What are your thoughts on sea monster / eel Simon? Personally I like it, but I know you generally aren't the biggest fan of it. But I wanted to know your specific thoughts about it if you don't mind sharing
Disclaimer: this is all for-fun creative bullshitting, I'm not the law, and I'm not dogging on anyone or encouraging bullying. My tone is "crazy guy at the pinboard", not any kind of anger!
I naturally gravitate to horror, and seeing so many people avoid it with a wide berth has been vaguely frustrating. Almost every sea monster idea I've seen of Simon has turned him into Man With Aesthetically Pleasing Fish Traits. It's not that serious, honestly who cares, but I'd love to see more straight-up awful horrible scary stuff about my awful horrible scary franchise.
If Simon were to mutate without the tree pendant involved, and he truly became a monster, it would not be "human man with some eel traits." It would be "horrible amalgamation of human DNA and [mystery oceanic DNA that vaguely resembles an eel] brute-forced into something that can survive a blood ocean. Maybe. Hopefully. God willing (literally)."
I'm a bit of a purist here simply because yeah, I did join the fandom to get my shit rocked emotionally and get spooked in the process.
So, since you specifically asked for my opinion, I personally think it would be more like the eel we see in the film. Similar but not the same. Maybe Simon would've even completely mind-melded with those two girls + addendum crew (?). Who knows.
If I were to go humanoid with it? Well, we already have that answer from the film. It's heavily implied this was the intended plan for Simon's "monster self." He was supposed to become some kind of eldritch "ghost":
Time is falling apart, melding together. Shadowman is Simon (reflect what he becomes.) Guilt, sorrow. Dissected = Eldritch Dissection of Simon.
But this fandom. I love it so, so much. You are amazing and you have done so much for me. I am forever blessed to have met you guys.
BUT YOU GUYS IGNORE THE SHIT OUT OF THIS VERY STRONG AND MOVING PLOT POINT.
THIS IS THE MONSTER SIMON YOU ALL WANTED. MARKIPLIER GAVE HIM TO YOU ON A SILVER PLATTER. YOU HAVE A CANON MARKIPLIER-APPROVED MONSTER SIMON AND YOU DID THIS IN RESPONSE:
YOU ARE NO BETTER THAN THE COI. YOU SEE SOMETHING TOO DISTURBING AND COVER IT THE FUCK UP. STOP BEING COWARDS. LOVE AND PEACE ON PLANET EARTH BUT IT'S THE PERFECT MONSTER MAN CAREFULLY CRAFTED FOR YOU AND YOU THREW HIM AWAY BECAUSE HE WAS TOO UGLY. YOU'RE NO BETTER THAN THE DAMN COI.
Okay. Love you guys mwah. Have a good day and thank you for the ask!