I will not take the Oath.
I hereby renounce the right to complacency,
But we have never had a right to be complacent. Complacency is only a privilege. When life is on the line, though the Laws sometimes allow for neglect, youāve raised me to care about life. I canāt in good conscience let a system thatās broken remain broken. Either it needs to be decommissioned or it needs to be fixed.
Here we get into the commitment thing that youāve always talked about. Yes, Iām worried about lifelong oaths. Itās why Iām not a Mason. Iāll live two hundred years, at the rate things are going. I canāt predict my own future well enough to say whether Iāll still agree with the Oath when Iām thirty, or one hundred and thirty. I know I donāt agree with it now, but even if I did, would I still, a decade in the future?
to take only what minimum of leisure is necessary to my productivity,
Iāve read the leisure-minimum documentation, I know that thereās a huge amount of rest necessary to remain at maximum productivity. I know the signs of burnout from school, and from what happened last year with Peregrine. But this algorithmic partitioning of life towards productivity doesnāt seem to be the best for me, even if Iām not a true voker like Apollo Mojave was. Freedom to choose when to work and when to voke and when to relax feels so much better. Itās not regimented; it leaves room for creativity and stretching and growth.
viewing health, happiness, rest and play as means, not ends,
Health. Thatās the lie. Health is one of our Utopiaās ends. Trying to defeat Death. Humanity canāt do that if health is just an instrument. Health has to be an end, not a means.
and that, while Utopia provides my needs,
I will commit the full produce of my labors to our collective effort
But Utopians never do this.
Either we say that everything, everything we do in any context ever, is towards the Project, or we admit that programming our coats and writing stories and composing the shreddingist anti-deathist death metal tracks are things which donāt actually contribute to The Grand Project. If we say that everything we do is towards the Project, then why have the Oath? If the set of things which do contribute are constrained, why do we do the things which do not contribute? I donāt like that two-facedness. I wonāt swear to it.
to redirect the path of human life away from death and toward the stars.
The one bit of the Oath that I do like is the last line: the goal.
I donāt need to be a Utopian to work towards that.
It is only while humans are alive that we are people. After death, what are we but fertilizer? Itās what we do while weāre alive that has meaning.
Itās meaningful to contribute to the Great Project, but many people find other sources of meaning in life. The Cousins find meaning in being helpful. The Masons and Whitelaws and Blacklaws find meaning in adherence to law. Greenpeace finds meaning in nature. Mitsubishi finds meaning in through nature, in the same control that Mason also likes. Gordian finds meaning in the mind. Europe and Mason find meaning in history. Humanista finds meaning in doing your best, in a way that I think only the Cousins really appreciate. Utopia does its best towards the Project, but I donāt think Utopiaās best is the best that can be done.
Utopia is a broken system, but its goal is a good one, and it seems like Utopia are the only people working towards the goal. So rather than decommission Utopia, the sole guardian of the Project, Iāll work to make the Project better.
How did it go? āOn my honor, I promise to do my best, to do my duty to my law and family, to help other people at all times, and to obey the Scout Law.ā
Thatās an oath I can uphold.
So Iāll see you in the morning standup call, and weāll have to figure out account access to the project boards and todo lists now that Iām outfreyn, and Iāll still play wingball.
But Iāll be wearing different boots now.
(aaaa I have to come up with boot designs now)
(why is this harder than coat nowheres)
((Sorry for springing this on you; it just kind of hit a point tonight where I needed to choose, because if I didnāt choose then I still would have made a choice))
(((Yes Iāll have #1551 done by standup; this just got in the way)))
This is set before Perhaps the Stars; it would be different if the narrator had read the events of that history.
Also available on me own website and on Archive Of Our Own.