In support of this week's protesters... SCHOOLS TOO NEED A HEALTHY HEART
Head teachers make much of âIndividualityâ â nurturing âthe fully rounded individualâ. But the whole point of a national curriculum is that everyone is doing the same thing in the same way at the same time with the same ends in mind. The last thing it aims for is individualism. Thatâs not a complaint, just a fact.
So it is down to extra curricula activities to do the rounding out/off. A library is the ultimate extra curricula opportunity. In a school library children can make their own discoveries about what interests them, what delights them, what scintillates them â the kind of discoveries that make you a distinct and unique person.
Put a child into a national curriculum and you are â to some extent â putting him into a cage and feeding him pre-digested pellets of selected knowledge washed down with a drop of exam technique.Â
Put a child into a library and you are introducing her to self-enlightenment â the sum total of the worldâs efforts to enlighten its young. ...Or if thatâs a bit overstated, at least the chance to develop their own tastes and pursue their own private passions.
You might argue that parents will shape the mental landscapes of their children â turn them into little individuals. But parents are designed to replicate themselves: Itâs human nature. No, free-range free reading is what liberates a child from the opinions of others â even his all-powerful peer group who think they know exactly what he should think and get up to.
We hear a lot about the selling off of school playing fields. Replacing your childâs intellectual playground with a bank of computers and calling it an Information Centre is every bit as dire and itâs happening on a much wider scale.Â
A paltry shelf of books in a classroom is no substitute for the Library as a physical entity.        Yes, itâs a bolt hole for the quiet reflective child who can, elsewhere in the school, find himself a social pariah.
Yes, itâs a bolt hold for the free thinker â the dissident, the dissenter, the true original who elsewhere gets called a pain in the academic backside.
Yes, itâs the haven of the nerd.
But for EVERYONE it is a place where knowledge is theirs to do with as they like.
Librarians donât have an agenda. They are there to help, not dictate. It gives them an extraordinary, priceless status in a school. Iâve come across School Librarians who are confessor, counsellor, life coach, ally, sounding-board, co-conspirator... Crucially the librarian is the one with the spade: the spade for digging an escape tunnel from the hard labour and mundanity of school and life in general.
A major reason why schools embrace the idea of shedding their libraries is to shed the cost of a librarian. (The books are there; they arenât costing anything.) But the trained librarian is every bit as important an asset to preserve as the books.
And bear in mind that the Schools Library Services wonât be there to paste over the deficiency: those are being disbanded faster than you can blink.
 Unfortunately, when it comes to literature in particular, the current rigid exam structure is proving to have one tiny down-side. It has put a whole generation off literature.Â
They get told exactly what to think about a handful of books, poems and plays, what to say about them when asked, using which precise words. Not quite the original purpose of literature or drama. In fact correct me if Iâm wrong, but the entirely opposite purpose of literature and drama.
But find your way into a library, and there it all is â literature â well, story, words, pictures, newspapers â STUFF. And it comes without a price tag. No one is going to test you on it, tell you what to think about it, set homework relating to it. It is just there to enjoy,  to explore, to dip into, to swallow or spit out. Lo and behold â personal opinion, individual tastes and preferences, worlds of the imagination, visual stimulation, a happier relationship with words, doorways to fantasy â even (though donât say it out loud) freedom of thought.
Until teacher training includes an obligatory module on childrenâs literature, young teachers are likely to prove just as clueless as their pupils about whatâs out there to read. Theyâre likely to say (if the subject of books comes up) that they donât have time to read (which is entirely possible!)
The librarian, on the other hand, is likely to ask, âGot time for a trip to Mars?â   âWhat do you think of black-and-red?â âHave you got the nerve for the First World War? This oneâs pretty harrowing.â âDid you enjoy Millions? Thought you would.â     âLike comics? Some of the best illustrators do graphic novels, look.â      âMonsters? Yeah! Give Gilgamesh a go.â  âHave you read the latest Mal Peet? I thought it was terrific.â âYouâre into grisly angst, arenât you? Are you up for Tender Morsels?â
I know that, as an author of fiction, Iâm horribly biased, but fiction is particularly  ill-served by the Nat Curriculum.  And fiction is an invaluable resourceto any poor, benighted kid trapped inside one small, unsatisfactory, slightly scary, regimented life: i.e. any schoolchild. A shelf of fiction represents a whole range of alternative lives, experiences and places to go. Just there. All you have to do is reach out and take down a book to put on another manâs shoes and walk a mile with him, to see the world through another personâs eyes. (And the art of identifying/empathising with another person is crucial to developing a moral capacity.)
And if all that sounds a bit airy fairy for the modern thrusting world of league tables and value-adding facilities, then:
Universities will always be looking for candidates who are widely read and show some spark of original thought: it stands to reason they will. How else can they possibly select entrants from a procession of identical cerebella stuffed with the identical contents of a standardised curriculum?
And academia aside? Industry is forever saying it needs people who can think outside the box. School libraries are the key for getting you out of the box and starting you thinking.Â
So a school library and a good librarian are the best value-adding facilities money can buy.
If you disband a library it cannot be re-assembled later, when times look up or when you think better of it. It is probably an asset that has been growing ever since the school opened, paid for out of decades of school budgets. Once gone, itâs gone. I would say to any Head Teacher eager to open young minds to the sunlight: closing down your library is about as sound as trepanning.
The Great Library at Alexandria probably burned down by accident â collateral damage Caesar would have said. Unfortunate collateral damage.Â