this letter was a long time coming. it was already late when you were 33.
i did the math today and realized you’re 48 now.
and for some reason, that unsettles me more than anything else. maybe because in my head, you never aged past that version of you i knew. i don’t even know what you look like now.
but in my head you're still there. in College of Science, uniform pressed, shoulders squared, that restrained smile you never let fully happen,
just the slight lift on the right side of your lip.
it’s strange how that stayed so clear, when everything else faded.
sometimes i forget it’s been more than a decade since i last touched you.
i owe you an apology i never had the courage to give.
so i want to apologize now. not in the way i should have back then--this is obviously too late for that -- but at least in a way that’s honest now.
for not telling you the truth,
that you no longer fit in the life i was building.
for choosing the easy cruelty of blocking you
instead of the harder kindness of honesty.
for every call i cut short.
every message i left unanswered.
because i was too consumed with becoming someone else.
i’m sorry for how i pushed you, how i challenged you in ways you probably didn’t expect from me.
i’m sorry for letting you feel something that might have been love. maybe it was.
i cared about you. that part was real.
but care isn’t always enough to stay.
i’m sorry i gave you my first. i didn’t think about what that might mean to you, or what it might make you hope for.
i’m sorry i left you there, in that town where everything started and ended for us.
i don’t know if there were others after me. i used to think there weren’t. you didn’t seem like that kind of man.
but then again, i didn’t seem like that kind of girl either.
sometimes i think about how easily it could have gone differently.
if i walked into your class that second year and didn’t tie my hair up so high that you later said made me look like a cat. didn’t wear those green skinny jeans you said made you notice me.
if i just… didn’t catch your attention at all.
maybe i wouldn’t have disrupted your life the way i did.
you always said, “you can do this, kid.”
and i think what stays with me isn’t that we didn’t end up together
it's that i never gave you the ending
Edit: who am i kidding? I loved you. I loved you. That part was real.