Komahina analysis from Soda manga
The Betrayal Hurt Hinata More Than He Lets On
After Komaeda shows his ātrue colorsā during the trial and gets tied up). In this scene, Soda is complaining about Komaeda and arguing with Hinata on the beach.
"I was also deceived by him..."
Soda is doing his usual yelling, but Hinata goes quiet and looks down. His expressions speaks volumes about how deep Komaedaās betrayal cut him.
Komaeda is literally the first person Hinata wakes up to on the beach. He was friendly, reassuring, and spent the entire intro guiding Hinata around the island. Because Hinata had no memories and was completely lost, Komaeda became his main anchor and his savior too. So when Komaeda turns out to be unhinged during the first trial, Hinata was shocked and felt betrayed.
"He helped me when I fainted at the beginning, so I thought he was a good guy..."
When Soda calls him "sweetly naive" Hinata gets surprisingly defensive and snaps back.
"Are you saying that you didn't believe in Komaeda and everyone at the beginning!?"
Hinata is defending the genuine connection he thought they shared at the start. He wanted to trust Komaeda.
He feels deeply hurt because he genuinely cared about Komaeda and trusted him first. Even after finding out how dangerous Komaeda is, Hinata can't completely erase the comfort Komaeda gave him on day one. Heās frustrated at Komaeda, but he's also frustrated at himself for still caring.
I just wanted to show this scene, thereās nothing much to say here except Hinataās expressions lol.
Hinataās talent & Suspicion
When the group is discussing the traitor and Monokuma appears to unlock a new island.
"I think Hinata is the most suspicious."
Hinata was shocked by Komaedaās response. He didnāt expect Komaeda to suspect him especially.
"Y...you said I'm the most suspicious!"
Hinata immediately calls him back out on it. Even with everything else going on: Monokuma, new island opening up⦠Hinata is fixated on what Komaeda thinks of him. He couldnāt just let Komaedaās comment slide.
Following up right after the last scene, Soda confronts Komaeda privately to ask why he suspects Hinata.
Komaeda tells his opinions/theories about Hinataās body-discovery history quickly turns into something way more personal.
Komaeda is genuinely reminiscing about how kind Hinata was to him.
When Komaeda catches the Despair Disease, Hinata actually goes out of his way to check on him in the hospital. For someone like Komaeda, who believes his bad luck destroys any chance at love or connection, Hinataās kindness was overwhelming.
"But such happiness hasn't existed in my life up until now..."
(Right after commenting about Hinataās kindness)
Komaeda wants connection, but his trauma and luck cycle have convinced him that good things always lead to absolute despair. Hinataās empathy feels "too good to be true".
Komaeda keeps in mind every ākindā thing Hinata has ever done for him: visiting him in the hospital, talking to him when no one else would. He just admits that Hinataās kindness brought him a level of happiness he isn't used to having and that terrifies him.
After Komaeda beats the Final Dead Room and accesses the student profiles, he learns the truth that Hinata was never an Ultimate at all, but a talentless Reserve Course student.
Even after Chapter 1, when Komaeda went full unhinged during the class trial and everyone else in the group started treating him like a freak, Komaeda still talked to Hinata with a weird kind of affection and gentleness. He sometimes teased him and he always sought out Hinataās presence and treated him like he was someone special.
Hinata had gotten used to Komaeda being weirdly attached to him. So when Komaeda comes out and looks Hinata dead in the eyes, and says: "Can you, a Reserve Course student, not talk to me like we're friends?ā It is a sudden change but what comes right after: āI think Iām going to cross you out of the possible traitor list since itās impossible for a reserve course student who has no talent to be part of the future agency.ā
Komaeda basically means: "Yes, you are nothing." but in a sense that Hinata is harmless and has nothing to do with Future agency which is good and bad at the same time?ā¦. Neutral I would say. (Bad according to Komaeda since Hinata is a reserve course student and Good since Hinata has nothing to do with the future agency).
Looking at Hinataās expression in the void, Komaedaās words validated Hinataās deepest fear: that without talent, his existence has no value, no purpose and no place among these people. I also think that Hinata was already kinda āsuffocatingā under his own inferiority complex but hearing the one person who originally made him feel seen and āacceptedā now openly look down on him for being talentless confirms every dark thought Hinata ever had about himself.
For Hinata, his entire life's drive was to be "someone special" He carried a deep, painful complex about being ordinary. Being stuck in a killing game alongside Ultimates already made him feel out of place, but he held onto a hope that maybe, just maybe, his forgotten memory meant he had a cool Ultimate talent hidden inside him. Then comes the reveal: He is nobody.
Komaeda steps up and voices his exact internal terror out loud: He is staring at the void of his own identity and right when he is questioning his existence.
Komaedaās attitude towards Hinata
The fact that Owari and Kuzuryu both react to Komaedaās sudden shift proves it isn't just in Hinata's head
Everyone saw how Komaeda hovered around Hinata, so when he suddenly flips a switch and treats Hinata with coldness, itās so shocking that even Owari who usually doesn't overthink, immediately calls Komaeda out for being needlessly cruel and harsh towards Hinata. And itās also a shock for Hinata as well, I think he tries to process both his existence and Komaedaās behavior towards him.
Hinata's Obsession with Talent
Itās not about Komahina but I liked Hinataās reaction in the manga. To the others, talent doesn't matter but to him, talent means a lot to him.
Soda try to reassure him: "It doesn't really matter what it is, right? You're you after all" and tries to be supportive in his own gruff way with "I don't really care whether you have a talent or not..."
But Hinata responds with: āITāS NOT GOOD!!ā and "I care about it!"
Hinata hates that he can't remember his talent, and he doesnāt seem to like when people brush it off like it's no big deal.
He needs to have a talent to justify his own presence among the Ultimates. His friends have talent but for Hinata, who is desperately clinging to the hope that he's somebody special, not knowing his talent is deeply frustrating. But right after, he changes topics because even though he wants to know about his ātalentā, talking about it also makes him uncomfortable and prefers not to think too much about it.
Thank you for reading along with my rambles. Let me know if I said something wrong, it happens when I make mistakes without realizing it.