yelled, walking out of your room. "What the hell is taking so long?" Mike asked. "Looking for the-" you picked up the pom pom. "Found it!" You said, relieved as you walked out of the house. Mike and Dustin rolled their eyes. "I need them for the pep rally-why am I even explaining this to you, get in the car." You huffed.
It wasn't a well known fact that you were Dustin's older sister. It seemed most people just thought you were neighbors or something. Dustin and you were opposites on the surface. He was a nerd who hung out with other nerds. You were a cheerleader who hung out with other cheerleaders and the basketball team.
You however, had a very similar personality to Dustin. You had a tendency to hide this fact though. You were a nerd, a giant one at that who actually enjoyed playing D&D and loved Dustin's friends. However, it seemed Chrissy, your bestfriend had other plans. She hated the idea of you getting bullied and pulled you into the cheerleader scene. You didn't mind it. As long as Jason left you alone. You absolutely hated that guy.
Why Chrissy was dating him was a god damn mystery to you. He was a jerk, always mouthing off at the wrong time. He was also annoyingly hypocritical, always talking about how Dustin's friend group was a bunch of devil worshipers who lived in sin, meanwhile you had caught Jason doing literal cocain in a rest stop bathroom during an away game. The boy was an ass and you prayed for that day for him to have a fall from grace and become some sort of social outcast so that you wouldn't have to see him again.
You walked over to Chrissy's locker, her seeming slightly off. She was just standing there, staring into it. "Chris, you good?" You asked, her jumping. "Oh... Hi, Y/n" she greeted. "What's up?" You asked. "...Later... I uh... I don't want anyone else to hear." She said. You nodded, the bell ringing. "Come on, first period." You ushered.
You walked into the science classroom, sitting at the table. "So what's going on?" You asked quietly as students shuffled in. "...Do..." she shifted uncomfortably on her stool. "Do you ever feel like you're losing your mind?" She asked. You blinked. "...Uh.." you wanted to give off a quippy response but that didn't seem wise. "Sometimes, yeah." You nodded. "...I just... I keep... seeing things." She admitted. You rose a brow. "Like what?" You asked.
"Like... A clock... and... mom.... and... I hear this voice"
"christ, there's voices now?" You thought to yourself.
"It calls my name and... I don't know I feel... I feel like I'm going insane." She admitted.
"Have you told anyone else?" You asked, the teacher writing things on the board. "Just the councilor..." she muttered.
You looked at her slightly concerned. "I just... I don't want to feel... anxious... anymore." She mumbled. "I uh... I know you don't really do it but... have you considered... weed?" You asked. Chrissy looked over at you slightly surprised.
"I'm not joking-" "No no- I never said you were." You halted. She rose a brow. "You... you really think..." she leaned over closer "weed is the answer?" She asked. "I mean... It'll take the edge off. Might help with everything." You said. "... and you know this how?" She asked. "We hang out with athletes, you really think they don't know how to get drugs?" You asked sarcastically. "... Can you find someone to... get..." "Yeah, I know a guy. Do you want me to go?" You asked. "Yeah." She nodded. "Okay."
The day dragged on, eventually the pep rally arriving. Dustin sat on the bleachers next to Eddie as you walked over. "Hey, do you have my scrunchie, the other broke?" You asked. Dustin rifled through his bag, Eddie raising a brow. "Is this Suzie?" Eddie asked. Dustin and you both gagged. "Dude no- fuck no!" You said. "That's my sister!" Dustin said. "Ah! You have a sister?" He asked. "Yes I have sister-" "I'm Eddie" Eddie introduced.
"Y/n- hey you're friends with Rick right?" You asked. "...Yes I am, why?" Eddie asked. "I can't seem to get ahold of him-" "He got busted." Eddie said. "Fuck" you sighed. "But I took over. Meet me after the pep rally. Picnic table in the woods behind the school. " Eddie said. "Cool, thank you." You said before pulling your hair back and rushing back down to the other cheerleaders.
Eddie took a moment to really register the information he just found out. Not only did Henderson have an older sister who smoked, he had an older sister who was a fucking cheerleader. Eddie stared as you laughed at something someone whispered to you.
Finally one of the teachers motioned for you all to go and you stood next to Chrissy as you chanted a few cheers. Eddie was impressed by your flexibility as he watched you do a round off, landing with a smile on your face. The basketball team soon ran out, the cheerleaders all sitting on the bleachers.
You could feel someone staring at you and you slowly turned around to see Eddie. You gave a small wave, him nodding to you. You turned back to Jason who was speaking about something but rolled your eyes, leaning over to Chrissy. "I meet with the guy after this, are you sure you're not coming with?" You asked. "...I'm sure." She nodded. "Okay. I'll give it to you at the game, okay?" You asked. "Okay" she nodded. You were curious to know if Jason knew anything about all of this. After all, this was his girlfriend.
Then again, you always noticed this odd gap of communication between Jason and Chrissy. Chrissy tried to tell him things but he usually brushed it off. His reaction to Chrissy's depression was already less than stellar, she outright refused to tell him about her eating disorder. This further confused you on why she was dating him in the first place.
The pep rally finally came to an end, you slipping off and walking out before anyone could really take notice. You walked out into the woods and found the picnic table but Eddie wasn't present. You hated this feeling. This constant sense of danger that came from multiple years in Hawkins.
Many many people were blissfully unaware of the real dangers that stupid lab left behind. You, unfortunately were not one of them. You knew everything, down to the Russians that were in the mall last year. In fact, you were there when your brother had to sing to his girlfriend to get her to save the world. Sounds stupid in retrospect. It was.
You heard a snap and you jump, turning right smack into Eddie. "Geez, you walk quieter than Mews!" You gasped. He blinked. "...The fuck is a 'Mews'?" Eddie asked, sitting at the picnic table. "My departed cat." You sighed sitting down. "Oh. Sorry for your loss." He apologized. "It's fine, we got a new one named Arwen." You said. He blinked. "Dustin name it?" He asked. "No, I did." You said. He looked at you. "And you named it after-" "Lord of the Rings, yes." You nodded. He looked downright shocked by your honesty. "You.... holy shit- you're a nerd!" He realized.
You gasped dramatically. "Shhh not so loud! The douchebags might hear you!" You teased, him chuckling. "You" he began. "Are certainly not what I expected." He said. "What were you expecting?" You asked. He looked at you with a small smile. "Someone completely bitchy. Y'know?" He asked. You nodded. "Lot of them are. Chrissy isn't, she's the only reason I'm with the uniforms." You admitted. "Cunningham eh? Bestfriend?" He asked. "In the whole world. She's the reason I'm here actually." You admitted.
Eddie rose a brow. "You're getting this, for her?" He asked. "Yeah." You nodded. "...No fucking way. She smokes?" He asked. "Not... exactly." You admitted. "What the hell made her want to try it then?" He asked. "...It's not really my place to say anything." You admitted. He nodded, leaning back back slightly. "Alright. Alright Henderson, you're lucky. Flattery works on me. 15 for this." He said, opening the lunchbox to show the baggy. "Man, I feel like I'm robbing you." You said making him chuckle. "As long as you're aware." He said making you smile.
That smile. It was something that practically shined when it was a natural smile. Your eyes lit up and that small giggle. God that giggle. Eddie's heart pounded in his ears. "So-so. Do you smoke?" He asked. "Yeah, occasionally. More like socially though." You said, pulling out your wallet. "Well you knew Rick so I figured you had to enjoy something in his stock, y'know?" He said. "Yeah, I had to be the one to buy things for Jason. Didn't want to ruin his 'holier than thou' image." You said handing him the cash. "Ah. Makes sense. Well, if you ever feel like smoking... socially... I can uh... give you my number." He said. You rose a brow but nodded.
"Or I could meet you after the game. Chrissy made it clear she wanted to smoke by herself." You said. That was a very true statement. When you tried to insist that you should at least supervise her, she absolutely refused. She went on about how the voices would absolutely get worse if someone was there. This was strictly for sleep and sleep alone. "Alright then. After the game." Eddie nodded.
You picked up your bag and got up. "Well Munson. It was a pleasure." You said with a smile. "Have fun at this... game thing." He said. "Have fun with the campaign." You said walking off. Eddie smiled to himself as he watched you walk away.
You walked back to the parking lot, seeing Jason talking to a basketball player. "Hey, where's Chrissy?" You asked. "In the gym" he yawned. "Is she okay?" You asked. "Yeah-dude tonight is going to be awesome." Jason said making you roll your eyes as you walked back into the gym. She wasn't there, so you went to the locker room. "Chris? You in here?" You asked, the sound of someone moving back echoing. There was still no response.
"God, you scared me!" You gasped as you turned the corner seeing Chrissy at her locker. She didn't respond and you rose a brow. "Chris?" You called. Still nothing. "Chrissy?" You put your hand on her shoulder and she jumped moving away from you. Almost like she was afraid. "Woah! Chrissy, it's me!" You gasped. She panted and sat on the bench. "Chrissy, what happened? Are you okay?" You asked concerned. "I-I could... I heard a clock... and-and mom." She whimpered. You hugged her, Chrissy sobbing into your chest.
Once she had calmed down, you helped clean up her face. "There. Now it just looks like allergies." You said confidently. "Thanks" she sniffled. "I uh.. I got the weed by the way. Are you sure you don't want me there?" You asked. "I'm sure... I'm sure." She nodded. You handed her the baggie and she hesitated before taking it and putting it in her backpack. "Sorry I made you go to that guy" she said. "He's not so bad." You shrugged. "Really?" She asked. "Munson's kind of cute actually." You muttered. She turned with a small smile.
"No way" she said. "What?" You asked. "You have a crush!" She realized. "Wha- I do not! I barely know the guy outside of Dustin talking about him!" You said. "If you don't, why are you defensive?" She asked. Your silence was enough of an answer to make her practically skip out the locker room and you sighed.
A few hours later and there you were cheering with the team and watching the game. You waved to Steve who gave a small wave back. You liked Steve. He was like a brother to you and Dustin both. Course he always treated you like an equal which was nice. You noticed Lucas on the bench and rose a brow. You knew there was a campaign tonight. So why was he here? Especially since he had been riding the bench for nearly the entire damn season.
You finally took a break, sitting next to Chrissy as you tied your shoes. "Having fun yet?" You asked. "I'm not sure we'll win this one." She said. "I dunno, Jason's playing alright out there." You said. She looked at you. "This is me trying to be supportive." You said making her smile slightly.
You rose a brow as you watched Lucas get pulled into the game. "No fucking way" you mumbled, watching him. "What?" Chrissy asked. "Lucas Sinclair is out there." You muttered. Lucas seemed nervous, looking around him before he saw you. He gave a small wave and you waved back, giving him a small thumbs up.
You actually found yourself impressed by Lucas as he moved across the court. Finally the end approached, only seconds left on the clock to score that last point. You watched Jason pass the ball, Lucas throwing it. You stood up, watching in awe as the ball soared through the air and landed into the hoop.
Cheers errupted throughout the gym, Lucas being praised for a job well done. You found yourself clapping for him as Chrissy gave you a small pat to let you know she was leaving. You hugged her, Chrissy slipping out of the chaos.
You waited a few minutes for the park to clear out, finally walking out into the cold air. You walked for a bit before a van pulled alongside you. You gripped your pocket knife before realizing it was Eddie.
"Need a ride Henderson?" He asked. "Yeah." You said, him nodding for you to get in. You sat in the passenger seat, looking over at him. "So, how did the campaign go" you asked. "They kicked ass. Actually, I was impressed by the youngest Sinclair. She knew how to play." He said. You blinked. "Erica played D&D?" You asked. "Yeah." He said. "Impressive" you chuckled. He smiled.
"What about you, how was the game?" He asked. "We won. Lucas actually made the winning shot. So that was cool I guess." You shrugged. "Not one for basketball?" He asked. "Not one for sports in general" you said. Eddie nodded. "Eddie uh... Why am I here?" You asked. "Dunno, you got in the van" he shrugged. "I mean, are we smoking? Are you taking me home? Are you driving me to my death?" You asked. "I'm down to smoke if you are." He said. "Always." You said with a grin. Eddie nodded and drove, turning up the radio.
When you reached his home, you actually recognized it. "Huh." You realized. "What?" He asked. "You live across from Max." You said. "Who?" Eddie asked. "Mayfield. Billy's sister." You said. "Oh. Right. That dick." Eddie grimaced.
You rose a brow. "Not a fan of Billy?" You asked. "Well I'm not one to speak ill of the dead but... that guy was an asshole." Eddie said, unlocking the door. You walked in behind him. "Excuse the mess, the maid took the week off." Eddie joked making you chuckle. "Eh. I've seen worse." You shrugged. Eddie opened a drawer and you looked around. "Do you live alone?" You asked.
"No uh, I live with my uncle. He works at the plant." He said. You nodded. "Feel free to look around, just uh... don't look too hard" he said, rummaging through the drawers. You nodded, walking. You came across what you assumed Eddie's room was. You were met with a guitar, you staring at it.
"You play?" Eddie asked, him standing behind you. You jumped. "Uh. Used to." You said. "Don't tell me you left the life of rock n' roll to be a cheerleader, I will cry." Eddie said making you chuckle. "What can I say, pom poms spoke to me more." You said. Eddie gasped dramatically and you giggled.
Eddie smiled to himself. "So you ditched the nerds for the jocks" he said. "No, no... I just.. I'm not really sure where I fit. I hate those guys outside of Chrissy." You admitted. "So you don't like the jocks?" He asked. "God. No." You grimaced. "So, maybe." Eddie joked making you smile. "They're assholes. All of them. I mean, except Lucas. Seems he's the only one not short of a marble." You said.
"If you don't like them, why hang around them?" He asked. "I would move the earth for my best friend." You shrugged. Eddie looked over. "She's lucky to have you." Eddie said. You smiled slightly, nodding as a thanks.
Eddie opened a drawer, looking over his shoulder. "Hey, I tend to get pretty tired when I'm high, do you mind if I stay over?" You asked. "It's cool with me." He nodded. "Do you mind if I change then, I'm not exactly feeling the cheerleader uniform" you said making him smile. "Bathroom's across the hall" he told you.
You changed into your gym shorts and a t-shirt, walking into Eddie's room. He was sitting on his bed with a joint. "Green hit?" He asked. "Sure." You shrugged, sitting next to his legs. He gave you the joint, you lighting it and inhaling. You coughed, leaning back onto a pillow and handing the joint to Eddie.
"Why have we never hung out before this?" You asked. Eddie coughed, handing you the joint. "I didn't realize you were Dustin's sister.. and I had you pegged as someone completely different." Eddie said as you released smoke slowly from your mouth. You passed him the joint, him setting it on an ash tray. "Totally thought I was a bitch, didn't you" you guessed. "Something along the lines of that" Eddie chuckled. "Hopefully that opinion changed." You said. Eddie smiled at you. "Definitely." He said.
You smiled slightly, Eddie fidgeting after a bit before you rose a brow. "Can I see your rings?" You asked. He leaned forward holding out his hands. You noticed the skull based ones. There were two, one mainly being an angry looking skull while the other was a cross surrounded by skulls.
"What's with the pig?" You asked, noticing the middle ring was a pig rather than adding another skull. "Reminded me of 'War Pigs'." He shrugged. "Black Sabbath. Nice." You muttered. Eddie rose a brow. "You just keep getting better and better" he said making you grin.
You noticed his other hand. Compared to his right, his left had only one ring. "You actually got a class ring?" You asked. "If I'm suffering multiple years of highschool, I am leaving with proof that I survived it outside of a stupid yearbook photo." He said making you laugh.
You noticed the black stone in the center making you raise a brow. Without thinking, you pulled his hand forward staring at the stone. "Is that obsidian?" You asked curiously. "Yep" Eddie said. "Is that your birth stone?" You asked. "Yeah, why?" He asked. "When's your birthday?" you asked. "October 29th." He answered. You looked up, realizing you were holding his hand.
Silence fell over the two of you, him looking into your eyes. "You gonna let go?" He asked, his voice quiet. "Do you want me to?" You asked, without thinking. Eddie stayed quiet, his eyes moving to your lips. You swallowed hard before clearing your throat and dropping his hand.
"Sorry, my throat is like, super dry." You said. Eddie nodded. "I'll uh.. I'll get us some water." He said getting up. He left his room, walking into the kitchen when the phone rang. He picked up. "Hello?" Eddie asked. "Hey, this is a weird question but you saw my sister earlier, do you know where she is?" Dustin asked. "Funny you should ask that Henderson, she's with me." Eddie said. "Really? Okay, great. Mom started freaking out when she didn't come home." Dustin said relieved. "Yeah, she's staying here." Eddie said. "... You two are hanging out?" Dustin asked. "Yeah." Eddie nodded. "Is Chrissy with her?" Dustin asked. "No, why?" He asked. "...Nothing I just.. Huh. I don't think Y/n has ever spent a day away from Chrissy." Dustin admitted. "Is there anything else you needed Henderson?" Eddie asked. "Nope, I'll uh... I'll just tell mom she's with Max." Dustin said before hanging up.
Eddie walked into his room to see you sleeping. He smiled slightly, setting the water bottles down and pulling a blanket over you. He grabbed a free pillow, flipping off the light before hearing you. "Don't leave me"
Your voice was small, quiet when you spoke. Eddie looked at the couch from the doorway before walking back into his room, laying next to you. He didn't move, he was careful to try to not wake you.
Your morning was odd, waking up next to Eddie was a confusing start. When did you even fall asleep. You leaned up, careful as to not wake Eddie as you slipped out of bed and walked into the kitchen, dialing Chrissy's number.
The line seemed to be busy, you calling the house phone to be sure. There was no answer, instead, another busy line. You rose a brow, hanging up. There was a gut feeling, something telling you that this was wrong. Maybe it was the past few years having nothing but terrible events happen, maybe it was the paranoia sinking in from everything that she told you.
"Everything okay?" You heard Eddie ask. "...Can you do me a favor?" You asked. Eddie nodded. "Take me to Chrissy." You said. He hesitated but nodded, walking back into his room. When he reemerged, he had his jacket and your backpack in hand.
He tried to make conversation but you were distracted, noticing an abundance of cop cars riding through town. That was never a good sign.
Dustin had made numerous attempts to call Eddie's but it seemed to fail. Finally, he had the realization that Max lived next door, him calling her. That's when he got the answer that you and Eddie had left moments before he got the news himself.
You directed Eddie, Steve driving a fast as he could to beat you to Chrissy's.
Eddie had to park across the street due to the crimescene tape and the many, many, MANY police cars that surrounded the area. Steve and Dustin sprinted over, blocking you from approaching. "Y/n, slow down." Steve halted. "The fuck happened here?" Eddie asked. "Y/n... It's Chrissy, something happened." Dustin said. "Dustin, what's going on, where's Chrissy? Is she okay?" You asked. "Her parents tried to call this morning, she-" "Dustin, is she okay?" You asked.
Air left your lungs as you saw a body bag being wheeled out of the house, "no" you whimpered, Eddie silently gaping at the sight. "CHRIS!" you screamed, trying to push past Steve but failing. You collapsed to your knees, Eddie pulling you into a hug as you screamed.
If you had just stayed. If you had just insisted that you stay with her, maybe she'd still be here.
Dustin stared at the house as he saw Chrissy's parents sobbing in the front yard.
There was more to this, he could feel it. He knew too much about Hawkins to think this was something else. This was too odd to not be something else. The question though, remained.