♯┆A Fixed Point .ᐟ
⋮ ⌗ ┆ Benjamin Poindexter (FBI!dex) x fem!reader
summary ⋮ Benjamin Poindexter x reader fic set before his fall into Bullseye. Y/N Hawthorne, a forensic psychology student in New York, finds herself becoming familiar with a quiet FBI agent who walks into her favourite coffee shop every morning. What begins as a simple routine slowly becomes something far more complicated.
⋮ ⌗ ┆ chapter 1/?
⋮ ⌗ ┆ wc: 3k
New York never really slept.
Even before dawn, the city breathed through the distant growl of traffic, the hiss of buses kneeling at empty stops, and the occasional wail of a siren somewhere beyond the rows of apartment buildings. From the fourth floor of your building, those sounds had become familiar enough that silence felt stranger than noise.
Your alarm sounded at six.
You reached across the bedside table and silenced it before it could ring again. A grey tabby immediately lifted his head from the pillow beside you, emerald eyes narrowed in quiet annoyance.
"You've got a harder life than I do," you murmured.
The cat answered with a slow blink before curling back into himself.
The apartment was modest, but it was yours.
Well—not yours. The landlord would certainly remind you of that if the rent was late—but it was home. A small kitchen with mismatched cupboards, a narrow living room dominated by second-hand furniture, shelves overflowing with university textbooks, and walls that desperately needed repainting. Nothing about it was glamorous.
You loved it anyway.
Every object had been bought with money you had earned. Every book had brought you one step closer to where you wanted to be.
Forensic psychology.
Less than two years remained until you graduated.
Sometimes that still surprised you.
There had been nights where assignments blurred into sunrise, mornings fuelled entirely by coffee, and weeks where your bank account looked frighteningly empty before your next pay cheque arrived from the university library. Yet somehow, despite everything, you had made it this far.
You intended to finish.
After showering, you pulled on running leggings, an old university sweatshirt, and trainers that had seen better days. You filled your cat's bowl before crouching beside him.
"I'll be back in half an hour."
He ignored you with complete dignity.
Outside, the cool morning air hit your face immediately.
The streets carried that peculiar quiet found only just before commuters flooded the pavements. A newspaper stand was being stocked on the corner. Delivery vans idled beside restaurants. Somewhere nearby, someone was dragging metal chairs across concrete to prepare for opening.
Your route never changed.
Three blocks east.
Across the small park.
Round the fountain.
Then back again.
Nothing ambitious. Just enough to clear your head before lectures.
Running had become less about fitness and more about routine. It gave your mind somewhere to organise itself before the day demanded your attention.
By the time you returned to the main street, your breathing had settled into a comfortable rhythm. Sweat clung lightly to the back of your neck, and your legs carried the pleasant ache that came from moving rather than sitting at a desk.
The familiar bell chimed as you stepped into the coffee shop.
Warm air wrapped around you immediately, carrying the rich smell of roasted coffee beans and freshly baked pastries. Indie music drifted quietly through hidden speakers while an espresso machine hissed behind the counter.
"Morning," the barista called, already recognising you.
"Morning."
"The usual?"
You smiled.
"Please."
She nodded before reaching automatically for a paper cup.
You leaned against the collection counter, fishing your phone from your pocket while customers drifted in behind you.
Then the bell above the door rang again.
The man who entered looked as though he belonged somewhere quieter. He wore a dark jacket zipped neatly to his collar despite the mild weather. His hair was trimmed short, almost military in appearance, and his posture was impossibly straight. Every movement was economical, precise, as though unnecessary motion had been carefully removed from his life.
His eyes swept across the café.
Not casually.
Methodically.
Door.
Windows.
Customers.
Counter.
You noticed because you studied people. It had become instinct. Most people looked around a room. This man assessed it.
He joined the queue without touching his phone or glancing absentmindedly towards the menu. Instead, he stood perfectly still with his hands loosely folded in front of him.
No fidgeting.
No sighing.
No shifting his weight.
Nothing.
It wasn't normal.
Not unsettling.
Just... unusual.
"Large black coffee."
His voice carried easily across the café.
Calm.
Even.
Controlled.
The cashier smiled politely.
"Anything else?"
"No."
His answer came almost before she'd finished asking.
You collected your own drink as your order was called.
"Thanks."
"You have a good one."
"You too."
Turning towards the door, you adjusted your grip around the warm cup.
Someone stepped aside at exactly the same moment. You both moved to avoid one another. Then accidentally chose the same direction.
"Oh—"
You laughed softly.
"Sorry."
The man immediately shifted back, giving you enough room to pass.
"My mistake."
His voice remained perfectly level.
Not cold.
Simply factual.
Up close, you noticed faint shadows beneath his eyes, as though sleep was something he tolerated rather than enjoyed. There was a tiny scar near his jawline, almost hidden beneath the morning stubble, and another disappearing beneath the collar of his jacket.
He met your gaze for barely a second.
Long enough to acknowledge you.
Not long enough to invite conversation.
"No," you replied with an awkward smile. "I walked straight into your path."
He gave a single nod.
Neither apologetic nor dismissive. Merely accepting the information.
For a brief moment, neither of you moved.
Then the cashier called out, "Large black coffee."
The man inclined his head.
"Excuse me."
"Of course."
He stepped around you with surprising care, making certain not to brush your shoulder as he passed. There was something almost rehearsed about the movement—as though he'd consciously calculated exactly how much space to leave.
You watched him collect his coffee.
"No room?" the barista asked.
"No."
"No sugar?"
"No."
"Have a nice day."
He paused.
"You too."
Again, perfectly polite. Perfectly measured. Nothing about him stood out in the way people often imagined suspicious individuals would. If anything, he seemed exceptionally ordinary.
Quiet.
Reserved.
Disciplined.
The sort of man who kept to himself.
You pushed open the café door and stepped back into the cool morning air. Behind you, a few seconds later, the bell chimed again. You glanced back without really thinking. The same man emerged carrying his coffee.
He turned left.
You turned right.
Within moments, the crowds beginning to gather along the pavement swallowed him entirely.
You never learned his name.
Not that morning.
Not yet.
—
The days settled back into their familiar rhythm.
Lecture.
Library.
Work.
Sleep.
Run.
Coffee.
Repeat.
There was a certain comfort in routine. You had always found it easier to manage the chaos of university when each morning began the same way. It made New York feel smaller somehow, less overwhelming.
About a week after your brief encounter with the quiet stranger, you noticed him again.
He was already inside the café when you arrived.
Just as before, he stood in the queue without looking at his phone. While everyone else filled the silence by scrolling through messages or staring blankly out of the window, he simply waited.
Perfect posture.
Hands loosely clasped.
Eyes calmly taking in the room.
You joined the line a few places behind him.
"Large black coffee," he said when it was his turn.
The cashier smiled.
"No room?"
"No."
"No sugar?"
"No."
"You have a nice day."
"You too."
The exchange lasted no more than twenty seconds.
By the time you reached the counter, he was already walking out with the paper cup held securely in one hand.
You thought nothing more of it.
Until two mornings later.
Again.
The same jacket.
The same measured voice.
The same order.
"Large black coffee."
"No room?"
"No."
"No sugar?"
"No."
It happened often enough that you began to notice the details without meaning to. He arrived within roughly the same ten-minute window each weekday morning. Never looked rushed. Never lingered. Always thanked the staff. Always left.
His routine was almost as predictable as your own.
"You know him?"
The question came unexpectedly one Thursday morning.
You looked away from the door, finding the barista sealing your cup with its lid.
"Him?"
She nodded towards the window where the man was already disappearing into the crowd.
"The FBI guy."
You blinked.
"FBI?"
She laughed quietly.
"I thought everyone around here knew."
"I've only been coming here for..." You paused, trying to count it in your head. "About eight months."
"He flashes his badge sometimes if someone asks why he's carrying."
"Carrying?"
"The gun."
"Oh."
Your surprise must have shown because she smiled sympathetically.
"Scared me the first time too."
"I never noticed."
"He keeps it well hidden."
You accepted your coffee.
"I suppose I wasn't looking."
"He comes in nearly every weekday."
"I've noticed."
The words escaped before you realised you'd said them. The barista grinned knowingly.
"Hard not to."
You frowned.
"What do you mean?"
She shrugged. "He's memorable."
That was true. Not because he was loud or charismatic. Quite the opposite. There was something about him that made the room subtly rearrange itself around him. People instinctively gave him space without seeming to realise they were doing it. He wasn't intimidating exactly.
Just... composed.
Like someone who always knew exactly where they were standing.
—
Nearly three weeks passed.
Spring slowly crept further into the city. Trees lining the park began showing fresh green leaves, and people exchanged heavy winter coats for lighter jackets.
Your coursework became increasingly demanding.
Behavioural profiling.
Criminal cognition.
Risk assessment.
Some modules fascinated you so completely that hours vanished inside the university library without you noticing.
Others required considerably more caffeine.
It was after one particularly exhausting seminar that you found yourself wondering, entirely absentmindedly, whether the FBI agent would already have collected his coffee.
The thought surprised you.
Not because it mattered. Only because it had become familiar.
He was simply... there.
Like the newspaper stand outside. Or the elderly woman who walked the same dachshund every morning. Or the man who played saxophone outside the subway entrance every Friday afternoon.
Just another constant.
Except, unlike everyone else, he never seemed distracted.
One Monday morning, you arrived a little earlier than usual. To your mild surprise, so had he.
He stood near the collection counter rather than in the queue, his coffee already waiting beside him. Instead of immediately leaving, however, he remained where he was.
Not idle.
Watching.
His gaze drifted towards the front window.
A delivery cyclist almost collided with a taxi outside. A pedestrian stepped backwards into the road without looking. Someone shouted.
Within seconds, everything settled.
The man hadn't reacted dramatically.
He had simply... observed.
His eyes followed each movement with quiet precision before returning to the interior of the café.
Only then did he notice you.
For the briefest moment, recognition flickered across his face.
Not warmth.
Not surprise.
Recognition.
You had seen one another enough times now to become familiar.
He gave a small nod. The same restrained acknowledgement as before.
You returned it almost instinctively.
"Morning."
The word left your mouth before you'd decided to speak.
There was a pause.
Short enough that another person might not even have noticed.
Then he answered.
"Morning."
His voice remained level, controlled, almost careful.
No smile. No awkwardness.
Simply polite.
The silence that followed wasn't uncomfortable.
It merely... existed.
The barista broke it.
"Usual?"
You looked over.
"Please."
As she began preparing your drink, you became aware that the man hadn't yet left. He picked up his coffee, adjusted the lid by a fraction, then glanced towards the door.
"You come here every morning," he said.
It wasn't phrased as a question.
You looked back at him.
"So do you."
Another tiny pause.
"Yes."
Nothing more. No attempt at conversation. No introduction. Just an acknowledgement of a fact.
He inclined his head once more before walking towards the exit.
The bell above the café door chimed as he disappeared onto the pavement outside, swallowed once again by the flow of New Yorkers hurrying to work.
You watched him leave for only a second before collecting your own coffee.
It wasn't until you were halfway back to your apartment that you realised something.
You still didn't know his name.
But somehow, after nearly three weeks of passing one another almost every weekday morning, he no longer felt like a stranger.
—
Another week passed.
Mid-term assessments arrived with all the subtlety of a freight train.
Your dining table disappeared beneath open textbooks, highlighted journal articles, handwritten notes and empty mugs that you kept promising yourself you would wash. More than once, you fell asleep with your laptop still open, only to wake an hour later with a crick in your neck and a paragraph of keyboard imprints pressed into your cheek.
The coffee shop became less of a luxury and more of a necessity.
The staff no longer asked for your order.
"The usual?" was all they needed.
"The usual," you would answer.
By now, you recognised most of the regulars. The elderly man who spent an hour every morning completing crossword puzzles. Two paramedics who alternated buying breakfast depending on whose payday it was. A woman in a navy business suit who always left with three coffees balanced expertly in a cardboard carrier.
And, almost every weekday morning... Benjamin.
You still hadn't heard him introduce himself.
One Tuesday, however, another customer had held the door open as he was leaving.
"Morning, Agent Benjamin Poindexter."
He had paused just long enough to acknowledge him.
"Morning."
That was all.
No conversation followed.
The man continued on his way, and Benjamin disappeared into the crowd as he always did.
Benjamin Poindexter.
The name settled somewhere in the back of your mind. You weren't entirely sure why. Perhaps because names made people feel more real.
'The FBI guy' had become Agent Benjamin Poindexter.
It suited him.
—
Rain arrived without warning the following Friday.
The sky had been overcast during your run, but by the time you reached the café the heavens had opened.
People crowded just inside the entrance, shaking umbrellas and brushing rainwater from their coats.
You joined the queue, pushing damp strands of hair away from your face.
"Looks like everyone's had the same idea," the barista joked.
"No chance I'm surviving today's lecture without caffeine."
She laughed.
"That's the spirit."
The bell above the door rang.
You didn't need to look.
For reasons you couldn't quite explain, you already knew who had walked in.
Benjamin paused just inside the entrance, folding a black umbrella with careful efficiency before slipping it into a waterproof sleeve. His jacket was spotted with rain, though not nearly as soaked as everyone else's.
He must have anticipated the weather.
Of course he had.
He quietly joined the queue behind you.
You glanced over your shoulder.
"Morning."
His eyes met yours briefly.
"Morning."
The line moved slowly. Someone ahead was arguing over an incorrect order, while another customer struggled to decide between pastries.
Neither of you spoke.
It wasn't uncomfortable anymore.
Simply... quiet.
Eventually, the cashier called your name. You stepped forward, reaching into your bag for your purse.
Your stomach dropped.
You checked again.
The front pocket.
The inside compartment.
Nothing.
"...No."
You frowned to yourself.
"I've left my wallet at home."
The cashier offered an understanding smile.
"It happens."
"I can just—" You sighed. "I'll come back."
As you turned away, a calm voice spoke behind you.
"I've got it."
You looked around.
Benjamin was already holding out his card.
You blinked.
"Oh... no, honestly, you don't have to."
"It isn't a problem."
"I can come back."
"You could." His expression remained as composed as ever. "Or I can pay for your coffee."
You hesitated. It wasn't the amount. It was accepting something from someone you barely knew.
Perhaps he recognised the uncertainty because he added, in the same measured tone, "You can repay me another morning."
There was no pressure in his voice. No expectation. Simply a practical solution.
The cashier looked between the two of you.
"Should I...?"
Benjamin gave a single nod.
"Together."
The payment terminal beeped.
Transaction approved.
You stared for a moment before letting out a small, embarrassed laugh.
"Thank you."
"You're welcome."
"I really will pay you back."
"I believe you."
His coffee was placed beside yours.
"Large black coffee."
He picked it up.
You collected your own cup.
For a moment, the two of you stood near the door while rain hammered against the windows hard enough to blur the city beyond into streaks of grey.
"I appreciate it," you said again.
Benjamin nodded once.
"You said you're at university."
You looked at him, slightly surprised that he'd remembered.
"I am."
"What do you study?"
"Forensic psychology."
For the first time since you'd known him, something changed. It wasn't dramatic. Had you not spent years studying facial expressions, you might have missed it entirely.
His attention sharpened.
Not suspicion.
Interest.
"Genuinely?" he asked.
The question came just a fraction quicker than his previous replies.
You smiled.
"Genuinely."
"What made you choose that?"
You shifted your coffee into your other hand.
"I've always been interested in why people do what they do. Not in the crimes themselves..." You searched for the right words. "More the people behind them. Their behaviour. Their decision-making. How trauma changes someone. Things like that."
Benjamin listened without interrupting.
Completely.
The bustle of the café continued around you—the hiss of steaming milk, the scrape of chairs against the floor, customers weaving past on their way back into the rain—but his attention didn't drift once.
When you finished, he was silent for a moment.
"Interesting," he said simply.
You laughed softly.
"Most people think it's morbid."
"I don't."
The reply was immediate.
Matter-of-fact.
"I think it's useful."
Before you could answer, something buzzed inside his jacket.
Not a phone.
A sharp electronic tone.
He reached into an inside pocket and glanced down at what appeared to be a bureau-issued device.
His posture changed almost imperceptibly.
Duty.
He slipped it away.
"I have to go."
"Right. Of course."
There was a brief pause.
"I'll see you around."
Benjamin inclined his head.
"Yes."
Then, without another word, he opened the café door and stepped out into the rain, disappearing once more into the moving crowds.
You watched the door swing shut behind him.
Only then did you realise that, after more than a month of crossing paths, you'd finally had something resembling a conversation.
It hadn't been long. Perhaps three minutes.
Yet somehow, it felt as though the quiet distance between the two of you had become just a little smaller.
—
°❀⋆.ೃ࿔*:・
© anehlcia 2026. Do not repost, copy, translate or use any of my work for ai. I post only on tumblr.
Next Part — HERE




















