Not the surface one; not the polished bar‑version. The real one. The one that slipped out before she could rein it in. And for a split second, it did something ugly and inconvenient in his chest.
He took a slow sip of his bourbon, eyes never leaving her.
“Garbage and piss‑covered sidewalks,” he repeated lazily. “You say that like it’s a moral equalizer.” His mouth tilted. “Difference is, sweetheart, I don’t have to walk ‘em. I choose to.” A second passed. “You? You sound like you’ve made peace with it.”
His gaze sharpened, studying her over the rim of the glass. “And that tells me more than the paycheck ever could.”
She hit him with that line about impressing him, and he actually huffed under his breath, something low and amused.
“Oh, I don’t doubt that,” he said smoothly. “If you were tryin’ to impress me, I’d probably need a minute to recover.” His eyes flicked down and back up again, slow and deliberate. “But don’t sell the banter short. You wield it like a blade.”
When he leaned close and she held her ground, that’s when it clicked for him.
Most people flinched.
Even the tough ones.
Especially the tough ones.
There was always a tell in the shoulders, a breath caught wrong, a micro‑step backward.
Freya didn’t give him that.
She went still. Controlled. Deliberate.
That wasn’t instinct. That was training.
Billy’s grin didn’t fade; it evolved.
“Spent time with married women?” he echoed, eyebrow lifting. “I spend time with all kinds of women.” He tilted his head slightly, studying her reaction. “And men. And soldiers. And liars. Patterns repeat.”
She leaned back, creating space.
“Shitty men,” he repeated, softer now.
Not mocking.
Not prying.
Just tasting the words.
“Yeah. That tracks.”
His eyes moved over her again, slower this time, not predatory, assessing. There was something in the way she said it. Not broken. Not bitter. Just… catalogued.
He set his glass down with a quiet clink.
“You know what I think?” he said casually, stepping just close enough to keep the conversation intimate without crowding her again. “I think you didn’t have shitty men.” His head tilted slightly. “I think you had dangerous ones.”
Silence settled between them, heavy but not loud.
Billy’s mouth curved slowly, appreciation clear and unhidden now.
“Oh, I like that,” he murmured. “You’re right. Dinner first. I’ve got manners.” He leaned one forearm on the bar beside her, posture relaxed but coiled underneath. “And I didn’t accuse you of anything. I just pointed out that you move like someone who knows how to survive.”
His voice lowered a notch, losing some of the theatrical edge.
He studied her face for another second, then let something honest slip through the cracks.
“You’re not sloppy. You don’t panic. You don’t overshare.” His eyes flicked to the bartender, then back to her. “That’s not PTA behavior. That’s someone who learned lessons the hard way.”
He pushed off the bar then, straightening, slipping his wallet from his jacket pocket without breaking eye contact.
“Dinner,” he said simply. “Real place. No neon beer signs. Somewhere we can talk without the soundtrack of bad karaoke.”
His grin returned, slower now. Less testing. More intrigued.
“And I promise, Freya… I won’t ask for your whole life story. Just the parts you feel like giving me.”
His gaze held hers, steady, unapologetically interested.
“Unless,” he added, voice dipping into something dangerously warm, “you’re scared I might figure you out.”