I've been mulling over your posts re: breathing exercises for a while and like⌠it makes sense to me that given how you've experienced a lot of techniques aimed at coping with anxiety as intensely invalidating & disenfranchising of your feelings, needs, intuitions, nervous-system responses, etc., that practicing a breathing method with a rigid externally imposed structure might activate that same distress. Does that resonate at all? (If so, it also means a lot of the well-meaning unsolicited advice you've been getting about technique would miss the mark for you since it's aimed at, so to speak, symptoms not causes.) If you're in the market for more well-meaning unsolicited advice⌠it seems like you've had pretty good luck with taking an intuitive, curious & sometimes-playful, sensory-based, descriptivist-not-prescriptivist approach to other types of grounding & centering practices. I would consider what your goals/hopes for doing breathing exercises, then try to get in a place/position where you're physically comfortable, breathe in a way that feels intuitive for you, start paying attention to your breathing & how you feel, and then maybeâif you're vibing with itâtry intentionally varying your breathing in whatever ways seem like they might be interesting, and see how they make you feel. Rather than taking a technique that works pretty well for most people and trying to figure out how to adapt it to work for you, start from the ground up, from your individual beingâlike getting a bespoke suit rather than buying off the rack & getting it tailored.
I guess my posts were worded as though I was searching for advice on how to make breathing exercises work for me, but I was more interested on understanding why they don't, and for the people for whom breathing exercises do work, why they do work.
However I have received such varying and contradictory answers on how breathing exercises are supposed to work and what they are doing physiologically, that I think answers to these questions are impossible.
I believe the reason it feels concerning is that I am trying to heal my medical fear, and the way I was taught this was supposed to work is that I was supposed to expose myself to the feared thing while using "coping skills" to mitigate the fear.
However, for me, all the common "coping skills" that purport to be able to shut down or reverse the physiological reaction of fear do not work.
The success I have found with healing has been through engineering experiences that feel safe, not controlling my own physiological responses of fear. I'm not even sure if "coping skills" broadly are appropriate here; when I was experimenting with "safe" medical experiences, getting my vaccines at the grocery store pharmacy, I found it comforting in some ways to acknowledge and feel those physiological responses. The physical process of fear in my body is, essentially, my body's preparedness to protect itself, and I envisioned my fear as my werewolf-self: a huge wolf wrapping her body around me and growling in warning while I get my flu shot.
I even found it helpful to imagine myself "transforming into the wolf" so to speak: surrendering control to the fear. I have a hard time articulating why this resulted in feeling confident during the potentially scary situation rather than avoidance.
"Surrendering to fear" in common speech would mean leaving and not getting the vaccine. Is it really true, or is it just an assumption that if a person surrenders to their fear, they will only avoid?
I think it's possible my problem with breathing exercises is much more fundamental than technique. Fundamentally, such "coping skills" are about reversing and shutting down the process of fear, and the assumption that this is good and desirable to do comes from a hierarchical view of humans as consisting of a "lower" body and a "higher" mind, with the mind having "evolved past" the body necessitating a relationship of power and dominance over the body by the mind.
This leads to the view that what the body knows is false and cannot be trusted, which is the fundamental idea underpinning the diagnostic category of "anxiety."
What I came to, entirely on my own and because I had no other option, is that my fear, or my wolf-self, tells me about my safety needs. Not only do these safety needs include physical safety from harm, they also include the need to have human dignity and to be protected from forceful violation. Fear that is connected directly to one of these safety needs is what I call "Saw trap" fear: it is primal and gut-wrenching and deeper than cognition, because it directly defends the self. It feels like how it feels to be caught in a trap and have to cut through your own leg to escape.
I think you can't cognitive-behavioral-therapy your way out of fear of rape, gruesome mutilation, or excruciating pain (not the thought of these things, but the imminent, certain threat) because it's essentially hardwired. That's what fear is FOR. You can't big brain yourself into no longer being an animal except through an extreme and maladaptive level of dissociation.
And I reckon that doing breathing exercises doesn't make you feel any better about having to saw off your leg either. And even if it did, why.
So a lot of my medical fear is that "animal-with-its-leg-in-a-trap" desperate biting clawing fear, a visceral certainty of unbearable harm and violation to the body, and that fear lives in me, in the deepest parts of my body and mind. There is a deep foundation of unsafety that my body learned from trauma.
So, my theory is that attempting to stop the physiological processes of fear does not work as a "coping skill" because it is suppressing a primal instinct that is foundational to the safety of the self.
In fact, I think that breathing exercises may be somewhat triggering to me at this point in my life because they activate the memory of feeling not allowed to be safe, not allowed to feel, not allowed to defend my body from harm. The Wolf fights me when I try to control my own breathing because she exists to protect me and she feels that I am preventing her from doing that.
In the years since I began unlearning the mainstream view and re-learning the animal self, my "anxiety" has been much less disruptive and paralyzing. But it goes completely opposite and contrary to everything I was ever taught and I'm trying to figure out how to work with that.
Why does it work to hand over control to the Wolf when getting my flu shot? Well, my fear exists to protect me, and in a strange way, her watchfulness and readiness to defend when I am in a vulnerable situation is reassuring. It's kind of an assurance that if the fear gets to be too much for me to be comfortable, she'll know what to do. And after the flu shot, the Wolf gets to feel that she successfully kept me safe.
I'm trying to apply this philosophy to going to get a blood draw (a higher stress experience associated with some trauma) but most of the resources or advice I would find online completely contradicts everything I've been doing.



















